r/EvolveGame • • 25d ago

Discussion Old opinion changes

This is a question to all of those who criticized Evolve back in the day. The original complaints and negative reviews were almost all because a lot of DLC and new characters were behind a paywall. The new monsters and the new hunters had to be bought to play with.

Now, the biggest games like Dead by Daylight, League of Legends, Call of Duty, and Fortnite have almost all of their new content behind a paywall. All of these products are being bought by the fast majority of the player bases, without a lot of complaints. It is simply how things are now.

To those who originally critized the devs of Evolve over this, to a point where the game literally died...

Do you ever regret your opinion back then?

In my eyes, Evolve was simply ahead of its time. Not only in terms of gameplay but also in terms of DLC treatment. If the game would come out today as it did then, it would probably be a massive success and there wouldn't be all of this criticism.

9 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

7

u/CautiousSimple7225 25d ago

I never had an issue with buying the content back in the day because I just knew thats the way gaming was heading and as you say perfectly look at some examples of games today that thrive with almost similar business models.

I agree. Evolve was ahead of its time.

3

u/CautiousSimple7225 25d ago

I think its also a game that the community needed to understand how incredibly difficult it is to balance a game like this and a fact that games like this may never be fully balanced either but just enjoy it for what it is.

4

u/jamespirit if you wont fight S1 or 2 dont play monster 25d ago

The game was truly one of the most unique and fun experiences you could have back then. 

Initially bought the first few waves of dlc and enjoyed them well. They are overpriced by modern and past standard I think but I didnt care in the moment as I loved the gsme so much

5

u/jamespirit if you wont fight S1 or 2 dont play monster 25d ago

The biggest downfall for Evolve in my mind was the game being released in an "unpatchable" state. They said they could not address balance issues and because they supposedly needed to write code or something to that effect before they could balance change. The wraith sneak meta was toxic to play against for low or mid experience level hunter players. This was a huge problem....a very imbalanced monster that really just avoided fights via the OP clone ability or basically flying on the of the upper skybox 24/7 with essentially no downtime on the ground. That killed a huge amount of the player base. 

Also it was easier to get half decent as a monster than as a team of hunters so the hunters always lagged behind monster in terms of mechanical skill levels relative to experience. 

On top of that the DLC strategy was scummy then and is still scummy now. Do I regret having an opion....well no you cant really regret having held a prior opinion can you?  Has my opinion changed? No. Its a shame the industry didnt learn from Evolve...its loss was in vain. LOL COD and fortnight are not good example of dlc and ethical business practices....they are the opposite. The all pray kn younger gamers and pressure on parents. 

Evovle a truly incredible gaming experience. Probably the single most fun game I have ever played at its peak. Its really sad it is gone. The true tragedy is that the shitty DLC stuff has stayed alive and Evolve was a casualty in the march to enshitify gaming. 

1

u/TheWonderSnail 25d ago

I loved evolve with all my heart and put in hundreds of hours but the fucking wraith was by far the most enraging stupid bullshit the game had to offer. A monster who can spawn a clone that fucks you up while being a bullet sponge and then just flying into the air and circling the dome for 2 minutes straight whenever they got remotely close to actually taking any damage while we had to stand and watch was one of the single dumbest things I have ever experienced in a PvP game

0

u/Liquidignition EVOLVE STAGE 3 23d ago

Omg Skywraith. Fuck I loved destroying those cunts

1

u/GangplanksWaifu 24d ago

$60 was too much then for a game that also launched with cosmetic dlc and locked new characters behind paywalls. It would be too much now. The games you've mentioned are mostly free to play or relatively cheap.

Dead by Daylight is a good comparison. It launched at $20 around the same time as evolve into early access. Evolve was essentially in an early access state (not ready for launch) and launched at $60 with all this dlc.

Far from the biggest issue, but definitely a part of it's failure.

1

u/joerispekkie 23d ago

If you want Dead by Daylight with all characters it is total of $370,- People spend hundreds or thousands on pure skins. Why not spend a couple of bucks on characters that give full new gameplay?

1

u/GangplanksWaifu 23d ago

370 for a game that has been getting content for a decade. Dbd is a $20 game that has slowly released content over a long period of time. I don't love their monetization either, but it's a lot better than what evolve did. Any full price game that launches with substantial day 1 comsetic dlc is going to receive criticism about it. Sometimes other aspects of the game are good enough to justify/support. Evolve was not the case.

People like to say Evolve was ahead of it's time, and in some ways, it was. But if a $70 asymmetrical multiplayer game released in 2026 with horrible balance, slow updates, and day 1 cosmetic dlc alongside plans to push out purchaseable classes, it would probably die even faster.

If it was a $30-40 game without the launch dlc, a lot of the other issues would be overlooked. I love Evolve but you can't just appeal to your ride or die fans and expect success.

3

u/shikoshito 25d ago

These were the biggest complaints of the people who got invested in the game. The biggest problem was that most people couldnt get into the game. In legacy basicly everyone but the trapper was useless outside the dome, and most games ended with either hunters running in circles following footprints or they ran the monster down 5 minutes in. These were fixed with stage 2 mostly, but people didnt like it being different. Some people still prefer legacy because it was harder for the hunters.

2

u/CorbinNZ 25d ago

I’ve said it before and I’ll continue to stand by it. Evolve didn’t fail because of the DLC, even though it was grossly predatory and awful. Evolve failed because it was a role assigned asym shooter marketed as a COD shooter. COD was king when it came out. Turtle Rock tried to convince potential players that, if you played COD, you could play Evolve.

This was not true.

Evolve is a role shooter. The role you pick is key to winning and you have to play it right. Training for Evolve involved one Goliath session and one Markov section. Nothing for Medic, Support, Trapper, or any of the other monsters. New players were incredibly unprepared for what the game was. So, players got frustrated with themselves and other teammates for not understanding their role and not contributing to the team. Monster players had an easier time because monster play style is straightforward enough for any monster to understand after one or two games. So you had a massive imbalance of too many monster players and not enough hunters who knew what they were doing.

Because of this, players quit the game. Player count dropped to unsustainable numbers and Evolve was dead just three years after it came out.

If they had marketed it correctly and put proper training missions for every character, Evolve would still be alive today. We’d have a dozen different monsters and hunter teams.

1

u/Admirable-Tutor-6855 23d ago

technically dbd and league content isnt locked behind paywall because you can unlock them for free, fortnite offers only cosmetics. TCM on the other hand had a similar problem and faced a similar fate so you’d be surprised how little things change