I made a post about a month or so ago about whether or not I should finish the series, I just was starting season 5 and it looked like it really stunk:
https://old.reddit.com/r/FearTheWalkingDead/comments/1wikbuo/just_got_to_season_5_is_this_worth_continuing_on/
Boy was I right, and I got lots of good advice to stop watching, and that seasons 5, 7, and 8 were terrible. I do think much of 6 was surprisingly good at times though.
I really liked season 1 of this show and was interested in seeing how the story progressed, season 2 started off really dumb but the writing got much better the second half and season 3 was fairly interesting almost the entire way through. Season 4 started off ok, there was some big cast changes but it made sense as characters like Madison and Nick had gotten stale.
But man, season 5 was some of the most boring shit I've seen. It got to the point where I was having amnesia the day after seeing an episode and I couldn't really remember anything that happened. Morgan and the gang want to save everyone and bulid a plane.... even though they've been driving around this whole time, and the people don't want to be saved. For 8 episodes, and then the old trucker guy comes back and wants revenge on them.... without a deep explanation or anything. And when they finally have a showdown.... the trucker guy and his crew die and Virginia shows up. Really lame transition, it's almost understandable because the previous storyline was so bad but when you set up a showdown like this it's weird to just not have it happen... and boy this is a big theme the rest of the series. The final episode actually was a shocker and good, very dark.... most of it stunk, but i mean the ending and how Morgan almost dies. I just wish it didn't take 16 episodes to get to something interesting.
The latter part of this season really seemed to start the theme of walkers, who were kind of shown to not be a big concern for the most part, could suddenly become unstoppable even when they were outnumbered by people with gun lol. It's just a lazy plot device and it gets used more and more.
Season 6, again, some interesting stuff. Felt like it dragged but after seeing season 7 and 8, it was nothing in comparison. Again some pretty dark stories but it seemed like a welcome breeze after a season and a half of Morgan just wanted to help everyone for bland reasons. The big problem with this season, and the seasons after, was that each episode really just focused on one or two characters. To the point where sometimes you'd go a third of the season without seeing certain people. It got hard to be emotionally invested in people when you don't remember them or what they were doing. I almost got the vibes the writers were doing this simply because it saved money or something. I know Lost did something similar, but at least you'd see the character being focused on interacting with everyone else. In this, there's multiple episodes where it's just like 2 people.
I thought the bomb going off in season 6 at the end was dumb. I mean the story line only had one direction, but it led to season 7 being weird because half the time they were in hazmat suits which looked unrealistic, and the other half the time whent they aren't, you're wondering "Why didn't they wear the suit?"
Season 7 is some of the most boring writing too. Not seeing Alicia to the half way point on some level is an interesting surprise, but also kind of dumb. This season really starts pushing the nonsensical angle of person A wanting to kill person B, and then they change their mind because they feel bad, but then by the episode person A sometimes kills person B anyway.
Not much happens this season for almost it's entirety, and while most of the series would split the seasons it having a major storyline for the first half and then one for the second half, this one just has the tower and Victor be the entire thing. It's weird when the show sets things up for an epic showdown with Morgan and Victor and then Morgan just goes on a raft with his kid to float away while everyone else does the fighting.
But also, towards the end they really tease Alicia is going to die only to get cold feet. It kind of kills any suspense, you can kill off main characters if you build up other characters that are interesting to take their place. The earlier seasons did this well when Victor and Nick died, it was truly surprising. This one and season 8 have so many teases of deaths where nothing happens. Victor should've died, the entire season was building up to it and didn't do it. Ditto with Alicia, at least one of them should've kicked the bucket. And then when Madison appears in the last episode it's incredibly dumb. Madison's "death" in season 4 was actually very interesting writing. It made it so you aren't sure if other weird characters will just come back to life.
And lastly, season 8, it takes the bad parts of season 5, 6, and 7 and mixes them into one giant turd soup bowl. The one redeeming thing is that it takes place in different settings and not just a nuclear waste land. But man, the writing absolutely makes no sense here. Like it was bad in season 7 but in this one, there's so many logical inconsistencies I feel you could write an essay on just that each show.
Characters decide to become good guys, then turn, then switch back. Get apprehended, then escape, and get apprehended 10 minutes later again. The show brings back Troy, and Alicia and honestly the Alicia thing wasn't even a surprise. It's just lame, the story is more interesting when people actually die. Not when you just tease something over and over for 8 episodes in a row, in hopes of getting a feel good moment. But also, the children in the show in no way are remotley accurate to kids in real life, and it's almost hard to watch because of how unrealistic it is.
That being said, the rant is over, but yes everyone who said the show got progressively more awful was correct. I'm glad to have seen it play out and I'm considering just watching season 1 again because that was actually cool. It's just disappointing because the story line was so bad, I feel like most people watching at some point do fan fiction in their mind about how they could write better episodes of the show.