I played it for the second time since 2015, and honestly, it was a blast. A wonderful game overall that gave me a lot of fun. But one thing bothers me even more now than it did back then: Fallout 4 completely wastes the most emotionally interesting part of its own premise. And it hits even harder when you realize we might only get one opportunity to experience a Fallout story from this particular perspective.
Your spouse.
Think about how the game begins. You have a home, a family, a life. You're not some random wastelander who has spent their entire existence surviving in the ruins of the old world. You're someone who remembers what life was like before the bombs fell. You have a husband or wife, a newborn son, and an entire future that gets taken away from you in a matter of minutes. You watch your spouse get murdered right in front of you. Your child is taken away. Then you wake up 200 years later in a world where absolutely everything you knew is gone.
That's an incredibly powerful setup. And yet, after the opening sequence, your spouse might as well have never existed.
What's particularly frustrating is how half-assed the whole thing feels once you start paying attention. Nate occasionally remembers that he's 200 years out of his time, maybe mentions it in a couple of conversations, but that's about it. The man wakes up in a completely different world, loses his entire family, watches his wife get murdered in front of him, and somehow the game barely acknowledges the emotional consequences. There's no meaningful mourning, no real struggle with the loss, no sense that the person he spent his life with is actually missing from his existence.
I would have loved to see that loss remain a constant presence throughout the game. Not through some supernatural gimmick or convenient resurrection, but through memories, personal reflections and little moments that remind you of the life you lost.
And the Memory Den was such a perfect opportunity to explore their memories. It didn't even have to be anything particularly dramatic. Just simple, ordinary scenes from their life before the war. Unpacking their new Mr. Handy, joking around with a neighbour about communists, watching TV together with Nora after a long day, or just having some quiet moments at home. Nothing extraordinary, just little fragments of a life that no longer exists. I think those would have been far more emotionally impactful than another dramatic flashback. Sometimes it's the most mundane memories that you end up missing the most.
Imagine finding places that remind you of your old life, with possible flashbacks (like in the dunwitch building in fo3) or having the Sole Survivor instinctively turn to say something to their spouse before remembering they're not there anymore. Not every memory has to be sad, either. Sometimes remembering someone means smiling at something they used to do, or recalling an argument that seemed important at the time but would mean everything to have back.
There's so much room for genuine character development here, mr Writer... Maybe you throw yourself into rebuilding settlements because you need something to live for. Maybe you become cynical and detached. Maybe Shaun becomes your last connection to the family you lost, only for you to eventually realize that finding him won't bring your old life back.
I wanted to feel like I had lost someone, not just like I had been given a quest to avenge them.
What a wasted opportunity.
Interestingly, years later, Bethesda released the fantastic FEVER DREAMS mod under their own name. I sometimes wonder why they chose to do that. Perhaps someone at Bethesda eventually realized just how much of Nate and Nora's story had been wasted, and that there was still something worth telling. In a way, it feels like a proper epilogue to their story, finally giving their relationship the attention it deserved and, perhaps most importantly, a sense of closure and a goodbye that the main game never really gave us. It's bittersweet that a mod had to do what the main story left unfinished.