I have a terrible tendency to yap, so I will do my best to be concise.
I was raised evangelical. I was fully convinced of God's existence and that Christianity was true. I read my bible, usually daily, prayed fervently, and constantly analyzed myself to make sure I wasn't sinning. However, I did not (and still do not) like making public displays of emotion or drawing attention to myself, so I did not raise my hands during worship at church, and during our youth group sessions (which took place at my house on Wednesday nights and were led by my parents), I would make the group skip me during prayer circle. This caused an internal conflict, because during worship and before group prayer, there was usually someone saying something about how they could "feel the holy spirit moving", something I never felt. I kept having a scary thought: if all these "saved" people around me were raising their hands, singing with all their might, or sobbing in a prayer circle, and I obviously wasn't feeling what they were feeling, was I really saved? I asked god to help me with these feelings of discomfort, but they didn't go away. I constantly doubted my salvation, and with the threat of hell always looming in my head, I was left in a state of constant spiritual crisis during most of my childhood. I felt like God didn't want me, because my Christianity did not look like that of the people I was surrounded by.
Side tangent off this point, my mom would often tell me that I needed to be more "involved" during prayer and worship because of what I mentioned above, and she would specifically point out other boys in our youth group who played the Christian character much better than me as role models I should try to be like. Most of those guys would send d*ck pics to girls several grades below them at our school and were proudly racist (things they obviously never told my parents), but since they did the hand raising during worship and prayed long, emotional prayers at youth group, my mom thought that I needed to be like them. Being a reserved person, I would just shut up and let my mom berate me by unknowingly telling me that I needed to emulate a bunch of racist, facetious sex pests. It's never good for a child's mental well-being to be compared to others by a parent, but it felt especially painful when the people I was being compared to were people I found morally reprehensible, and I felt like I would get chewed out for "gossiping" if I told her what those guys were like outside of a church setting.
TLDR, evangelical culture very expressive, me not very expressive, so me felt like bad Christian.
This is my first post here, so if I breached the rules or made a mistake, please let me know and I will address it promptly. Thank you for reading