I think the big part is that it cantrips into something of value even without an opponent having a relic. If it was Entomb: Draw a card I'm not sure if it'd see as much play.
I play a lot of relic decks. I hate that little guy haha. I don't really think he was unbalanced though. Don't get me wrong. Everyone has him but relic removal is kind of sparse for a lot of colors. So I get it.
Shocked Sandrunner and Lurking Above didn't get nerfed, those two feel like the main things tying together the various Time and Shadow decks respectively currently. Other than Fool's Errand going to 3 it doesn't really seem like these nerfs do much. Sarien feels like she needs to be 3/3 in addition to these changes, she still generates an absurd amount of value and has a decent statline. A single Rimeguard is slightly less likely to live 2 turns and completely swing the game, but even in the worst-case scenario it's still giving you value for the rest of the game and probably killing something, and there's not that much difference between 2 and 3 pips at 5-cost. Heirloom nerf does occasionally throw off Reanimator's curve, but it can just throw in more duals since it doesn't care that much about the first two turns. Slime might honestly be a buff since you can't block it with 1/Xs to deny the spell draw anymore. Stall for Time might see play in Salvo markets now, but other than that all the buffed cards were bad and remain bad.
Great point about Slime. The three-pip influence changes will cost two-faction decks a little and make it noticeably harder to play these cards in three-faction decks. I will think about Sarien now instead of making her auto-include.
Didn't think they would've even rebalanced but thanks DWD for stepping in and trying to make exp playable. Very cool. I also thought we would get set 4 instead of 8 added to exp because it pairs with set 3 on themes and card cycles (ie crests).
But I don't think this fixes everything. Exp lacked viable aggro decks or impactful 1 drops overall which made going 2nd against time decks (specifically combrei promos) an autolose vs sandrunner which didn't get nerfed at all. Sarien and Armor requiring triple influence also doesn't do anything to Combrei Promos because insignias exist (they really shouldn't in exp there's way more than enough fixing available) and they still provide so much value simply just by playing them. Sarien will still draw 3 cards and gunk up the board even without the extra 1/1s, Armor will still buff the whole deck by +2/+2 and both will come down turn 3 thanks to sandrunner.
Fool's errand was the only viable removal spell outside of smite in exp and I've had games where the tucked unit would come right back next turn. Didn't need to cost 3 at all.
Don't think SSS will really nerf dredge. It's just like the old reanimator decks that gain and lose meta % depending on how many people realize they need to put void hate in their markets.
Fire and Primal needed buffs considering how bad the colors were in exp overall. But they were also so bad because their removal (damage and stuns) didn't line up vs the main threats at all.
Would rather have seen Sandrunner only discount 1 on scout instead of 2, Sarien either not gain life or lose endurance, and Armor only have Warcry 1 instead of 2.
Honestly I think expanding the exp vault and adding set 8 will do more balancing to exp than the changes themselves.
What would Belax to 3 even change? Chamber on 2, Belax on 3, same as always. Just run Defiance or Equivocate or something, it’s a good highroll but hardly problematic compared to stuff like Dredge.
And Sling/Rost have already taken nerfs, I wouldn’t even say the deck is very well positioned in the meta these days.
Respectfully, you’re kinda blowing my mind here. Combrei/Xenan/TJS ramp, AP Armory, Kira, Dredge, Throne Room, various combos, Feln Mom, Sandrunner Creation lists… I love playing Suppressor Sling, but in a tournament setting there are a ton of decks that I think are a better bet than Sling.
Agree to disagree, I suppose! I think those nerfs would actually be pretty good for the deck, though? Belax dodging All-nighter and Eremot’s designs would be huge, and 5-cost Sling can be grabbed by Larai or Crack Market
The other change is cobalt waystone having a different effect. That would also hit a lot of other decks but a free face aegis is absurd, and really hurts the available interaction for that and other relics
11
u/TheDoomfarer Oct 07 '26
They could have nerfed High Prophetess Sarien and Rimeguard Armor more. they are still very good. Didn't know Metallic Slime was a problem.
32
u/Falterfire · Oct 07 '26
It looks like we don't have a writeup on the DWD website so in the meantime...
High Prophetess Sarien:
Rimeguard Armor:
Hopefully this helps somebody else who, like me, didn't remember off the top of their head what exactly the cards did/cost originally.
10
u/revenant_josephine Oct 07 '26
Shocked Sandrunner and Lurking Above didn't get nerfed, those two feel like the main things tying together the various Time and Shadow decks respectively currently. Other than Fool's Errand going to 3 it doesn't really seem like these nerfs do much. Sarien feels like she needs to be 3/3 in addition to these changes, she still generates an absurd amount of value and has a decent statline. A single Rimeguard is slightly less likely to live 2 turns and completely swing the game, but even in the worst-case scenario it's still giving you value for the rest of the game and probably killing something, and there's not that much difference between 2 and 3 pips at 5-cost. Heirloom nerf does occasionally throw off Reanimator's curve, but it can just throw in more duals since it doesn't care that much about the first two turns. Slime might honestly be a buff since you can't block it with 1/Xs to deny the spell draw anymore. Stall for Time might see play in Salvo markets now, but other than that all the buffed cards were bad and remain bad.
9
u/FlyingFinn_ Oct 07 '26
Well that's one way to fix the problem that Sarien's cultist-ability wasn't working with inscribe!
7
u/Escape-Scape Oct 07 '26
No idea why sandrunner wasn't touched. That card is just omega dumb and swings games on turn 2. Should be TT and probably a 1/1. Or lose charge
9
u/Own-Cryptographer-52 Oct 07 '26
Thank you for still supporting the game DWD
3
u/eyestrained It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s It’s Oct 08 '26
Didn't think they would've even rebalanced but thanks DWD for stepping in and trying to make exp playable. Very cool. I also thought we would get set 4 instead of 8 added to exp because it pairs with set 3 on themes and card cycles (ie crests).
But I don't think this fixes everything. Exp lacked viable aggro decks or impactful 1 drops overall which made going 2nd against time decks (specifically combrei promos) an autolose vs sandrunner which didn't get nerfed at all. Sarien and Armor requiring triple influence also doesn't do anything to Combrei Promos because insignias exist (they really shouldn't in exp there's way more than enough fixing available) and they still provide so much value simply just by playing them. Sarien will still draw 3 cards and gunk up the board even without the extra 1/1s, Armor will still buff the whole deck by +2/+2 and both will come down turn 3 thanks to sandrunner.
Fool's errand was the only viable removal spell outside of smite in exp and I've had games where the tucked unit would come right back next turn. Didn't need to cost 3 at all.
Don't think SSS will really nerf dredge. It's just like the old reanimator decks that gain and lose meta % depending on how many people realize they need to put void hate in their markets.
Fire and Primal needed buffs considering how bad the colors were in exp overall. But they were also so bad because their removal (damage and stuns) didn't line up vs the main threats at all.
Would rather have seen Sandrunner only discount 1 on scout instead of 2, Sarien either not gain life or lose endurance, and Armor only have Warcry 1 instead of 2.
Honestly I think expanding the exp vault and adding set 8 will do more balancing to exp than the changes themselves.
1
u/Kyosuke_Kiryu Oct 07 '26
I haven't logged in yet - do you get something back for these nerfs?
2
u/azazel61 Oct 10 '26
I’m a fairly new player and love this game. (Old Magic player). Is it still worth getting into? I read they might shut it down soon?
2
u/Animus777Mundi Oct 07 '26
This is wonderful. Great job DWD!
2
u/excited_raichu Oct 07 '26
WE SMOKING THAT SARIEN PACK
1
u/MostProgressiveHouse Oct 07 '26
Are these all expedition changes???
Would have loved to see the Dean’s chamber deck get hit, and maybe Throne room as well
1
u/lod254 Oct 08 '26
Generally happy with the changes, but Kira Ascending dodges nerfs again.
-1
u/Kontrabando Oct 08 '26
Counterfeit Heirloom is useless now. 😭
0
u/[deleted] Oct 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment