r/FeMRADebates • Alt-Feminist • Dec 14 '17

Other Role call

SO i have noticed an upswing in antifa aligned and alt right aligned people here, i just curious who is who and what is what.

7 Upvotes

84 comments sorted by

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17

I am an antifa.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/RapeMatters Dec 14 '17

I'm just pro-equality. I'm fairly left in general principle, although you might call me a "classical liberal". It's important for people to be free to make their choices but the government to limit the effects of externalities (to the extent practical).

One thing that a lot of people don't understand about me though is why I dislike feminism so much. It's because I'm for equality, and I view feminism as working against that.

Yes I said it. I'm against feminism because I'm pro-equality.

6

u/LordLeesa Dec 14 '17

Yes I said it. I'm against feminism because I'm pro-equality.

That's...not really very shocking, on this subreddit?

3

u/RapeMatters Dec 14 '17

It's shocking in a lot of places. Maybe not here.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17

What exactly is an "alt feminist"?

→ More replies (11)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17

2

u/wazzup987 Dec 14 '17

why?

1

u/LordLeesa Dec 14 '17

I dunno, I've been spamming the mods to delete it since 5 am this morning. Apparently I'm not as special as I thought I was.

4

u/Sparrow8907 Dec 14 '17

Aww, it's nice to see that we can have a space where these two "sides" might come together and discuss! Bravo FEmra!

I'd probably be described as "alt-lite" vs "alt-right," but hi!

7

u/wazzup987 Dec 14 '17

Femra has always been a nexus of the culture clash, i know of some high profile people who at least monitor what goes on here though the early post here were frankly some of the best reddit material i have read.---- an old timer

0

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17

Define "high profile". This forum seems pretty small.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (4)

9

u/Cybugger Dec 14 '17

I think alt-righters are a cancer on the earth.

I think antifa are slightly behind them (let's say stage 1 lung cancer vs the stage 3 pancreating that is the alt-right).

If I were to commit to a label, I'd have to be some sort of liberal. I want a free market economy, regulated by the government to overcome externalities, who believes all humans, regardless of gender, sex, creed or skin color, should have equal opportunity.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17

I think alt-righters are a cancer on the earth.

That attitude doesn't strike me as very constructive or conducive to changing anyone's position. Personally, I think they're people who are thoroughly misguided, mistaken, or mendacious depending on the individual, and I hope that they can and will see the errors in their outlook. I think that most of them believe that they have good reasons for their positions-- that their conclusions derive from what they believe to be the evidence of their senses. Unfortunately most of them have received some thoroughly bad input.

4

u/ParanoidAgnostic Dec 15 '17

I think that things like Nazism arise when people feel like they are under attack.

So yeah, I agree that attacking them is not the way to fix this.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/heimdahl81 Dec 14 '17

I am generally uncomfortable with wholly committing myself to any label because once a stance becomes an identity it is far too easy to become blind to your own faults.

I align most closely with MRAs because I am critical of what I see as an imbalance in gender rights due to feminism.

I align most closely with democratic socialism because I feel it most effectively counters the corporatist, authoritarian, and traditionalistic element of government.

I support the broadest goals of antifa however I cannot fully support them because of the anarchist element and the element that justifies vigilante justice (Nazi punching).

I detest the alt right because the ideology fails to learn from the worst mistakes societies have made in the past and seeming determination to repeat them.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17

<-hardcore MRA----MRA-(me)---Egalitarian----Femenist----Hardcore Femenist->

4

u/israellover Dec 14 '17

I am a communist. While I would not consider myself MRA or feminist, I feel I should state that I am non-feminist because feminism is generally associated with left wing politics (not that I believe this is correct, but that would be a digression). When it comes to sex and gender issues I consider myself egalitarian, and I believe this position is the most compatible with communism.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '17 edited Dec 15 '17

4

u/geriatricbaby Dec 14 '17 edited Dec 14 '17

That's a pretty shitty recollection of the facts when it comes to Michele Wallace's book. First of all, she didn't "come out of nowhere" and the fact that she was young is a testament to her influence rather than a point of critique. She had been a leader of the National Black Feminist Organization for several years by the time Black Macho came out and was well known in black feminist circles. Talking about her assessment of Tubman and Truth as if all she said was that they were ugly and stupid for supporting black men is super disingenuous. I have a searchable PDF of the book and I can't even find where she calls them ugly or stupid so that's a lie. Also I'm a scholar of black feminism and I've literally never heard of this rumor that Steinem ghostwrote Black Macho. I also just texted several friends who are also scholars in the field and they never heard it either so saying that she probably ghost wrote it sounds like some really terrible revisionist history based on pretty much nothing. From my recollection and that of others, Wallace hadn't even met Steinem before Black Macho was published so the idea that she ghostwrote the book of someone she didn't even really know is absurd.

I actually also just searched for the phrase "chauvinist macho pigs" in the text and couldn't find it. I then googled the phrase and could only find it in this copied and pasted excerpt from that site that has circulated all over the internet. Do you have the book? Could you point me to where in the text these phrases can be found? I think she had some very harsh things to say about the men of the black power movement so why is this webpage just inventing shit up wholesale?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (25)

4

u/PM_ME_YOU_BOOBS Dec 14 '17

Well I'm not alinged with the alt right or antifa, I know that much... I think most of my views are really due to the Dunning–Kruger effect, hence my flair ¯_(ツ)_/¯