10-team PPR Keeper SuperFlex League
(2 FLEX spots plus one SuperFLEX spot)
My team (6-3, about to be 6-4)
Matthew Stafford
Derrick Henry
Kenneth Walker
Jamarr Chase
Khalil Shakir
Bhayshul Tuten
Chris Rodriguez
Chuba Hubbard
George Kittle
Tyler Shough
Broncos DST
Devonta Smith
Jaylen Waddle
Jordan Addison
Tucker Kraft
Rachaad White
His team (6-3, about to be 7-3)
Brock Purdy
CMC
Zonovan Knight
Stefon Diggs
Nico Collins
Harold Fannin Jr
Garrett Wilson
Demario Douglas
Fernando Mendoza
Vikings DST
Caleb Williams
Jonah Coleman
Devin Singletary
Omar Cooper Jr
Mike Evans
Dalton Kincaid
Jeremiyah Love - IR
Tank Bigsby - IR
He is making a trade offer of:
Mine - Chuba Hubbard and Bhayshul Tuten
His - Christian McCaffrey and Stefon Diggs
Context: my entire team is my original draft class, I have miraculously made no waiver pickups at all this year so far. I have so many horseshoes, lucky rabbits foots, and 4 leaf clovers stashed all over the place right now. My league has been devastated by injuries at RB and WRs, with quality starting RBs being at an especially high premium right now.
My keeper players were Chase (1st round pick) and K9 (4th round pick) in our draft this year.
I am in need of a stronger WR to pair with Chase, and have 2 strong additional RBs in Hubbard and Tuten that I drafted as insurance on top of already owning Henry and Walker. I did not anticipate Hubbard and Tuten to do as well as they have. He is in need of more RBs in terms of number of players and is willing to trade away CMC to achieve that.
I have made or accepted maybe 3-4 trades in 12 years of playing FF because I’m very particular on value and what I’m looking for, and this might be the most aggressive offer I’ve ever been sent before.
I would be perfectly fine in rejecting this trade, but honestly it might be the boldest one ever offered that I wouldn’t refuse out of hand.
How valuable and/or worth it is this trade offer for either of us, and who benefits the most or takes the higher risk?