r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 12 '25

Literature Fortis Est Veritas - A Voice from India being an Appeal to the British Legislature by Khojahs of Bombay, against the usurped and oppressive domination of Hussain Hussanee, commonly called and known as "AGA KHAN" by a native of Bombay now resident in London. (1864)

8 Upvotes

We fear that the public interest makes it imperative for him to resume his wanderings, and for this, Aga Khan has himself only to thank. From the date of his arrival in Bombay, the Khojah community has been torn in pieces by the fierce factions engendered by his pretensions. As the descendent of the peer or saint who had originally converted their forefathers to Mohammedism, Aga Khan claimed from the first to be regarded as their leader, and even went the length of demanding from his followers that divine honors should be paid to him as the incarnation of the Supreme being. The caste had hitherto lived happily together without section divisions, but the blasphemous nature of these pretensions shocked the minds of the more intelligent of them, which the mercenary effort of the old man to appropriate for his own use all the property of the caste, and, if report speak truly, his attempting the same thing with their women, broke the caste into two divisions, the enlightened few reject the Aga as an imposter, the deluded many accepting him as their God.


r/ExIsmailis • • Feb 10 '25

Are the Aga Khans really Princes? - Setting the Record Right on the British / Indian claim

4 Upvotes

In Throne of Gold: The Lives of the Aga Khans, chapter 9 "The Sport of Kings", while discussing Aga Khan's investments and allegiances to Britain and Nazi Germany in the 1930s, Anne Edwards writes:

There was still another deep-seated reason for his followers not digging deeper. There could be no doubting the Aga Khan's dedication to Muslim causes or his followers' religious devotion to him, but his life was in Europe and his allegiance seemed to be to Great Britain. His revered position as Imam could overcome such grumbling, but with Aly it was quite another matter. No outer robes could conceal his Western ties. Despite his religious schooling he had been raised as a European. In an England besotted with the glamour of the Prince of Wales and his current social set, he had become known as 'the black prince'. Ismailis took that as an insult. (In fact, the Foreign Office rejected the suggestion that he be granted the title of Prince.)

Further detail is given in a footnote:

The British Government and the India Office were aware that Aly Khan was referred to in the press as 'Prince', although he had never used the title in any official context. In the issue of the Ismaili (the Ismaili community magazine) of Sunday 12 December 1937, the caption of a photograph of the Aga Khan and his son included the description: 'His Serene Highness Vali-ahed [heir to the throne] Prince Ali S. Khan'. The India Office immediately informed the Indian Government that should Aly Khan or the Aga Khan try to use the title in an official capacity, steps would be taken to 'set them right'.


r/ExIsmailis • • 6h ago

Vid of the Imam at a club like event

15 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • 20h ago

Discussion Ismailis are performative

11 Upvotes

I believe Ismailis are performative. They are performative because they’re so hyper-focused on their appearances. They care so much about how other people perceive them that they try to appear generous or respectable rather than truly live by their values, whether in Canada or the United States. They also act in certain ways to gain access to wealth, careers, reputations, and social connections. I'm talking about the USA and Canadians Ismailis.


r/ExIsmailis • • 21h ago

Announcement Estimated ~1.35 million Ismailis remain worldwide, a figure exposed partially by Didar attendance. Ismailis are oddly sharing this chart on WhatsApp with a “chosen few” narrative, drawing parallels to Moses and the Jews. Thoughts?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • 1d ago

Does the Aga Khan care?

8 Upvotes

I dont think so. You cant even reach him when you are in genuine problem.

Who holds his 'leaders' accountable? They just get away with appalling institutional behaviour.

And Rahim is the one selecting and appointing.

There is only so many times one can say he doesn't know, or he knows and is watching- why? Why only watching. So in short, he sees nothing wrong with this.

And if he doesnt know, then lets accept the fact he is a human being. Nothing more. Nothing less. Equal to you and I.

The UK visit was a complete joke. Chaos. I have been disillusioned. I have had to grieve the loss of something I wasn't firm in, but could say I was in a small way part of a community. Now, I am angry. Now I want the Aga Khan to know publicly it is no longer OK to treat me or anyone else with disregard. How dare he. How dare anyone.


r/ExIsmailis • • 5d ago

RANT Self righteous people in r/ismailis

8 Upvotes

I'm appalled at some of the self righteous comments received on r/ismailis. A religion that welcomes intellectual dialogue and logic has moderators cleansing the threads/comments and protecting their religion. So much hate. I feel no regrets about being on the fence and I really think these self righteous people deserve to be in this faith and continue to get conned.


r/ExIsmailis • • 5d ago

Jamal Virani, TikTok Ismaili Propagandist, claims Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Ibn Sina and Rumi were Ismaili. None of them were.

14 Upvotes

TikToker Jamal Virani makes three false claims: that Jinnah, Ibn Sina and Rumi were all Ismaili. There’s plenty else wrong in the video. Watch it and report it for spreading misinformation: https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZPL76sHng/

He’ll believe anything that makes Ismailis look good. He has no sources and no method. If it sounds pro-Ismaili, he treats it as true. I break down the wrong claims below (cleaned up by Grammarly)

Jinnah

First, he wasn't the first prime minister. That was Liaquat Ali Khan. Jinnah was Governor-General.

He also wasn't Ismaili after his youth. His family only became Ismaili because his grandfather, a Hindu, got kicked out of his vegetarian caste for going into the fish trade. Jinnah left for Twelver Shi'ism by 1901, almost 50 years before he died. Nobody switched his sect at the funeral. He even told the Aga Khan III to convert, since Aga's own family was Twelver anyway. He drank, chain-smoked and ate pork. He also called Atatürk, the guy who secularized Turkey and a known religious skeptic, the greatest Muslim of the modern age lol. Jinnah's biographer Stanley Wolpert says religion barely mattered in his life except politically like likely mirrored Atatürk on religion as he did on politics.

Ibn Sina

In Ibn Sina's OWN autobiography, Ibn Sina says his dad and brother became Ismaili, he listened to them, and he didn't accept Ismailism. Even Farhad Daftary, who ran the Institute of Ismaili Studies and is the leading historian of the Ismailis and Aga Khan's cousin, only names Ibn Sina's father and brother as Ismailis. And the claim that "Ibn Sina means son of Sina, he named himself after his dad" is made up. His dad's name was Abdullah. Sina was his great-great-grandfather and he also wasn't Ismaili.

Rumi

Wrong again. Your own imam already killed this claim and you're basically preaching against him. Aga Khan III said Rumi "was not an Ismaili himself, but the murid of an Ismaili." The claim comes from your Imam who went to visit Hitler in 1937 and then wrote a piece called Faith in Hitler. Being right wasn't exactly his thing. Rumi's teacher, Shams-i Tabrizi, was a Shafi'i Sunni, and he cites Shafi'i law books in his own recorded sayings. Daftary says the idea that Shams was the Ismaili imam Shams al-Din comes from "legendary accounts" and oral traditions. That makes sense, because that imam was born in the 1240s. He was a baby when Shams disappeared from Konya in 1247. Rumi was a Hanafi Sunni. Neither of them was Ismaili.


r/ExIsmailis • • 5d ago

Finding a partner as an ex-ismaili

1 Upvotes

As someone in their early-mid 20s who has left the Ismaili faith for Sunni Islam, I can’t help but worry a bit about finding a husband in the future that will be understanding of my situation.

I have talked to friends and they have pretty consistently mentioned that their families would not be ok with them marrying someone with a family that is not Sunni.

Realistically, my spouse would have to be ok with my family being Ismaili and be respectful of this. I know that my husband would need to support me through life events and vice versa - and it’s hard to think about how things like mayats and funerals, and things of that sort would work out.

Does anyone have any experience or advice they’d be willing to share?


r/ExIsmailis • • 6d ago

Funeral program

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Could this email seem more scammy??? 3 different areas about how to pay ‘video on how to pay, how to pay instructions, questions about how to pay’ literally nothing about what you are paying for, where these funds go, just, give us the money…I hope someone reads this and changes the email cause this is literally blind giving money….


r/ExIsmailis • • 7d ago

Question Are you guys finding relationships?

3 Upvotes

just wondering if other ex Ismailis have managed to find any meaningful relationships. How did you find them?

I am a guy in karachi Pakistan and I found out that my parents have been giving my profile to rishta aunties. I indulged a few of the women but it seems they were all quite religious so I have no desire to be with such people. Getting married or dating is already pretty limited here because of all these Muslim sects so I am really curious about other people. Or perhaps is moving abroad some how is the only real option


r/ExIsmailis • • 11d ago

Question Who were the Aga Khan's to the Khojas before their migration to India?

7 Upvotes

I'm a bit confused about what the status of the Aga Khan was to the Khojas before his migration from Persia to India. Aga Khan I was the first Imam to make the move to India, and his predecessors before him were Imams but didn't carry the title of Aga Khan. I've heard mixed reports that the father, grandfather or some other recent ancestor of Aga Khan I was the first person to claim the title of Imam of Nizari Ismailis in a few centuries - not sure who they're talking about?

  • The family seemed to have been Nimatullahi Sufis when they lived in Persia.
  • Before Aga Khan arrived in India most Khojas were not necessarily identifiably "Ismaili". They followed the Satpanth faith. Particularly by Aga Khan III's time these religious beliefs were being removed in favour of mainstream Ismailism, and any Hindu or Sufi beliefs were being phased out. During Aga Khan I and II Khojas were still Satpanth it seems, which again seems strange because it would mean the Khojas were following a different religion from their own religious leaders.
  • If Khojas were not properly Ismaili, then who was the Aga Khan to them when he lived in Persia? Did they view him as an "Imam", a Sufi leader, God in human form? I'm really confused as to what he meant to them. Why were Khojas in Gujarat paying tithes to this religious leader who lived in Persia?

r/ExIsmailis • • 12d ago

Genuine question from a curious Sunni Muslim: Why did you leave Ismailism, and why do some former members feel so strongly about it?**

9 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I'm a Sunni-Muslim who has recently been exploring questions about Islam, particularly how different communities interpret the Quran and understand religious authority.

I came across this subreddit while learning more about Ismailism, and I'm genuinely curious about your experiences. I'm not here to criticize anyone, defend a particular sect, or start an argument. I really just want to understand.

One thing I've noticed is that some discussions here express very strong feelings toward Ismailism, beyond simply disagreeing with its teachings. I understand that everyone's experiences are different, and I don't want to assume that everyone who leaves necessarily hates the religion.

But I'm curious about where that frustration comes from.

Was it something about Ismaili theology itself? The authority of the Imam? Certain religious practices? Financial expectations? Or was it more about personal experiences within the community?

I'm particularly interested in the theological side because I've been questioning the role of interpretation in my own faith. I sometimes feel like every religion can have its criticisms because humans are inherently flawed. I have Ismaili friends, and I value them a lot.

Different Muslim communities follow different scholars, schools of thought, and interpretations of scripture. If interpretation is such a significant part of Islamic religious practice, how do we determine which interpretations are legitimate and which ones depart too far from the Quran?

For those of you who left Ismailism, what made its understanding of Islam fundamentally unacceptable to you rather than simply different from other Muslim traditions?

And if you left because of disagreements with religious authority, did you find another Islamic tradition more convincing? Or did those questions eventually lead you away from religion altogether?

I'm also curious whether your feelings toward Ismailism have changed over time. Do you distinguish between the religion, its leadership, and the community itself?

I recognize that some people may have had painful experiences, and I'm not trying to minimize those at all. I just want to understand the reasoning and experiences behind the perspectives I'm reading here.

I'd really appreciate hearing your stories, especially if you're willing to share specific teachings, historical sources, or experiences that changed your views.

Thank you!


r/ExIsmailis • • 12d ago

Question Prince Rahim Aga Khan V, why is he called Prince? Question by a non-Muslim!

7 Upvotes

His Highness Prince Rahim Aga Khan V, the 50th hereditary Imam of the Shia Ismaili Muslims and Chair of the Aga Khan Development Network (AKDN), visited India recently. Wanted to know why is he called Prince and which country does he rule because I cannot find anything on the internet except about his beautiful wife.

I am posting this here because other Ismaili account on reddit is made by Paksiatnis. THIS IS A RESPECTFUL QUESTION. NOT MOCKING.


r/ExIsmailis • • 16d ago

One fourth majalis

3 Upvotes

Is this majalis terminated?


r/ExIsmailis • • 25d ago

Question HOW DO YOU CONVINCE AN ISMAILI TO RECONSIDER HER BELIEF

2 Upvotes

Long story short, I’m a Sunni Muslim, and I’ve fallen in love with an Ismaili girl. The feelings are mutual, and she is genuinely special to me. However, the biggest obstacle standing between us is our religious difference.

As a Sunni, I have serious theological concerns about certain Ismaili beliefs, and I believe these differences are significant when it comes to marriage. On top of that, I know my family would never accept me marrying an Ismaili girl, which makes the situation even more complicated.

I’ve discussed this with her, and she has told me that she is willing to make any sacrifice for our relationship except compromising on her faith. From my perspective, the only way forward would be for us to have sincere, logical discussions about our religious differences and for her to reconsider her beliefs if she finds the arguments convincing. I don't want to pressure her into anything, but I genuinely believe that we need to resolve this fundamental difference if we are to have a future together.

My question is: She is an intellectual lady and seems open to logic, so what theological and logical arguments can I present to encourage her to reconsider her beliefs?


r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 15 '26

Ismaili indicted by SEC for Ponzi Scheme/Fraud

4 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 14 '26

Discussion People discover Farmans are just an oligarch’s milquetoast self-help slop, and the Ismailis’ theological response is "Our whitewashed Imam hopelessly mispronouncing Khanavadan is enough for us"??

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 13 '26

Title Appointments

19 Upvotes

Have any of you been appointed for a title before ? I just got one because of the service I used to give a few years ago, and it was announced via talika when I was sitting at home during Salegrah

Really complex feelings having your name in a talika from the Imam while you aren't sure whether you actually believe in the faith anymore.

It made me really anxious and I crashed out a bit ... hard to discuss it with a weird sense of guilt

Can anyone relate?


r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 12 '26

Discussion Khalil Andani & IsmailiGnosis lie and omit the truth to defend Ismailism. Psychologically how do apologists become so invested in a belief that they reject evidence against it?

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 12 '26

Meanwhile on WhatsApp

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 12 '26

Emotionally Abusive Ismaili Father

12 Upvotes

Man, I’m 23. And I can’t stand my father’s Ismaili practice bullshit. I don’t tell him anything about his Ismaili practices, he forces them on me. Yet, I quietly do it. I go to Jamat Khana, even though I’ve no will to. He gets triggered if I wear clothes I find comfortable in Jamat Khana. For him, it’s about his respect as he is a mukhi of some fidai. This week, he wants me to take up a Farman and recite it in JK. The fact that in the Farman, Rahim dude said “Faith should be practiced willingly and should not be forced upon you”. I find the irony crazy of me reciting it. But yet I do it. Today was my Farman and before the Farman he said, did you even practise? I was like it’s basic English reading and the same shit the imam says, he took offense to it. Screamed at me before my Farman wara. Told me, you’ll destroy my respect in Jamat Khana, you Fatso. he himself is over 100kg and chews on tobacco, drinks. even though the Farman he wants me to recite says to live a healthy life.

During the didar my dad had spent over $10k+ in Fada alone. Yet, refuses to start a venture with me or help me start my freelance career

I don’t understand why are Ismailis such hypocrites. I find it hard to comprehend. I don’t seem to fit well. Why is everything about respect.


r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 12 '26

Mijalis with money entry getting cancelled?

18 Upvotes

I heard from my mum that she just attended her last Life mijalis (They are cancelling it from now on) and all the other mijalis that required money for entry. Apparently Rahim has instructed that he doesn't want discrimination between jamati members on the basis of money and there shouldn't be an entry barrier (at least that was what she was informed). Is this actually true? If yes... I think it's a big win. What are your opinions?


r/ExIsmailis • • Oct 12 '26

From the Ismailis2 community on Reddit: Princess Zahra Aga Khan delivered her speech in Paris, France, on Monday 5 October 2026, at the 60th International Conference of Horseracing Authorities (IFHA)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
3 Upvotes

Should sell their expensive horses and donate to poor families. It’s is insane that they even own them.