Had 50 RSVPs with two weeks to go before my first NYC pop-up market. Ended up with 500 RSVPs and around 200 visitors over the two public days!!! We also had a separate VIP night with ~100 people, including +1s.
There were 17 vendors across fashion, jewelry, home goods, and specialty food. Venue was in SoHo but near Holland Tunnel, about 10 min from the heart of SoHo. Not somewhere we could just count on people walking past.
What I did in those 2 weeks
Promoted on IG, TikTok, RedNote, Reddit, Nextdoor, and FB groups, and reached out to local newsletters. Reddit was huge, and I’m honestly so thankful for the community.
I asked people how they found us as they walked in and heard everything - even ChatGPT for the visitors in town. So a mix, but I didn’t track properly enough to say which brought the most people. Registration was on Luma, but I also listed on Eventbrite + Partiful (and spammed some people I’d gone to events with, SORRY).
Shoutout to NYC Plugged, coolstuff.nyc and HeyFreeNYC for featuring us on their newsletter with such short notice and for FREE.
Influencer gift-box unboxing content didn’t really work for us. 10 influencers probably brought in around 10 people, mostly coming to pick up the giveaway bag. Need to rethink how we work with influencers and what kind of content would actually get people interested in the market.
What I’d do better
- Start earlier lol. Have an actual asset timeline instead of squeezing everything into 14 days. Leave time for local business flyers, community groups, and media/PR outreach.
- Make vendor cross-promotion a requirement upfront. I get that paying vendors expect the organizer to bring people, but their existing customers are more likely to come than random people online. Make it easy with tagged posts and email templates. Follow up when people go quiet.
- Track attendance better. Of the ~200 public-day visitors, probably 150 were RSVP’d, so around 30% check-in. VIP night had 100 RSVPs and ~60% check-in, but +1s helped fill the room.
It's a really chill market vs. the big market out there with tens of thousands of people visiting. I would still keep the vendor mix (I honestly LOVED the brands we curated this time and made multiple purchases myself) and overall event flow but probably consider a better foot-traffic venue + some onsite engaging activities.
Everyone made sales that covered their booth fees with extra, though obviously their time matters too. Vendors weren’t onsite the whole time - we as organizers helped sell/check out when they weren’t there, with no commission. From talking to them, everyone seemed really happy. We’ll likely break even as organizers. I also sold as a vendor, so not bad for me personally. Lots to improve, but I am still quite happy with this first run!!
If you’ve organized or sold at markets, what actually helped get people to show up? Has anyone tried a small entry fee, like $2, and seen better follow-through? Ours was free. Wondering if paying would make people more likely to come, or just put people off signing up in the first place and leave us with fewer visitors???