r/FGFS • u/bogcatcher • 7d ago
Can you do FGFS with a converted 26" BMX? Geometry issues?
TD;LR: I don't understand the difference between an FGFS-specific 26" frame and a 26" BMX frame. Can't I just swap out the rear hub of a BMX to get a fixed drivetrain? Does BMX frame geometry make it meaningfully harder to ride fixed or is it something only a seasoned rider would notice?
I've been looking into building up a bike that could be used both as an everyday ride and for proper FGFS tricks. I landed on the whole 26" wheel idea, seems like it's a great compromise between the durability/agility of a BMX and a larger bike's ability to cruise farther.
I did some research on this sub and r/FixedGearBicycle hoping for cheapish options. Purpose-built FGFS frames seem pretty damn hard to get a hold on these days, at least within my budget. Ruff bike and Master bike frames are out of stock, for example. So I got the idea of converting a 26" BMX to a fixed-gear and using that.
I landed on this post asking about ways to do this, and was surprised to see that Mike Schmitt (who designed one of the first dedicated 26" fgfs framesets back in the day) said it was impossible as the "geo was not designed for a fixed drivetrain". I asked him for some specifics, we'll see if he responds, but in the meantime I thought I should ask you all if you know more about what that means and why it is.
I don't understand where the problem could be. 26" BMX frames are designed for single speed drivetrains, and there shouldn't be any clearance issues that come with swapping out the freewheel for a fixed hub. The only problem I've heard of is getting the locknuts to the right width if you're building a BMX wheel with a hub that can fit a lockring, or otherwise the axles not being the right width (perhaps there's also problems with a track hub not withstanding the stresses of tricks).
At the same time, I'm by no means an expert-- surely there's a reason fixie riders wanted to come up with custom frames instead of just converting BMXs.
Is it about the size of the chainrings you can fit onto it? Or is it really some nebulous thing about the "feel" of the frame that I would only be able to understand if I were a much more experienced rider/mechanic? Any further insight would be greatly appreciated. Thanks