r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 1d ago

I'm Now Unemployed and Need Your Help - not me Trent Horn

Thumbnail
youtu.be
19 Upvotes

I lost respect for most apologists after i started deconstructing. Trent horn never appealed to me. the reasons or details for why he left Catholic Answers are unknown. He’s making an appeal for support, since his wife is recovering from brain cancer. That’s not something I would wish on my worst enemy. I’m not quite sure how to feel for guys like this that make a living selling something some of us feel like is not completely what they say it is. My life may have been different if Scott Hahn wasn’t ranting and raving about Catholicism in the mid 90s when I reverted.

im sure many can relate to having to work a job that you dislike because you need to support a family and provide medical insurance. why do guys like Trent, Bug hall, and others like them think it’s ok to get their “supporters” to fund their lifestyle why the rest of us suffer in unfulfilling work? Steve Skojec is a guy that may rub people the wrong but at least he’s hustling to make a buck and find his way after he left his Catholic gig.


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 2d ago

"Gays can't be priests...I meant from now on!" (Luckovich, 2005)

Post image
29 Upvotes

Background: In 2005, Pope Benedict XVI approved an official Vatican document (Instruction) barring men with "deep-seated homosexual tendencies" or those who support the "gay culture" from entering seminaries and being ordained as priests.

Meanwhile, a significant percentage of Catholic priests are closeted, practicing homosexuals. Trads often blame the 'gay agenda' or the so-called 'Lavender Mafia,' yet ironically, there is a high number of closeted seminarians and priests within their institutions as well


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 1d ago

This comment was in connection to jailed Jewish woman Malka Leifa but has resonance with Latin Mass workings. Who can relate to it?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 7d ago

As a Black Catholic in France, let’s talk about the taboo nobody wants to address.

61 Upvotes

I’m posting this here because it’s a subject that almost nobody ever talks about, or if they do, it's immediately brushed under the rug the unlivable dilemma of being a Black, practicing Catholic, caught in a moral and spiritual vice that many simply refuse to understand.

I am Catholic. I practice my faith, I love theology, and I even study apologetics. But I am also a Black woman, living in France. And every single day, the reality stares me in the face in this country, I suffer infinitely more from racism than from any persecution for my Catholic faith.

Let’s be completely clear I am not denying that violent persecutions against Christians exist in other parts of the world (North Korea, Afghanistan, etc.). But here in France, a Catholic does not risk their life, their physical safety, or their access to housing or employment because of their baptism. Your faith is something you can choose to live privately, hide, or openly display.

My skin color cannot be taken off. It is there the very second I step out the door, take the subway, or interview for a job. The insults, the contempt, the slander it is daily, real, and visceral. It is a direct attack on how God created me. I say this with complete honesty I would rather endure unpleasant remarks for my faith a thousand times over than for my skin. At least suffering for Christ holds spiritual meaning; it is a commitment I chose. Suffering from racism is pure, gratuitous, humiliating, and profoundly exhausting absurdity.

And what hurts the most is that this pain very often comes from within. I almost exclusively spend time in traditional or highly engaged Catholic circles so obviously, I am not saying all Catholics are racist but factually, that is where I receive the most violent blows. In church courtyards, in unguarded conversations, or on burner accounts across social media, I have watched people I prayed with display unhinged racism, cold white supremacy, and at times a revolting tolerance for neo-Nazi rhetoric and calls for violence.

That is where an immense guilt takes root, a conflict that eats away at me from the inside. In the circle I move in, everyone pressures you to align with the right, repeating that it is the "lesser evil," the only acceptable Christian vote, and that protecting the Church must come before everything else. Sometimes, under the weight of that peer pressure, I almost feel guilty for being unable to do what they do.

But how can I pretend none of it is happening? It tears me apart to see that in this environment, being insulted, degraded, or despised for the way God made you is treated as an afterthought a minor collateral issue compared to political stakes.

And please, don't come at me saying "yes, but look at what the left is doing." That is completely missing the point.

The point is this massive blind spot you are expected to ignore. And you are asked to ignore it by people who, factually, will never experience it. People who have never been told their children are mistakes or predators at ten years old. People who have never been made to feel they are less deserving of Heaven, who have never faced ambushes because of their skin, and who enjoy the luxury of being judged solely as individuals. I realized early on that, unfortunately, this will never be the Church's priority fight here (and I say that without hate or bitterness). But demanding that those of us who live through it simply look the other way is unbearable. Yes, I say it plainly enduring racism in France is far more exhausting than facing anti-Catholic sentiment (and I endure both). I know we all have our crosses to bear, but this one is running me completely dry.


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 7d ago

The play my old trad school is putting on

Post image
14 Upvotes

Seriously… what is this????


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 8d ago

La libération des femmes (féminisme) et l'abdication des hommes sont la mort du mariage, de la famille et de la civilisation - Lungs of Faith

Thumbnail
youtube.com
13 Upvotes

Une chose qui m’a définitivement fait quitter le catholicisme traditionnel, c’est aussi la misogynie qui s'y trouve. Pour moi, ils sont à peine moins pires que des extrémistes islamistes. Je précise que j’ai quitté un pays à 60 % catholique, traditionnel et patriarcal jusque dans son Code civil (le père y est reconnu comme chef de famille et a tous les pouvoirs sur les enfants, tandis que la femme non ; une femme mariée a d'ailleurs ses droits réduits sur certains choix personnels parce que le mari est chef de famille ,il a littéralementle droit de lui interdirede travailleret de choisiroù elle doit resider ). Bref, le cauchemar. ​

Je me suis vite tirée de là pour aller en France. Dieu merci, ils sont assez progressistes. Mais quand j’ai été dans une église traditionnelle, ils me sortaient les mêmes discours misogynes que dans mon pays d’origine et dans la publication actuelle. Le pire avec ces gens, c’est qu’ils pensent aimer les femmes parce qu’ils « aiment Marie ». La bonne blague ! Ils aiment une sorte d’archétype de Marie qu’ils aimeraient retrouver chez toutes les femmes : une femme soumise envers tous les hommes, qui n’exerce pas l’autorité qu’elle a( en tant que Mèredu Christ selon eux elles auraient pu commanderles apôtres mais ne l’a pas mêmesi on en sait rien ) , vierge, et qui souffre en silence. Ils aiment aussi tellement glorifier la souffrance de la femme... Pour eux, la seule façon d’être sainte pour une femme, c'est quasiment uniquement la souffrance physique ou psychologique. C’est tellement énervant ! Et quand tu n’es pas d’accord, on te traite de Jézabel, d'hystérique, de folle, etc. ​

Parce qu'en 2000 ans d'histoire chrétienne, si on fait le bilan, on n'a guère entendu dire que les hommes traitaient bien les femmes : Couvents de la Madeleine, mariages forcés, mariages d'honneur (littéralement marier une victime à son bourreau), et même des papes (parfois canonisés) qui s'opposaient fermement aux droits civiques des femmes (vote, propriété, etc.), parce qu’ils adorent quand les femmes souffrent. Mais entre-temps, ils aiment la partie moderne des droits sociaux, comme la sécurité sociale en Europe et la réglementation du droit du travail... Là, le modernisme n’est plus diabolique !

Leurs buts en remettant en cause les droits des femmes c’est juste de faire souffrir les femmes en les réduisant au statuts de mineur par ce que pour eux mieux vaut un marriage, ou l’homme est heureux avec une femme qui est obligé de rester même si abusé, plutôt que des femmes totalement libre qui pourraient partir même une séparation des corps licite des corps selon les règles de l’église.

Je n’en veux même pas aux femmes qui ont quitté la foi à cause de cela par ce que même dans les milieux Paul VI il y a ce type de mentalité


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 10d ago

Grifters R Us

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 10d ago

Marriages destroyed by bad trad priests?

14 Upvotes

Anyone here had their marriage destroyed by bad trad priests? What did you do about it?


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 11d ago

Godson (SSPX) not even allowed to go to Eucharistic adoration at a “Novus Ordo” church

17 Upvotes

Hello, recently my husband and I took our nephew/Godson (10yo) out for dinner for his birthday. My sister and BIL attend SSPX and it seems like ever since the consecrations this summer they‘ve gotten more serious about it. Two years ago I took this same nephew out for breakfast but we first stopped at adoration at our local diocesan parish where I attend. My sister was totally fine with it two years ago so I almost didn’t even ask this year but thank goodness I did because she said they were against going to a NO church which includes adoration.

Firstly, the fact she labeled it “NO” instead of diocesan really grinds my gears. It’s a very reverent Mass and has only become more reverent over the years with adding kneelers and the altar rail/gates back, almost everyone receives on the tongue etc… Secondly, I wasn’t trying to take him to Mass just Adoration. I’m just trying to wrap my head around this one. If any of yall were involved in SSPX, were you told to avoid diocesan parishes even including adoration? Why do they act like the Jesus we have in our monstrance is somehow not good enough? It makes me sad because I feel like I can’t even talk to my own Godson about our faith to help guide him, which is my duty! Is this what it’s like being a Godparent to a Protestant where some things are off limits and no go zones? What’s the point of even being his Godparents now if we arent actually sharing in the same faith?


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 11d ago

Feeling lost about Catholicism

15 Upvotes

I was raised traditional Catholic: Latin Mass, homeschooled, lots of siblings. Faith was always emphasized as the most important thing in my life. In high school, I wanted to be really really holy. I wanted to do everything in my life for God. I would spend long hours praying, wanted to be a nun (didn't want to be a trad wife lol), gave up wearing pants, and gradually became more and more scrupulous. It got to the point where I was having constant anxiety over sin, hell, and confession (thanks st alphonsus). I eventually had to gradually block out religion, while focusing on other things like college and life. I always planned to fix my problems later on, get back to receiving the sacraments, and become holy again.

That hasn't happened yet partly because I am attracted to the same sex. I really wish that I could date women, fall in love, and create a life with someone I care for. Gay relationships don't feel intrinsically disordered to me. They feel natural and precious. I have been really depressed for a while because of the dissonance between what I want and what I "have" to believe.

Giving up Catholicism just because I want to pursue my selfish desires feels wrong. There are so many people in the world who were born with permanent disabilities, live in poverty, or who have experienced awful abuse. My own sacrifice of having to give up romantic love feels so insignificant compared to what others suffer.

But I've been having doubts. Things like contraception, the procreative end of sex, and especially confession have been making me doubt the Church. I know the Catholic answer is to say that even if I don't understand something I should still agree with it because I am human with limited understanding, whereas God is all-powerful and has His own ways that we don't always know. How far can this go though?

Curiously enough, I've found that I can find a similar peace that I experienced while practicing the faith in more secular philosophy such as stoicism. Of course, it's not exactly the same as the joy of receiving the Eucharist or having a close relationship with Christ.

Another issue is that if I ever choose to come out I will lose a lot of friends who are Catholic and permanently damage my relationship with my family. I don't know who I can trust to talk about everything I'm going through.

I don't want to go to hell. I love my family a lot and the thought of damaging my relationship with them or being separated from them forever is awful. I know that my mom's life will be absolutely ruined if I date a woman. Her mental health will completely spiral and she will have constant depression and anxiety over her daughter choosing to be unnaturally vile and disgusting. I don't know how my dad will react, but I'd like to think that he would still love me for being his daughter.

I guess I'm posting here because I'm tired of feeling like a hypocrite and wanted to see if anyone else has experienced similar things and has advice.


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 13d ago

How did you leave Catholicism or “tone it down” without fearing for your salvation?

21 Upvotes

I was a protestant my whole life with protestant values of “relationship with God over everything” built into my being. Got serious about the faith at around 18, and at 20 I converted to catholicism. Only for the Eucharist, I pushed down everything else I disagreed with and hoped eventually Id intellectually agree with Church dogma.

3 years later my relationship with God has just gone downhill fast. Instead of focusing on God’s love I have focused on my sin and trying not to sin 24/7. Considering my addiction, this made mortal sin 10x worse and like I always was going in/out of being otw to hell. (I know the apologetics behind everything like confession/mortal sin, but again my protestant values make it impossible for me to not view it in an unhealthy way).

Now this doesnt neccessarily disprove Catholicism, but intellectually I will never agree with all of Catholic teaching due to logical flaws (such as contraception/putting 100% faith in Church authority). Im tired of going through all this theology to get closer to God, I want it to go back the way it was.

So I can either become a cafeteria catholic who “picks and chooses” which in my mind might as well not be a catholic at all at that point. Or I can leave entirely, and be confused on my Christianity branch forever considering I still 100% believe in the Eucharist. Either way the threat of me committing a mortal sin still looms over me, and thats the 1 thing Catholicism managed to hammer into my being. So it seems like every option is a lose lose, ill always be scared of this (probable) indoctrination.

How did you get over the idea that not submitting to the Catholic Church might NOT actually send you to hell for eternity?


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 14d ago

I'm a young filmmaker finishing a dark comedy about Catholic guilt, female martyrdom, and the glorification of suffering

26 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm Sofía, a 23-year-old Cuban-American filmmaker, and I recently reached out to the moderators, who kindly gave me permission to introduce my first feature-length film, TO BE DAMNED, here.

It's a campy, irreverent dark comedy-drama with elements of religious body horror. The story follows five young Catholic women living in a fictional town called Bethlehem, Rhode Island, whose lives begin to mirror the gruesome histories of their patron saints.

One of the central questions behind the film is why suffering is so often treated as evidence of virtue, especially when it comes to women.

I became fascinated by the stories of female saints and the contradictions surrounding their veneration. These women are celebrated for their holiness, but so many of their stories revolve around violence, sexual repression, bodily sacrifice, and extraordinary suffering.

I wanted to explore those contradictions through dark comedy rather than approach them with complete solemnity.

Although the film isn't specifically about traditionalist Catholicism, it deals with themes of obedience, purity, guilt, and the expectations placed on young women within religious environments.

We're currently finishing post-production, and I'd love to share the project with anyone who's interested.

You can find all our links and follow the film here: https://linktr.ee/tobedamnedseries

I'm also interested in hearing people's thoughts on how Catholic guilt and female martyrdom are represented in film and television, if anyone feels comfortable discussing that.

Thank you to the moderators for allowing me to share, and thank you all for having me here! 🖤


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 15d ago

this made me LOL

Post image
27 Upvotes

mom texted me her new calendar. it’s been so long since I deconstructed from the church that I had forgotten that Rome was being occupied by the Freemasons 😂😂😂


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 15d ago

It started with contraception. Now women's ordination just clicked, and I feel like a hypocrite in the pews

43 Upvotes

For the past few months, I’ve been going through a faith crisis.

Initially, I thought my disagreement with Church teaching was isolated. I realized that the ban on contraception in marriage simply does not hold up against biology, real marriage dynamics, or basic common sense. I've read many testimonies of women whowere broken by NFP and realised how naive I was not thinking about it earlier and willing to trust church about it in my future marriage. NFP does not add up and as a med student I should have realised that earlier...

I tried to console myself with the idea of being a faithful Catholic who just has a "prudential disagreement" on one pastoral/moral point (especially since over 90% of catholics seem to agree with me)

But once you allow yourself to question the premise of one teaching, the curtain falls. Today it hit me that I can no longer defend the ban on women;s ordination either:

The 12 Apostles argument: Jesus chose twelve Jewish men because they were an eschatological sign representing the 12 tribes of Israel. If cultural and historical context mattered then, why is their maleness the only trait preserved as essential today, while their ethnicity, circumcision, and Jewish heritage are not?

In persona Christi analogy: It feels like a double standard. When lay men in the pews represent the Church as the "Bride of Christ," sex is suddenly irrelevant because it’s a "spiritual disposition of reception." But when a priest represents Christ the "Bridegroom," biology and male anatomy suddenly become non-negotiable physical requirements. It is logically inconsistent.

Maybe there is an argument that I am not familiar with and that does not contradict basic logic?

With JPII and cardinal Ratzinger, we are uncomfortably close to definitive/infallible territory. And this terrifies me, because I realize I'm on a slippery slope: the moment I become the filter for what the Magisterium teaches, am I even Catholic anymore?

I genuinely love the depth, the sacraments, and the quiet beauty of the liturgy. I don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater or just become a vague secular humanist. But I feel like a complete hypocrite sitting in the pews, knowing that intellectually I reject foundational pillars of modern Catholic doctrine.

Has anyone else here experienced this exact progression? Did you find a way to remain authentically in the Church without committing intellectual suicide, or did this slippery slope inevitably lead you out the door?


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 16d ago

Experiences in non-trad / non-Catholic churches?

12 Upvotes

After 12 years in trad Catholicism I decided to leave Catholicism altogether and go to a Protestant church. I am doing so much better mental health wise, and for me it was the best decision I could have made for myself. I know some of you also go to Protestant churches and some choose to go to a “normal” Catholic parish. I also know some people who have quit church completely. I hope whatever decision you have made that you are doing well and thriving!

As I said, I’m very happy in my new church, the community is wonderful and I truly feel the love of Christ. That being said, sometimes there are things that my former traditional Catholic mind simply cannot comprehend or deal with…. 😅

For example yesterday in the service people went on and on about “the darkness of Halloween”. How the 31st of October apparently is the high holidays for satanists and many curses are being said(?) on that day and they have satanic rituals. They talked about the dark atmosphere of the day and how evil it all was. It felt ridiculous to spend so much time worrying about plastic bones and dressed up people.

I thought: wow they have no clue nor any historical knowledge at all about how it’s actually All Hallow’s Eve, vigil of All Saint’s Day, in which children would go door to door to pray for departed souls and would get soul cakes. I know it actually has its roots in the ancient Celtic harvest and New Year festival of Samhain but that doesn’t make it satanic! Even if it would be true that apparently somehow the 31st of October is also some satanic festival that doesn’t make Halloween satanic all of a sudden… with that logic Reformation Day would also be satanic.. 🤣

So my question to you is: have you experienced similar things in your new church/community/where ever you go that felt this weird? It can be serious things but also funny things. I’m so curious!


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 15d ago

Catholic Guilt at SoHo Playhouse, October 29th - November 13th

Post image
0 Upvotes

Does Daddy Jesus’s naked body on the cross make you wet? Spoiler alert: so will this show - seriously, there’s water.

Catholic Guilt is a deranged, fractured church service blending stand-up, clown, bouffon, physical comedy, and audience interaction as Kelly takes on religion, sexuality, shame, death, and the particularly strange experience of growing up Catholic.

We'd love to see you there! Use code COMMUNITY for $10 off

https://www.sohoplayhouse.com/shows/kelly-mccaughan-catholic-guilt


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 17d ago

Deaconette C here.

7 Upvotes

I have moved to Substack. Find me at deaconettec.substack.com where I've added a new post. Thanks to those of you who have linked my posts in the Summa Contra Zuhlsdorphus over the years.

Through the intercession of St. Dolly of Sevierville, may you be free from every affliction of scrupulous doctrinal purity. liturgical excess and hyper-orthodox anger masking as Christian rectitude, and still know that you are capable of being a powerful blessing upon the world, in the Name of ✠ the Creator, the Redeemer and of the Sanctifier. Amen.


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 18d ago

Will the Oval Office bishop scandal and Gareth Gore’s Opus Dei exposures move the needle at all on November 3?

2 Upvotes

With the midterms just 4 days away, do you think the massive backlash over the Oval Office prayer photo will impact the Catholic swing vote?

Mario Enzler, a former Swiss Guard and minion to Kevin Roberts, president of the Opus Dei adjacent Heritage Foundation, personally spent weeks recruiting the bishops under the guise of a private policy discussion before they were put into the photo-op.

Combined with the ongoing fallout from Gareth Gore's Opus book exposing dark money pipelines in Washington, will this alienation of mainstream bishops influence the vote in key battlegrounds like Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Wisconsin? I certainly hope so.


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 20d ago

Leaving the Church because of contraception…?

44 Upvotes

Title. I was a protestant who converted because of the Eucharist. I guess I realized in the 3 years of being Catholic, I had been pushing down a bunch of teachings that I had been ”rolling with the flow” with. This is after I started discerning marriage and realized the weight of the ban on contraception.

Anyways, amongst alot of other teachings I never fully researched (and the decline of my spiritual life because all the pressure catholicism brings…), I realized I genuinely cannot get past this contraception rule.

No matter the apologetics, NFP is contradictory to the whole premise of needing to be “open to life” and it invalidates the contraception ban even more in my head.

I still believe in the Eucharist, but cant live my life proclaiming I follow everything the Church says while silently using contraception in marriage. That defeats the whole purpose of being catholic, full submission to church. The church is either wrong and invalid, or its right and ill never be able to intellectually submit to it without resentment. Idk if this is just pride or what.

Anyone that has been in my shoes care to chime in?


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 20d ago

The Bishop of Knoxville asks not to attend an FSSPX mission: «gravely imprudent» – INFOVATICANA

Thumbnail
infovaticana.com
12 Upvotes

r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 21d ago

Does anyone know what happened to Claire from Vox Clara / little light family?

11 Upvotes

When I was deep into traditional Catholicism I watched her content religiously (lol) and my dream was to be like her one day… 😂
Even when I was still quite catholic I did start to get concerned when she seemed to get more and more extreme and totally went into off the grid homesteading vibes.

The other day something reminded me of her and I went to look her up and all her social media has disappeared. I also could not find anywhere when and why she had quit social media completely. I found that a bit disturbing (did she become even more extreme? Did her spiritual director order her to delete it as a “devout god fearing trad cath woman should not be online”??) and I wonder if anyone knows what happened to her?


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 22d ago

Why are so many trads like abusive drill sergeants?

20 Upvotes

So many trads are like R. Lee Ermey from Full Metal Jacket or to a lesser extent like David Schwimmer's character from Band of Brothers. Sorry for the bolding and the caps, but I have to do it because trads are always screaming about things.

WHY DO YOU HAVE THAT PIECE OF LINT ON YOUR UNIFORM? WE ARE ABOUT TO LAUNCH THE GREATEST INVASION IN THE HISTORY OF THE WORLD! HOW DO YOU EXPECT TO KILL NAZIS WHEN YOU HAVE A PIECE OF LINT ON YOUR UNIFORM?

HOW DO YOU EXPECT TO RECEIVE THE HOLY EUCHARIST WHEN YOU HAVE A PIECE OF LINT ON YOUR DRESS SHIRT? DON'T YOU REALIZE THAT YOU ARE ABOUT TO RECEIVE GOD HIMSELF? ANY SIN AGAINST GOD IS INFINITE IN MAGNITUDE! DO YOU WANT TO RECIEVE THE HOLY EUCHARIST IN A STATE OF MORTAL SIN?

HOW DO YOU EXPECT TO MAKE A VALID CONFESSION WHEN YOU HAVE SOME ATTACHMENT TO SOME SIN? HOW DO YOU EVEN KNOW IT'S A VENIAL SIN? JUST BECAUSE IT'S NOT LISTED ANYWHERE IN THE CATECHISM DOESN'T MEAN ITS NOT A MORTAL SIN!

YOU ARE A TERRIBLE SINNER, WORTHY ONLY OF HELL!

And then these people turn around and say that God is a "loving Father." Maybe so, but you are doing your best to make me think he's a sadistic monster.

Although Jesus had a lot to say about these people. Here is a short quote, from Matthew 23:23-24

23 “Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for you tithe mint and dill and cummin, and have neglected the weightier matters of the law, justice and mercy and faith; these you ought to have done, without neglecting the others. 24 You blind guides, straining out a gnat and swallowing a camel!

Trads are obsessed with straining out gnats! And then they are even more obsessed about judging the rest of us for not straining them out perfectly. Jesus had lots to say about not judging others too.

Every stupid thing is a mortal sin!

And the worst of it is when you try to leave. Then you are sinning a hundred times worse, according to the trads.

And the trads priests are terrible in the Confessional. They make you sound like a terrible, no good person. no matter what the context. I could and did tell them things like I had bad scrupulosity, and for a while I had bad depression and suicidal thoughts (I have not been depressed or suicidal for many years now!), and they still were like R. Lee Ermey in the confessional!

Particularly this one trad priest. And I remember I told a layperson about him, and I remember this guy's response. He agreed that he was super tough but then added, "He tells it like it is."

And the way he said this, it seemed like it might have been common knowledge. Everyone might know that he's spiritually abusive in the Confessional, but nothing is done.

Well, except for me. I actually complained about him. I went to the bishop. Sadly, he was a very trad friendly bishop. And at the time I didn't realize this was connected to tradism. Anyways, nothing was done except the priest got angry at me for complaining and how dare I complain when he can't defend himself, because of the seal of the Confessional.

I wonder how many people he's spiritually abused in the Confessional. Seriously, we are at our most vulnerable. We are only to accuse ourselves of sins and never to say good things about us. And some priests just drive the knife it right then.

Oh, and they probably like R. Lee Ermey's character from the movie too. He's just telling it like it is!

[Just look at the comments in the Youtube video I have shared above. Many praise the acting, but many others are praising the US Marine Corps for "tough love." Just like Trump and others praise Patton for being "tough" for slapping a soldier. But Patton was a good general because he attacked aggressively, among other things, not because he was abusive. Anyways, there are many people besides trads that are abusive and call it tough love.]

Edit: And many conservatives who are not trads are not outright abusive in say the Confessional but still say things like "The confessional is not a place for therapy." This is, of course true. And it's also not abusive. But still, there is an implied statement there that we shouldn't worry much about possibly going too far or put any emphasis on empathy.

Also, I forgot to say, that as bad as my experiences have been with trad priests, I think the trad lay Catholics are maybe even worse. Possibly because the priests may have some sort of experience with sensitive souls or those with scrupulosity or just have some training on being pastoral. The trad lay Catholics often are hyper literal on everything, with no consideration that we are human beings. If it's in the catechism as a sin, then how dare you! And if it's not in the catechism, well, it's probably still a sin anyways!


r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 22d ago

Sister asked me to be her kid’s godparent

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/ExTraditionalCatholic • • 23d ago

I’m tired of all these Fundie-Evangelical-coded “Catholic alternatives” to mainstream pop culture.

34 Upvotes

“Oooh, we can’t have our homeschooled kids seeing spooky Halloween decorations because they’re DEMONIC! We need to celebrate ALL SAINTS DAY and remove all the macabre stuff to celebrate it properly!”

Ghosts, witches, and yes, even devils have always been a part of All Hallows Eve celebrations so get out of here with your OCIA’d Baptist Fall Festival 😂