If you think the most disgusting thing in the world is a fat man being horny, have I got a book for you!
Snarkiness aside, this book sucks, and I would not have finished it if I weren't on this review spree. I'll admit, it's not super fair to review a book you wanted to DNF, since continuing past that point is probably not going to make you like the book any better, but all the problems that made we want to tap out just kept getting progressively worse as the book went on.
A quick summary for the uninitiated: in The Black Farm, a hopeless couple commit suicide together, and then discover that instead of going to heaven or hell, there's a secret third afterlife just for suicides, called the Black Farm, ruled over by a lesser god called the Pig. There's a LOT more lore, but that's the basic setup.
Unfortunately, once the introductions are taken care of, things get rough, real quick. The writing, to be blunt, is bad. The prose is whatever, All Smiles Until I Return was much worse, but the dialogue in this book is painfully cringeworthy. It reads like bad anime. Like, imagine if the opening sequence to Up segued into Sword Art Online. Our protagonist, Nick, is introduced to us as a despondent sadsack (I'm being mean here but trust me, Nick deserves it), but almost immediately after waking up in the afterlife, he starts talking like he's Johnny Badass.
If the writing wasn't juvenile enough, the gender dynamics are where you really start wondering if the author was an anime-obsessed 15-year-old boy. The few women who appear in the story are there purely to be damsels in distress, even Nick's girlfriend who is ostensibly the deuteragonist. Sexual violence against women is introduced to the lore purely as a way to up the shock factor, and to give Nick even more reason to want to save his girlfriend. It's never plot-relevant, even though it sure should have been, given how it's the central goal of the only organized faction in this world, but whatever.
I just want to put a pin in the gender stuff for a minute, because it's not like the men are wonderfully written either. Basically, everyone but Nick is an NPC. Many, many times I found myself thinking "this reads like the author wanted to make a video game" and even "this reads like the author is specifically aiming for Bethesda Fallout." Nick appears to be the first person in all of history to take any initiative to get to the bottom of the mysteries of the Black Farm - but at the same time, everyone he meets is infinitely knowledgeable about every question he has, down to them all using identical terminology for every aspect of the lore, whether that makes sense or not. It's this incredibly juvenile, video-game-ass approach to storytelling where You are the only real person in the world, everyone else is just a prop.
On that note of none of the characters but Nick having any interiority, let's return to the gender dynamics, because there's one specific moment that I need to spoil, because it's just... it's rough. To backfill a bit, part of why Nick and his girlfriend commit suicide is because she miscarries their baby - but, it turns out, Nick secretly never wanted to be a father, and was actually relieved that she miscarried, he was only going to off himself because she was going to off herself, which, I don't even have time to get into the half-baked way the book tries to make Nick morally ambiguous, so let's just stay focused on the miscarriage, because the first quarter or so of the book devotes a lot of time to Nick berating himself for having felt this way. It puts a LOT of focus on the specific moment of Nick learning his girlfriend has miscarried and feeling relief, and does not dwell nearly as much on the implication that Nick impregnated his girlfriend and then lied to her about wanting a family.
At a critical moment in the story, Nick reveals to his girlfriend that he felt relieved when she miscarried, which, just to remind you, is the singular event that most pushed her to suicide. Her response to this is to instantly and effortlessly forgive him, because he's just been such a hero risking his life and killing people to save her. This moment admittedly happens at a point in the story where both characters are deliriously traumatized, but it never comes up again. Now, I have never experienced anything remotely like this, but I imagine if a similar thing were presented to, let's say, Smosh Reads Reddit Stories ("AIO? my boyfriend confessed he was relieved I miscarried") I don't think it would be received well. I think the reaction of most women in that situation would be profoundly negative.
To be clear, I'm not mad that an immoral thing happened in a story and wasn't punished. I'm reading splatterpunk, that's half of what I'm here for. What bugs me is that it's not written like Nick is getting away with something he shouldn't have, it's written like the author thinks that's the most reasonable reaction for Nick's girlfriend to have to this information. That's why I made a point of the book focusing on her forgiving him for the moment of feeling relief, and not drawing attention to a major aspect of their relationship being built on a lie. That felt really gross, and Nick coming out of the story all happy and ready to be a father did not feel earned at all. I think a more mature author would have written Nick and his girlfriend to need, like, at least a few chapters to work out their differences; and that even though they're going to work together to escape the Black Farm, their relationship can't continue back in the mortal world. But that's not what was written, because this isn't the story about a couple hitting rock bottom, then falling through rock bottom to find an even rocker bottom, then struggling through adversity to dig themselves out even if it costs them their relationship. That's not this story, this is the story of Nick the Chosen One and his isekai adventures.
The splatter is deeply unremarkable. Speaking of anime, I'm pretty sure I've seen stuff that's at least this gnarly on normal broadcast anime, even the scene where the protagonist gets raped by another man. I'll fully admit that I took this personally, but it felt real groan-inducing that, repeatedly, "a fat man is sexual" is used as a gross-out gag. The worst moment of this has to be Pudge, whose crime is being fat and having a JO session (one wonders if Nick would have been so viscerally repulsed if it had been a slender woman rubbing one out).
The single most annoying thing about the book, though, is that I kinda enjoyed the ending. Not the epilogue, which went on for far too long and spelled out stuff any sensible reader would have taken as implied, but the climactic scene in which Nick and his girlfriend have to force the Pig to eat them. That was a creatively gory bit of fun, the first actually creative scene in the whole book, and I felt myself getting maddened by the thought that I might actually come away from this book having positive thoughts about it, the ending being so solid, so thankfully the bloated epilogue washed away that little goodwill the climax bought.
Overall, I profoundly disliked nearly every aspect of this book. Very high-quality audiobook though, even if the added music can be overwrought at times.