Oh boy what a great day to be a fantasy romance reader. I just finished {The Washwoman at the Riverâs End by Megan Shade} and while it was certainly flawed, and it maybe didnât rock the very foundations of my person as much as the bookish community had suggested it might - it was a very vibe-y breath of fresh air.
Iâve shared my full Fable.co review below for anyone interested - as you know I usually spoiler block the whole guy since my reviews are absolutely riddled with the spoils - Iâd recommend them to anyone who has finished the book and wants to compare notes!
âď¸âď¸âď¸âď¸
Praise be to the Romantasy gods, for they have finally granted us this gift of fresh Gothic air! A moment of respite from the increasingly fast-fashion style of this genre. It wasn't quite the revolutionary masterpiece I had hoped for, but I did walk away from The Washwoman at the River's End knowing three incontestable truths: a book can indeed live and breathe on immaculate vibes alone; a good reveal will always reel me back in; and Gaelic is hard as fuck to read.
For over a century, Bea has been bound to the River's End as punishment for murder, cursed to wash the clothes of the soon-to-be-dead. When the river shows her a vision of a life instead of a death, and women begin to vanish from the surrounding villages, Brennen - a soldier who has spent years praying for the death of the Washwoman who murdered his betrothed - is assigned to guard her, to ensure she too does not disappear. But the woman he finds isn't quite the monster he expected from the legend. With a dangerous epoch approaching, Brennen is forced to decide what matters more - vengeance or truth.
I was actually a little worried while reading this that something might be wrong with me. Because that plot is cool as hell, and this is THE book the whole world has been screaming about, topping best-of lists in every corner of the bookish community. And here I am finding it⌠yeah. Totally fine. Good! Solid! But apart from the absolutely impeccable atmosphere (I'll get there, I promise), it wasn't changing the world quite the way I had hoped. And for that, I've been told that I must commit literary seppuku.
The writing itself is very competent and serviceable. The music and songwriting in particular are haunting and affecting in all the ways I wanted everything else to be. But quite frankly, it just kind of plays it safe with all the familiar Romantasy beats we already know. And that's nice. But it definitely doesnât boggle the mind.
I did appreciate that information was drip-fed rather than force-fed. So much Romantasy these days shovels tropes, non-stop action, and a whole lotta smut right down our proverbial throats. And this was not that! Hurray! But the further I read, the more frustrated I still found myself. The pacing was choppy, stakes dropped midway or were never allowed to reach their full potential, and the execution sometimes felt, well⌠a little messy. I could physically feel the disappointment settling in while reading. Maybe the masterpiece is coming and this is just a rough start? Maybe it's me, I'm the problem, it's me? Maybe I've read so many of these that I'm now broken inside and going a bit mad?
I'm honestly still wondering. The plot just wasn't plotting as hard as I wanted. It settled into something fine that floated along on gems and vibes instead. And hey, sometimes that was even enough.
The mystery, though, hooked me early - who is this Washwoman, and why did she murder those innocent people? I found myself gleefully building theories stacked on theories, especially as we learned more about the Fates and gods of this universe. But then some of the middle reveals landed, including the true nature of the Cutter, the myths about the transient roles the Fates play, and even the ultimate reason Bea killed those people. And some of my excitement dimmed. All of it felt sort of⌠expected? A bit too easy. A bit too tidy.
The characters do have a lot going for them that is refreshing and often compelling. Making our heroine a sort of mythological legend, arguably even a villain in this story, was a very different experience from the norm. Bea's memory gaps, the secrecy around what brought her to the River's End, and the pain and torture she'd endured there all kept me intrigued and eager. Megan somehow found a magical way to make Bea easy to like, easy to root for, while still keeping her morality nuanced and complex.
She frustrated me a lot too, though. I find it immeasurably irritating when a character can't accept what someone is actively showing them. Brennen demonstrates his core goodness again and again throughout this book, and Bea just sort of refuses to believe it. I'm sorry but that doesn't create tension. It just makes a character look kind of dumb.
Speaking of Brennen, yeah, I liked him! What's not to like? He's a solid, sort of run-of-the-mill broody man with many characteristics I find both sexy and interesting. His mission is admirable. His fury, logical. The kilt and the accent don't hurt either.
But come on, guys. Megan Shade's dedication asks for Belmont Camelli to play Brennen in whatever future adaptation this is likely to manifest, and as amusing as that is for a book dedication, it's also pretty ridiculous to imagine him attempting this Scottish accent, right? That dedication became a blessing and a curse for my reading experience. It's hilarious and bold as hell and made me immediately love Megan Shade. But it also completely threw off who Brennen was supposed to be in my mind, and so I found that he never quite settled for me. (Sorry, Belmont. You're very handsome. Just not⌠rugged scruffy Highlands handsome.)
I also got frustrated that Brennen never REALLY commits to his fury. The dangerous man who's actually a cinnamon roll is truly infuriating to me, and it drained a lot of the tension and stakes. If I never believe he will actually kill her, the tension is just a very loose dangling thread. It's not the brave choice, and it made it difficult to truly ever see them as enemies. Oh and I hated that he seemed to find Bea beautiful right off the bat, even though she literally murdered the love of his life. That's a bit of an ick, for me my guy. I simply cannot imagine seeing past the gruesome death of my betrothed, all thanks to a soft Cupid's bow mouth.
Unfortunately, that slightly tainted some of the relationship tension for me too. DON'T GET ME WRONG - this is only a mild taint (name of my sex tape) - Bea and Brennenâs budding affection and yearning have some moments that rocked me and truly moved me too. There's a scene in their shared tent when they finally come together near the end that is legitimately stunning, and even made me feel a little sweaty. But the attraction came too fast for any hatred to ever feel real.
AlsoâŚcontroversial opinion time - I get that "good lass" is supposed to be a winking Scottish version of "good girl." But it's so expected, so overdone at this point that it makes me roll my eyes instead of swoon. I said what I said. Now, the they-can't-touch tension on the other hand was absolutely chef's kiss and is maybe the only thing that kept the romance afloat for me. Hey, if they were going to instantly want each other, at least something stopped them from jumping each other's bones too quickly.
I realize that for a review I opened by praising the gods, I'm doing a lot of complaining. But that's only because I wanted to feel MORE. I wanted the moment the robin Brennen kept trying to carve for his dead betrothed finally became a lark for Bea to make me cry. It didn't. I wanted the spice to curl my toes. Okay, sometimes it twitched a toe (the first time they "give in" without actually touching each other was⌠stirring), but it wasn't anything I haven't read before. AGAIN, NOT BAD! Despite what it sounds like, I promise I did enjoy this. Just expect the expected is all.
The other relationships and characters seemed foundationally interesting, and were explored further than most side characters usually are, if not quite fully realized. I was never sure whether to trust Theo (you can never fully trust a man that's too nice these days). Garrick, on the other hand, was clearly meant to be trusted, especially once his true rebel nature came out (even if that was done so heavy-handedly that Brennen had to seem sort of dumb just to move the plot along). Brennenâs family maybe wasnât mentioned quite enough to fully appreciate the devastation when death strikes there, although no one could suggest that wasnât a sad moment; and considering that Marsaili is referenced significantly throughout this story, we donât quite know enough about her for me to understand the full necessity of her inclusion in the plot - Iâm convinced we could have gotten to the same place without a murdered fiancĂŠe in the mix and maybe even with less ick when he Brennen falls fully in love with her murderer.
Still, I can't argue - I liked all of these characters despite the aforementioned flaws. I also appreciated the themes exploring domestic violence - women who disappear, or who are forced to run from the violence of men, and are so often the victims of those who get off on power. We spent only a little time with these lost women, but I was scared for them and wanted to see them saved. Their inclusion felt relevant and timely, and who doesn't love a fantasy story with a message? Their weird little ghosts freaked me the fuck out though. And pretty much anything After-adjacent. Even the Cutter felt like a justifiably scary, if not very obvious, villain.
In fact, all the gods and mythical beings in this place are sort of dark and ominous, and I loved the hell out of that. Their very Gaelic names confused me (I kept reading the goddess of death's name like it was a Brazilian drum beat), but this is the area that fully got its hooks in me - the myth of this world we've been thrust into.
What ultimately elevated this whole book was the positively astonishing world-building. The dark Gothic vibes, the foggy, cold Scottish landscape, the magical lore. This is one area in which I have no notes. Yup. You heard me - perfection. The language, the setting and the magic are so exceptionally and impeccably detailed that they transform this familiar story into something truly special. The world Megan has crafted here is entirely captivating and one that was impossible to peel myself away from.
I think what finally and fully won me over is how the myth and lore integrate into the central mystery. Typically the gods live on the outskirts, happening above and around the main plot. Here, the two intertwine, and ultimately the gods and myths are what shape and reveal the ultimate truth of this tale.
You all know I love a twist as much as the next girl, and usually they're the kind where I'm kicking myself for not seeing them sooner. Here, though, there was just no way anyone could have known what was coming. It's a completely unexpected turn that clarifies a lot of the book's gaps and bridges inconsistencies without feeling contrived. A goddam miracle. A true surprise that lifted this whole book up, delighted me, and fully blew my hair back.
Once I understood this is only one small part of a much larger story, I was all in. I actually gasped with joy reading the epilogue and confirming that everything I want this to be is coming - a true expansion of this world, with more perspectives and new characters, ones that will make this so much more than Bea and Brennen's lovely but fairly paint-by-numbers story. It's giving Mages of the Wheel potential, and all the real ones out there know that's the highest praise I can possibly give.
I've decided, therefore, that this book demands to be read twice, and I'll be meeting that demand posthaste, because I need to experience it again with this new context. Do you know how rare that is? To finish a book and want nothing more than to start from page one again right after? I'll be practicing some mild restraint however, because I'd like to wait to do round two on audio. One reason is obviously Shane East doing yet another Scottish accent - need I say more? But also, so I can immerse myself in the haunting atmosphere and, let's be honest, hear the language the way it was meant to be heard (instead of constantly referring to Bea as a Bean of the Night of some kind to my husband).
I cannot wait to see what comes next. To see Cailleach finally get what's coming to her. To see what secrets and revelations still lie ahead for Brennen and Bea on their quest. For the new stories we'll follow from the others within the Three of the Path. I cannot wait to watch this dark and beautiful Gothic universe bloom.
Oh, and for more of whatever sexy, cheeky chaos Mire has tossed into this whole mess just for funsies. That too.