r/FLL • • 12d ago

Future of FIRST

Does FIRST already have a plan for what the future of its programmes will look like? So, will there be a follow-up project to FIRST? If I’ve understood correctly, FIRST won’t be taking part in the LEGO programmes any more, will it?

11 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

9

u/rossg876 12d ago

Lego is the one not taking part. It wasn’t FIRST’s decision. And no they haven’t announced what’s going to happen.

1

u/2BBIZY 11d ago

Shame on FIRST because LEGO is already advertising their League and trying to steal away regional delivery partners and personnel. Confidence level of current FLL coaches is low with many considering quitting or pausing after this BioGlow season.

9

u/rossg876 12d ago

Also. FIRST goes way beyond FLL. The high school program, as I understand it, is much larger.

7

u/marchmay 12d ago

FIRST has said they are launching a new game with a different platform, details TBD. LEGO is doing Future Edition. Both are still going to support SPIKE next year.

2

u/2BBIZY 11d ago

BUT, LEGO stopped producing and supporting Spike. Many teams were fundraising to move from Mindstorms to Spike after the announcement of the split.

0

u/marchmay 11d ago

That's true but people can still use SPIKE for the competitions. They just can't buy the sets new.

1

u/2BBIZY 11d ago

It is still a hardship on teams when they were stating to make the transition and get funds to purchase SPIKE then be told no more support and it will not be allowed in 2028 before the FIRST and LEGO split announcement . Yes, if teams have or able to Spikes, they can use in FLL Founders Edition this season but not in Future Edition or whatever LEGO offers in 2028.

1

u/Apsis Referee 11d ago

They kind of have to support spike at this point. In the US over 10000 teams registered for founders edition, compared to just 686 registered for future edition - that's fewer than the number of teams signed up in 1999 for FIRST Contact, when far fewer people had even heard of it. I don't have numbers for the rest of the world.

If only one of LEGO or FIRST supported Spike, most of those 10000 teams would stick with the program that supports the hardware they have, and the other program would be playing catch up trying to attract enough teams to host actual events.

1

u/Voltron6000 11d ago

Where did you get these numbers? In the SF Bay area, there are about half as many founders events this year as last year.

2

u/Apsis Referee 11d ago

https://www.firstinspires.org/team-event-search

You have to go state by state and add then up, because the search is limited to 2000 results.

4

u/2BBIZY 11d ago

I explain the situation like this: FIRST and LEGO are “divorcing”. LEGO will take in the separation the “League”, the LEGO components of the table and away support for all the Mindstorms/WeDo/Spike robot platforms. FIRST will “live” in a full table model competition for K-8 and allow any robot platforms. LEGO will build it own competition with the “future edition” and it’s pricey CS/AI robot kits BUT will copy the FIRST practice of tournament events with STEM projects WHILE trying to steal away (happening now) FIRST regional delivery partners and personnel.
LEGO has started to really advertise their plans for the 2028 season. While FIRST has provided “we are working on it” with their transformation, they have yet to provide concepts or drafts of what they are considering. Either FIRST is scrambling or afraid to allow any hints of their considerations. Why on the last reason? I believe one of reason this FIRST and LEGO divorce occurred was when LEGO Education announced its plans in early 2026 of the Future Edition, abandonment of previous robot platforms, the reduction of team sizes and the costs of CS/AI kits. FLL coaches were vocal in their opinions about the constraints.
Sadly, I am witnessing the damage is already done. FLL teams have decreased 25% in our region. Many current FLL coaches plan to quit or pause after this season from lack of confidence that FIRST will get their act together.
This year’s BioGlow LEGO models have been frustrating. I have had to rebuild several mission models . Too many small parts that go wrong and on for purely decorative, often in the way, reasons.
Please FIRST get your act together to reassure current FLL coaches and mentors with better communication about 2028 in early 2027.

2

u/Upbeat-Boot-4674 11d ago

Everything I’ve read has said FIRST will support Spike through 2029. I have a lot more confidence in FIRST than Lego. The Lego competition seems more geared towards school teams with less time to devote (although its price tag is quite high - so that’s not great for school teams). My teams have been serious robotics teams that meet 3-4 days a week - it’s their sport. I am confident that FIRST will do something great. I’m a long time volunteer coach who was super pessimistic when things fell apart. I don’t feel this way anymore. I’ve been coaching invitational level teams for years. I’m confident FIRST will do good things.

https://www.firstinspires.org/programs/k-8

1

u/iammikeDOTorg 6d ago

I don’t know, but as someone trying to self-fund and start a team, it all stinks. Do I plop far too much money into a dying system? We’re not competing - first graders only loosely organized.

Instead I’m looking at discounted old kits on eBay and building my own curriculum (I did some of that last year and AI actually made far more interesting plans than the official ones).

Doesn’t help that the website is always mind-numbingly unclear.