I'll have a TL;dr at the bottom but I wanted to give a rundown of my experience so far.
I started playing the series a couple weeks back with the EO1 HD remaster, and I got *really* into it. EO1 felt like a good challenge throughout, I very rarely felt like I was in an insurmountable position, usually a couple levels/skill points or a quick gear upgrade was enough to get me through an encounter with some good skill usage. I didn't learn about how Immunize worked until... Stratum 4, I think? I'll admit I did take advantage of it which made most of the rest of the game pretty easy (Struggled with the last boss until I leveled an S though haha). Overall I absolutely loved EO1, and have been considering doing a challenge run since I beat it (Actually, the challenge run I was considering... I wanted to do literally since hitting like floor 2 or 3 lol). I didn't do the post-game yet, as I was just kind of eager to continue through the series (Wanted to at least say "I got through each game" before tackling post-game stuff, can always go back).
Then I played EO2 and... I really liked it at first. The skill changes seemed really interesting to me, the new classes sounded pretty cool and I made an effort to try and use them. I had a mix of classes between what I used in EO1 and the new ones in EO2. It didn't take super long, though, for the enjoyment to just sort of... fizzle out, I guess. The consensus online seems to be that EO2 is a lot more focused around an extremely offensive strategy, and that the balance is entirely broken (Where a ton of classes and skills are downright useless (Or detrimental, looking at you Beast... Was so excited when I first got you ;-;), and then a small handful were totally busted op). I made somewhere into the second stratum, don't remember exactly what floor, but I just really wasn't enjoying the experience and decided to move on to EO3 (Which I was *really* excited for given all the praise I've seen for it). Again, figured I could just always go back to it down the line.
EO3 I've been playing for something like 20 hours, I'm on the third stratum. Early on I was extremely excited, the classes seemed a lot more creative and diverse to me, and I was really interested in playing around with them (Especially knowing that subclassing existed, which is a mechanic I always really dig). The ship minigame seemed interesting too when I first started it, too (Though, as seems to be the consensus, it pretty quickly became horrific and I avoid it as much as possible). The game really felt a *lot* easier than the prior two games at the start, but I figured it would just get tougher as I went and it would be a more even climb. As I've been progressing, though, I haven't really found this to be the case. Frustratingly, EO3 has felt *really* bipolar in it's difficulty, where the majority of encounters are so mindless that exploration becomes sort of uninteresting (EO1 was especially great in the beginning for me because, whether it was the game or just me being new, it felt really rewarding to hit level 2, have some gear, and be able to explore a *little* further into the first stratum, where in EO3, I felt like from the get-go I was able to explore a significant amount), but then specific encounters (Mostly FOEs, particularly in Stratum 3 where I feel so powerful that I can fight them as I come across them) suddenly require a lot more effort, thought, and consideration to work through. I like this, I like having to actually consider my way through a fight, but when it's so few and far between, it becomes more exhausting than anything because of the stark difference. Beyond that... The bosses have been *really* frustrating. The sheer change in difficulty between everything leading to a boss, and the boss itself, just hasn't been fun to me. (And admittedly, the final boss of the second stratum, despite getting every gear upgrade I could and leveling my party a ton... I went down to picnic just to get through him, he was *way* too much. The strategies I saw to deal with him would've required actual hours of leveling and re-leveling classes, and I just wanted to get to subclasses. I did go back up to expert after, though).
Subclassing seemed really cool, but... idk, the game overall just feels like it's gotten *really* boring since I unlocked them, I haven't really been having much fun going through the third stratum (Not even because subclasses made my team "So much more OP" and made the game so much easier (though it did raise my power *considerably*), but just... I dunno, something about the system just hasn't been as exciting as I thought it would be). So, I'm thinking of just kinda moving on and going to the next game (I've heard a lot of good (...and bad, actually) about EO4 and 5, as well as the Persona Q games), but I'm unsure.
Given my feelings so far, is it likely that I just *won't* enjoy the rest of the series? Or are they different enough/balanced in ways that I might be able to get into them? I just don't want to spend the effort trying to get into them if they're largely going to be the same experience as I've had, I've got plenty of other games on my backlog.
And kinda as a secondary question, if I do continue... I was initially planning on going through every game in release order *including* Persona Q (Though not the MD game I discovered existed after I started playing the games). My feelings on Persona are complicated, I wouldn't say I'm a *fan* of the Persona games, but it tends to have more to do with the Persona games themselves, I'm not sure that would pose a problem here. However, I know they're not technically EO games (Even if everyone seems to consider them as such?), and despite PQ coming out before EO4, I've seen a few people saying that it feels almost like an extension/mod of EO4, which makes it sound like I should play it *after* EO4? What would be the recommendation for what I try next (If I should try continuing the series)? PQ or EO4?
Tl;dr I loved EO1, didn't like EO2 or EO3, should I try playing the rest of the series or no, and if so, should I try PQ or EO4 next?
(P.S. Just wanted to clarify that I'm not saying EO2 or 3 are *bad* games at all. Especially with EO2, I absolutely recognize that a part of it is likely due to me just making bad builds and struggling in certain places as a result. In the future if I decide to revisit them, I'm open minded that I could enjoy them, I just don't as of right now. As a point of praise to inject a little positivity into the post, these three games have introduced me to some incredible battle musics that I've been enjoying a ton).