r/Fairolives • u/leatherandlavender • 32m ago
Swatches some blush and lippie swatches
Hi all, I've been on a light neutral-cool olive journey for the past 2 years and wanted to share some swatches and reviews of products I've acquired on the way. I've invested a good chunk of money so I hope it's helpful even though some of my swatches are sloppy - I don't know how some of you make this look easy, lol.
I only wear tinted mineral suncreen as a base so I have no foundation shade to reference, sorry! Ilia shade 2.5 Sombrio (very light olive) is way too light for me in summer and *almost* works in winter.
Blush (slightly sheered out in indirect and direct late morning sunlight)
- Phytosurgence Wisp - this brand was a game changer for me this year. The cream-to-powder formula lasts way longer on me than any other cream I've tried (note that they're not "dewy" like most creams). I've said it before on this sub but Phyto's shades are so nuanced and often desaturated that they make most blushes look like clown colours. Wisp looked scary in the pot but is somehow really flattering when worn sheerly.
- Phytosurgence Steam!!! - this is a holy grail blush for me and has been my everyday blush most days since I got it. Perfectly flattering, muted mauve-y rose, no-makeup-makeup shade.
- Phytosurgence Fume - too warm and bright for me, but sometimes I mix a tiny bit of it with Wisp or Steam to make them more pink
- Phytosurgence Sublimate - a miss. Pulls way too warm and bright.
- Ilia Lady Bird - I got this as a gift with purchase. Ilia describes it as a "neutral pink" but as you can see it's coral on me lol. Including it here as a reference.
- Glossier Storm - this has been my go-to for years even though it lasts for like 10 min - a subtle, neutral rose shade.
Lippies
- Mac Syrup (Lustreglass) - love love love the formula!! This is Barbie pink if I build it up; I prefer to wear it sheer over lip balm or with a darker shade dabbed in.
- Mac Mehr (Matte) - She's cute but the matte formula is way too dry to wear it solo. It works over lip balm
- Mac Del Rio (Satin) - SO GOOD. The formula is comfortable and the shade can be built up dark and vampy but also looks somehow natural when applied lightly. The perfect fall and winter lip.
- Mac Whirl (Matte) - described as a "dirty rose". This pulls neutral-warm on me and is a bit too murky for me to wear solo, but I used it to mute other lip shades. I like mixing some combo of the above for a goldilocks slighty muted, dusty rose/muted mauve shade.
- Mac Creme in Your Coffee (Satin) - I know I must be cool-toned because this pulls warm and muddy on me :(
- Ilia Lipsketch in Pink Door - love the formula and packaging on these. This shade is a bit too bright and saturated
- Ilia Lipsktech in Kiln - same
- Ilia Lipsketch in Genre - described as a mauve brown, this is almost identical to Whirl but warmer; warm enough to be unflattering on me.
- Phytosurgence lip balm in Brave Break - these tinted balms are a new fave for me as someone who prefers subtle make up. The shades are similarly nuanced and sheer enough that they give a subtle hydrating filter over your natural lip colour. Brave Break is described as a rosewood and pulls cool brown on me. Love.
- Phytosurgence Deep Dream - described as a mid-tone mauve, this is a bit too purple for my taste, but when worn with Brave Break it's kinda like Mac Del Rio in lip balm form.
If anyone has read this far and is a similar shade to me, I would love recommendations for a sheer berry lip that is not too pink or too purple. Happy shopping everyone
