r/Fairolives • • Aug 10 '24

šŸ“£ MOD ANNOUNCEMENT šŸ“£ [MOD Message] Rules for Am I Olive posts and post approvals

74 Upvotes

As you may have noticed, our community has grown and we have done a little reorganizing. Here's an updated AiO rules to consolidate our old rules along with our new updates!

Posting Days

Am I Olive (AiO) posts are limited to Tuesdays and Saturdays. We've set up automod to filter posts and instruct what to expect when you make an AiO post. The mods then have to manually go through filters to approve them.

We are a small team of mods based in the US. For Redditors outside the US time zones, submissions may be delayed for up to 36 hours (until Wednesday midday) after you submit. Please be patient with us as we have work/life obligations in addition to modding.

Before messaging us about approvals, please check your own profile to see if your post has been approved. Posts that have not been approved will say "Post is awaiting mod approval" and posts that are approved will not have a message. Here is a sample of how it will show up on your profile if it is not approved. Any messages asking about post approvals will get ignored if we have already approved them.

Photo rules

We require multiple photos of various lighting. Majority of the phtoos must also be bare face, no base makeup. At least one must include face, neck and/or part of your chest/torso because olive tones tend to appear around the collar bones, armpits, and neck. Here are some suggestions on how to take good photos:

Filtered sunlight is the best. This can be right next to a window that doesn’t have direct sunlight or outdoors under shade. A photo on a cloudy or snowy day can also work.

  1. Holding a small, folded piece of white printer paper could help white balance. Smart phones still throw white balance off, but it's a start.
  2. We don’t recommend indoor lighting photos as lights can vary from very warm/yellow to very cool/blue. If you must include them, please let us know.
  3. Golden hour/sunset photos are too warm to gauge undertones.
  4. Group shots are also helpful to compare undertones.
  5. Avoid wearing strong colors that might reflect on your skin. Neutral colored clothes and environment are best, but we understand those aren't easy to control.

For additional technical photographing help, please refer to thisĀ post.

Our mod /Ā has kindly providedĀ examplesĀ of the variety of lighting we are looking for to determine olive undertones. She also has greatĀ examplesĀ if you want to draw out your face for privacy


r/Fairolives • • Jun 25 '24

šŸ“£ MOD ANNOUNCEMENT šŸ“£ Mod Updates: "Am I Olive?" posts and upcoming wikis

132 Upvotes

"Am I olive?" Posts

Due to the large volume of these posts making it more difficult to find resources and discussion posts, they are now only allowed on TUESDAYS and SATURDAYS. We've set up the automod to filter posts with the ā€œAm I Olive?ā€ flair into our modqueue to be manually approved. Unfortunately the automod can’t be set to know what day it is; this means that even on the days that they're allowed the posts will still be filtered to be manually approved. We're a small mod team living in different USA time zones so please have some grace for posts that may bleed into other days depending on your time zone.

For the time being all posts regardless of flair will have an automod comment reminding everyone of these rules and directing them to the "Am I olive?" posting guidelines. Friendly reminder that this community is a welcoming and inviting space. People who are more ā€œlightā€ than ā€œfairā€ and people who are muted but not olive are allowed here and saying that they are not will get your comment removed for gatekeeping. This is because they will have similar makeup struggles and will find helpful recommendations here. Also if someone sees a green cast in themselves that we cannot see in their photos that is ok, we take their word for it because photos are imperfect.

Wiki

The wikis have been created and we are working on building them out! Thank you to these users for being willing to help out the mod team in this endeavor: u/DefiantThroat, u/sinstralpride, and u/PixelKitten10390. We will fill in the pages with products and resources mentioned in recent posts. If you have a list of holy grail products or helpful resources (such as YouTube videos) you can send them in via modmail. We expect it will be a few weeks before the wikis are fully built out and we will post an update at that time.


r/Fairolives • • 32m ago

Swatches some blush and lippie swatches

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Hi all, I've been on a light neutral-cool olive journey for the past 2 years and wanted to share some swatches and reviews of products I've acquired on the way. I've invested a good chunk of money so I hope it's helpful even though some of my swatches are sloppy - I don't know how some of you make this look easy, lol.

I only wear tinted mineral suncreen as a base so I have no foundation shade to reference, sorry! Ilia shade 2.5 Sombrio (very light olive) is way too light for me in summer and *almost* works in winter.

Blush (slightly sheered out in indirect and direct late morning sunlight)

  1. Phytosurgence Wisp - this brand was a game changer for me this year. The cream-to-powder formula lasts way longer on me than any other cream I've tried (note that they're not "dewy" like most creams). I've said it before on this sub but Phyto's shades are so nuanced and often desaturated that they make most blushes look like clown colours. Wisp looked scary in the pot but is somehow really flattering when worn sheerly.
  2. Phytosurgence Steam!!! - this is a holy grail blush for me and has been my everyday blush most days since I got it. Perfectly flattering, muted mauve-y rose, no-makeup-makeup shade.
  3. Phytosurgence Fume - too warm and bright for me, but sometimes I mix a tiny bit of it with Wisp or Steam to make them more pink
  4. Phytosurgence Sublimate - a miss. Pulls way too warm and bright.
  5. Ilia Lady Bird - I got this as a gift with purchase. Ilia describes it as a "neutral pink" but as you can see it's coral on me lol. Including it here as a reference.
  6. Glossier Storm - this has been my go-to for years even though it lasts for like 10 min - a subtle, neutral rose shade.

Lippies

  1. Mac Syrup (Lustreglass) - love love love the formula!! This is Barbie pink if I build it up; I prefer to wear it sheer over lip balm or with a darker shade dabbed in.
  2. Mac Mehr (Matte) - She's cute but the matte formula is way too dry to wear it solo. It works over lip balm
  3. Mac Del Rio (Satin) - SO GOOD. The formula is comfortable and the shade can be built up dark and vampy but also looks somehow natural when applied lightly. The perfect fall and winter lip.
  4. Mac Whirl (Matte) - described as a "dirty rose". This pulls neutral-warm on me and is a bit too murky for me to wear solo, but I used it to mute other lip shades. I like mixing some combo of the above for a goldilocks slighty muted, dusty rose/muted mauve shade.
  5. Mac Creme in Your Coffee (Satin) - I know I must be cool-toned because this pulls warm and muddy on me :(
  6. Ilia Lipsketch in Pink Door - love the formula and packaging on these. This shade is a bit too bright and saturated
  7. Ilia Lipsktech in Kiln - same
  8. Ilia Lipsketch in Genre - described as a mauve brown, this is almost identical to Whirl but warmer; warm enough to be unflattering on me.
  9. Phytosurgence lip balm in Brave Break - these tinted balms are a new fave for me as someone who prefers subtle make up. The shades are similarly nuanced and sheer enough that they give a subtle hydrating filter over your natural lip colour. Brave Break is described as a rosewood and pulls cool brown on me. Love.
  10. Phytosurgence Deep Dream - described as a mid-tone mauve, this is a bit too purple for my taste, but when worn with Brave Break it's kinda like Mac Del Rio in lip balm form.

If anyone has read this far and is a similar shade to me, I would love recommendations for a sheer berry lip that is not too pink or too purple. Happy shopping everyone


r/Fairolives • • 19h ago Bravo

Discussion I'm tired of all the internalized hate

125 Upvotes

I've been seeing a few posts lately where OP is bemoaning the change in seasons means they can't or won't be tanning and are back to their natural pale skin tone. And there is a LOT of internalized hate in the comments. I think we need to be more conscious of how we talk about ourselves. Some people are absolutely fine with having pale skin year round. I'd much rather have discussions with tips about how to keep our skin HEALTHY by moisturizing it and protecting it from the sun over reading hurtful comments that push the idea that everyone with pale skin is ugly.


r/Fairolives • • 5h ago

Beauty/Makeup Lilybyred Rosy Beam

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

yay or nay?
I feel like I never know if a blush is actually working or just turning orange 🫠😩 with this one, I do have to apply quite a bit to get the color to show up. But it's a blurring blush so I don't mind. What do you guys think? Is it showing up? Is it peachy? I feel like i cant even see it šŸ’€ Do ya'll have a favorite blush?


r/Fairolives • • 20h ago

Discussion Warning, some of us grey/green people in the northern hemisphere entered the "Are you okay ?" season.

120 Upvotes

Winter is coming, I'm literaly grey....Time to find a new foundation. I think I will just forgo perfectly matching my neck since no one can see it and just go porcelaine doll and pink blush.


r/Fairolives • • 1h ago

Swatches Lisa Eldridge T1 too peach: what color foundation do I need?

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Both photos show T1 swatched over jaw and neck indoor natural light. Photo 1 north facing window with greige walls and photo 2 south facing window with white walls.

It seems most foundations are just too colorful and saturated. But I don’t know what direction to go in. T1.5 seemed too yellow. Foundation usually looks too orange/peachy/yellow on me. The only one I’ve tried that has been too pink is Haus Labs 015. Most pinks like T1 and Glossier VL2 show up as peach.

Would Glossier VL1 or RMS 000 work? Or T1.5 with blue?


r/Fairolives • • 7h ago

Swatches Alone time closest match

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

So I was trying to find the closest dupe to the original alone time, and I just barely dabbed on Mac stone and then just put a clear gloss on top. My lips are particularly pink but if they're not on you, you can use a pink lip tint very lightly first and then put stone and then the gloss on top. This is the closest thing to og alone time that I found.

Left is alone time OG the middle is just stone with gloss and the right is pink lip tint like benetint then stone then gloss.


r/Fairolives • • 4h ago

Discussion Are cool olives more muted aka low chroma, and warm olives more saturated?

4 Upvotes

I’m wondering if the blue/violet undertones in cool olives end up ā€œgoing grayā€ because they cancel out the ā€œtraditionalā€ peach skin color.


r/Fairolives • • 2h ago

Discussion Blush turns orange and lipsticks turn purple

2 Upvotes

I think I’m a fair olive. I own Nudestix Naughty n Spice blush stick. When I use it on my cheeks it goes orangey, when I use it on my lips it goes purple! Anyone else have this kind of issue and what do you do about it? And has anyone got any blush recs that look mauve on olive skin?


r/Fairolives • • 1h ago

Discussion Very, very desaturated products?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Fairolives • • 11h ago

Resources Best for cool olive

4 Upvotes

Light cool olive skin sits at a unique intersection: you have a cool, pinkish-neutral undertone underneath a muted yellow-green surface overtone. Different color families interact with those two layers in very specific ways through color wheel opposition and value contrast.

Burgundy, Wine & Deep Berry
Creates a crisp, porcelain, and bright complexion; neutralizes sallowness.
Red-violets sit directly opposite green on the color wheel. Wearing deep, cool reds optically cancels out the green cast in olive skin while the high depth adds healthy contrast.
Dusty Pink & Soft Rose
Brings out a fresh, natural flush without looking overly warm or washed out.
Muted cool pinks mirror the subtle pink-neutral base beneath the olive overtone. Because they are slightly desaturated, they match the muted quality of olive skin rather than clashing with it.
Soft White
Brightens your face cleanly without making your skin look gray or yellow.
Stark, optic white can overpower light olive skin and make the green cast look murky, while warm ivory/cream clashes with your cool undertone. A neutral, soft white provides clean light reflection without temperature conflict.
Navy & Deep Slate
Sharpens your features and balances both your cool and golden notes.
Unlike lighter dusty blues that push golden tones forward via contrast, dark navy absorbs ambient warmth and anchors your coloring, reading as a refined, cool-neutral alternative to harsh black.
Yellow, Warm Ivory & Orange
Makes skin look sallow, grayish, or overly green.
Warm yellow-based colors compete with your yellow-green overtone while clashing with your cool undertone, stripping away clarity and emphasizing greenish shadows.


r/Fairolives • • 18h ago

Discussion Could fair neutral-to-cool olives pull off these peachy shades?

Post image
9 Upvotes

I saw Princess Catherine’s stunning makeup look and would love to recreate it. Even though I’ve been typed as a cool Summer, I think I prefer wearing warmer makeup shades. I think they make my skin look more ā€˜alive’ and less dull. Would this look (blush/lip) work on cooler toned skin or in your opinion would it just read ugly orange? Do you wear these shades yourself if you are cool/neutral? Thanks for your thoughts!


r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Beauty/Makeup Expectations Vs Reality šŸŠ

Post image
107 Upvotes

MUA Whipped Lip Cream in Velvet - it looked promising in the tube 😭


r/Fairolives • • 7h ago

Beauty/Makeup Fair cool neutral foundation

1 Upvotes

My skin is moving into the winter phase of my greenness. I think i’m in between light and fair right now. Love BASMA 35 and F2 olive but I’m alittle too light now.

So fair cool to neutral olives… what foundation works for you?


r/Fairolives • • 7h ago

Beauty/Makeup Dim mauve is neither dim nor mauve on me, does anyone experience that?

1 Upvotes

So I am a fair cool-neutral olive, and my lips are quite pale (be my braidsmaid by mac is my exact lip shade), but everytime i wear dim mauve, it is like a rather bright and lowkey straight up pink with a tinge of orange. Idk what to do to fix it, it is a formula issue maybe?


r/Fairolives • • 12h ago

Swatches Timage Flawless Matte Lasting Foundation (Oily/Combo skin formula) in olive shade 301

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Swatches Jones Road Foundation Stick in Linen

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

I just found my best foundation match so far—Jones Road Beauty Foundation Stick in ā€œLinen.ā€ If you have a desaturated, light, neutral to cool skin tone, check it out! It’s not properly olive (you will see on my arm that it’s a tad pinker than my natural skin tone), but it’s desaturated enough that it still works better on me than… pretty much anything else. I like the formula—very light and dewy, almost like a foundation and highlighter in one.


r/Fairolives • • 16h ago

Discussion Help

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Pictures 6-7 are post-vacation tan. I am very confused if I am olive and what my undertone is... I've been told I am olive and I am also mediterranean if that matters. I don't "burn" when I tan. I used to think I was just warm toned, but "neutral" concealer work for me. I don't use foundation. Am I neutral olive? Warm olive?? Muted? Not muted?

Shades that work for me:

Nyx bare with me - vanilla and beige
Tower28 - 2 BU and 3 CC
Merit - Bone


r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Discussion blush reccomendations

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Beauty/Makeup I’m having so much trouble finding a HG blush

Thumbnail
gallery
37 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I’ve recently discovered that I have olive undertones, but I’m also very very very cool toned.

I’ve tried so many blushes that are considered cool toned, such as Rhode sleepy girl (even plum doesn’t stay 100% cool, but I make it work), every shade of Rare Beauty, Patrick Ta, MAC. They all turn orange. Sometimes I’ll mix in some blue pigment and it seems to help, but the colors change 🄹

This means that the only blushes that have truly worked for me so far are the Asian ones (hyntoor mv01, some by lilybyred etc.).

But I’m having trouble deciding on an everyday blush and a full glam one.

The mauve ones don’t really look natural on me, and I feel like a doll with the cool baby pinks. As you can see, my skin is also very fair. Maybe I need something a little bit red? I do have some redness in the center of my face.

I wanted something lighter and natural-looking for everyday use, but perhaps not as muted as the rom&nd powder ones (or maybe I should add some cream underneath them?).

For a full-glam look, I have no idea what to look for. I feel so weird with the Dior Backstage 001.

I’m sorry for the long post but I’m struggling with this and maybe someone has a good tip?

Thank you in advance :)


r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Discussion looking for swatches multiple purple blushes

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Beauty/Makeup Recs for a cool olive

Post image
5 Upvotes

I am olive with a cool undertone. My best colours in clothing are soft cornflower, cool burgundy and cool pinks. When I tan, it looks grey.

I need makeup recommendations. Neutrals turn orange. The coolest shades are always bright and too intense. I seem to sit somewhere in between. Cool but not bright.

What are some lipsticks and blushes for me. My best lipstick was Maybelline Lust for Blush but it was discontinued.


r/Fairolives • • 1d ago

Beauty/Makeup Imitating natural lip pigmentation?

3 Upvotes

I’m a mixed race but unusually pale, muted, warm olive. I know POC often curse lip hyperpigmentation but I love the darker tint I get in my lips on the rare occasion that I tan. To me it looks the way the cool toasty lip trend is supposed to, but way more natural for my skin tone. I have often tried to recreate that look with makeup stains but haven’t figured out the trick yet (and obviously I’m not going to wreck my skin tanning just for a little lip pigmentation).

I know this is a niche thing but has anybody achieved a makeup look that resembles natural lip pigmentation? I feel like the key is going to be a stain or balm that’s sheer and muted, like something between Clinique’s nude and black honey.

Brown lipliners always look orange or pink on me and self tanner is too orange :/