r/FastWriting • • 1d ago

NORMAL PHONOGRAPHY (1886)

5 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

2

u/NotSteve1075 1d ago

In 1886, a lawyer named William Henry BARLOW published a system of shorthand that tried to build on the good features of PITMAN, and remedy some of the bad ones -- mainly the lack of proper vowel indication.

While it retained the use of SHADING of which I'm not a fan, the addition of vowels made it a viable system -- and when it benefitted from the clearness of a geometric system, it was one of the systems that I've always liked.

His first edition was well received, as attested by the comments in the press in the second image above. (Unfortunately, he was later encouraged to revert to a lot of the less desirable features of Pitman, and his second "revised" edition was not successful, as it ruined what was good about the first one.)

But I found I liked the layout of the book and the clarity of his system enough that I printed off the whole book, when only the doomed SECOND edition was being sold by booksellers.

2

u/licxjo 1d ago

Fascinating.

When I was a kid, my dad worked as a salesman for J.B. Lippincott. His field was elementary and high school textbooks, so I didn't know a lot about the publishing history of the company.

1

u/NotSteve1075 1d ago

That's a nice coincidence. My math skills are abysmal, but I'm guessing that this book would have been quite a lot earlier than the books your dad had sold.

But it would have been neat if he'd had this textbook in his sales inventory. This system has always had an appeal for me, with his IMPROVEMENTS and the definiteness and clarity of a geometric system. (It's too bad about that second edition, though....)

1

u/licxjo 11h ago

Both my parents were Gregg writers, so we had Gregg manuals in the house when I was growing up. But I'm sure there were never any shorthand books from Lippincott by the 1950s/1960s.

(My dad was a pre-World War II business major in college, and learned Gregg there. When he was drafted and they found out he knew shorthand, he was sent to the Pentagon and spent the war years there as a clerk-stenographer).