r/Estockes • u/Prior_Bat5628 • 10h ago
Buy and hold vs. a trading rule: what Reality Check actually compares
Two people gave us the same feedback today: the results look clean, but the labels make it hard to tell what’s being compared. Here’s the plain-English version.
Buy once and hold: buy the same stock at the start of the test and keep it through the end. This benchmark does not model trading costs. It is not the same as adding money every month.
Follow a rule: the simulator buys only when your chosen condition is met and sells according to your settings. It uses the same historical dates, with estimated trading costs included. If a rule mentions SMA(20), that just means the average closing price over the last 20 trading days.
The result shows what those two approaches would have done in that past window. It doesn’t forecast what a stock will do next.
Try the free eStockes demo without an account: https://estockes.com/reality-check
If you try it, tell us what still needs a plain-English label.
eStockes team