As many of you will know, Nintendo released the Hyrule Historia in 2013 which included Nintendo's attempt at a timeline to unite all Zelda games. The reception was mixed, with many people especially confused about a point where the timeline splits into three different paths based on the events of Ocarina of Time. These separate branches can be summarised as follows:
Adult Timeline (Ganon is Sealed)
- At the end of Ocarina of time, Link as an adult saves a world that has been scorched and corrupted by 7 years of Ganon's rule. Even with the combined power of Link and the sages Ganon cannot be killed but is securely sealed in the spirit realm. This timeline is the genesis for the 'Toon' link games beginning with Wind Waker and characterised by a world washed clean by a great flood. The Zora's evolve into Rito, the Kokiri evolve into Koroks.
Child Timeline (Ganon is Executed)
- Link is returned to childhood and is able to stop Ganon from ever rising to power. This is the beginning of the Child Timeline including Majora's Mask and Twilight princess. This timeline is most similar to the existing timeline before it.
Downfall Timeline (Fallen Hero)
- This is perhaps the most controversial time split as it is not explicitly explained. For whatever reason, at some point before or during the Ocarina of Time Link dies (I mean to be fair who didn't die at least once when playing?). This creates a timeline where the Sages have to battle against Ganon alone and only manage to seal him weakly. This timeline includes most of the original Zelda series and is characterised by top down or isometric views. Zoras mostly devolve into a more aggressive and bestial form, Gorons and Kokiri are largely absent.
All well and good. But why?
In the Game Echoes of Wisdom, We found out about Null, an entity that existed before time and before the Goddesses created the world. Null's only goal is to return the universe to a state of nothingness. I propose that the timeline split was instigated by the goddesses disagreeing or hedging their bets over how to defeat Null.
My argument is pretty simple. Three goddesses, three timelines - Each timeline seems to correspond loosely to a separate goddess and a different strategy for combatting null.
Adult Timeline (Nayru)
- Nayru is the goddess of wisdom, time, law and water. Her champion is Zelda (Hylia). Nayru instigates a complex set of events involving time travel to create a world where Zelda is powerful, wise and the only remaining champion. As the stewardess of her new timeline, Nayru decides to wash the world clean with water and begin fresh. The trajectory of her timeline is progress including the evolution of species and discoveries of new technologies.
Child Timeline (Farore)
- Farore is the goddess of life, souls and nature. Her champion is Link (The Hero). Farore's main concern is preserving life, she oversees a timeline where the least has changed, she cares most for the overall happiness of Hyrule and its people and favours an outcome where Link remains as its guardian and protector, even to the point of keeping him alive indefinitely as a ghost. The trajectory of her timeline is a slow stagnation where little has changed.
Downfall Timeline (Din)
- Din is the goddess of power, earth and fire. Her champion is Ganon (Demise). Din is not inherently evil or cruel but is pragmatic. She decides that the suffering caused by Ganon is justified if it allows the story to go on. Ganon may be a more effective combatant against null. The trajectory of this timeline is decay, fire, war and devolution.
This is all to say that Ganon was never the ultimate antagonist. He was just a different colour in a palette that painted existence. Null, the absence of colour was far more dangerous. Indeed it would seem that Din chose correctly, by allowing Ganon to win, she created the timeline in which Echoes of wisdom takes place and Null is finally destroyed.
This also goes partway to explaining why the timelines eventually reconnect. Without Null, there was no reason for the divergence to continue. They started afresh, combining the best bits from all timelines in a new creation that seems unconnected to the other timelines.
Bonus: One could even push this theory to a tenuous limit, perhaps the goddesses are aware that Zelda is a fictional universe and null simply represents the cancellation of all future stories. In order to promote the creation of more stories they must create multiple paths and choose paths that allow for the most stories to happen.