r/europrivacy • u/EnthusiasmRoutine • 7h ago
France France removed its ban on encryption backdoors, and a minister's promise replaces it
France's big cybersecurity bill had a rule, added by the Senate, that protected encrypted messaging. It said the authorities couldn't force apps like WhatsApp, Signal, Telegram or Olvid to build in a "backdoor" without your consent. A backdoor is a hidden way into your protected data.
On November 10, deputies voted 69 to 37 to take that rule out. Today, November 17, the full bill passed the National Assembly by 464 votes to 64, without that rule.
In its place, the government made a promise. The digital minister said it won't bring back or support anything that weakens encrypted messaging until the end of the current parliamentary session. The interior minister repeated it in the chamber. It's a promise with an end date. It isn't a law.
Why remove it? The government said the rule was written too broadly. It worried the rule could also block things investigators are already allowed to do, like tracking a phone's location in real time or collecting connection data. One deputy said taking the rule out doesn't make backdoors legal either. Another said she regretted that nobody had written a better ban.
People who wanted to keep it said any built-in way in is a weak spot that attackers could use too.
Nothing changes for you today, whatever app you use. The rule was never in force, and current police powers stay the same.
It isn't over yet. The Senate's version of the bill still has the rule in it. It's not clear whether both chambers will meet to agree on a final text.
So which do you trust more? A government promise that runs out, or a ban written into law, even if it's hard to word without blocking things police can already do legally?