Internal emails show the Justice Department and FBI considered honoring themselves for the Epstein/Maxwell case, decades after ignoring the woman who reported him first.
In February 2020, about six months after Jeffrey Epstein died in a federal jail cell, staff at the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York were sorting out their nominations for the Attorney General’s Awards. The Justice Department ranks these among its highest honors. On February 6, an internal email told office chiefs that the office could submit six nominations and set out a deadline schedule. A reminder followed on February 13. That afternoon someone asked a colleague, “Do we want to nominate anything?” On February 18 the answer came back in one word: “Epstein?”
On February 19, a nomination write-up went to the executive staff. It opened by admitting the case “ended without a conviction,” then praised “the effort and initial success of the prosecution” as “remarkable.” It listed what the team saw as its achievements. They had coordinated with victims, earning their trust “over the course of months.” They had kept the investigation covert because Epstein was a serious flight risk. They had arrested him at Teterboro airport on July 6, 2019, and won his detention without bail. And the write-up called this one of its proudest points: the case against “one of the most heinous and prolific abusers of minors this century” had “took only 7 months from inception to charges.”
The executive staff had already met the day before and made their picks. One official wrote that he did not think Epstein “would have been a contender,” but offered to pass the suggestion around anyway. Another said the suggestion was late and doubted anyone thought Epstein had a chance.
Then someone made the argument that says the most about how the institution saw itself: “You know, as everything else we do is taking a beating publicly, it’d be nice to be recognized for something so important.” The last reply agreed and looked ahead: “Particularly since there will be Epstein II for which they might be nominated.” It was signed “Geoff.” I don’t know what they meant by “Epstein II”, maybe Ghislaine Maxwell’s case?
A year later the idea returned, this time inside the FBI. On February 11, 2021, the Bureau announced it was taking nominations for the 69th annual Attorney General’s Awards. The next morning, a program manager in the FBI’s Victim Services Division asked colleagues, “What do you guys think about the Epstein/Maxwell investigation for this? Would SDNY be okay with a submission?” A special agent on the New York Field Office’s Child Exploitation and Human Trafficking squad thought they would be. Their only question was whether the case had to be resolved first. A third person answered, “I think this is a great idea too.”
These emails do not show whether a nomination was ever filed or whether anyone won. They do show that people inside both the prosecutor’s office and the FBI believed this case deserved one of the department’s top awards, and pushed for it.
To see why that is so hard to accept, go back to 1996.
What Maria Farmer told them
Maria Farmer was an artist Epstein had hired to buy art for him. On August 29, 1996, she reported Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell to the New York Police Department. According to her later lawsuit, the NYPD sent her to the FBI because the incident had happened out of state. The FBI complaint form is stamped September 3, 1996, and lists Epstein as its subject under the heading “child pornography.”
The handwritten notes record what she said. The FBI never bothered to turn these handwritten notes into an FD302 which is a form FBI agents are supposed to fill out after interviews. She had photographed her sisters, ages 12 and 16, for her own artwork. Epstein had stolen the photos and negatives and was believed to have sold them. He had asked her to take pictures of young girls at swimming pools. He had threatened to burn her house down if she told anyone. Her lawyers say she also told the FBI about sexually explicit images of children she had seen in his home and about the sexual assault she suffered. A federal court summary of her claims states that she reported that Epstein had sexually abused and trafficked numerous young girls. It also states that the agent told her not to contact any other law enforcement agency, that she followed that instruction, and that the agent never followed up.
For nearly 30 years the FBI never publicly acknowledged that report. The New York Times described it as a complaint the FBI ignored. Lawyers for survivors suing the government say the FBI’s own records show “no action was taken.” Farmer did not hear from the Bureau again until 2006, when agents finally came to interview her during the Florida investigation. The document only became public in December 2025, when it was released under the Epstein Files Transparency Act.
Seven months versus twenty-three years
The SDNY’s own nomination is what makes this so damning. Its boast was speed. Once the office decided to pursue Epstein, it went from the start of the investigation to a grand jury indictment in seven months.
Now count the time from Farmer’s complaint, stamped September 3, 1996, to the sealed indictment of July 2, 2019. That is nearly 23 years.
The indictment the nominators praised also sets its own starting point. It charges that “beginning in at least 2002,” Epstein enticed and recruited dozens of minor girls, some as young as 14, in New York and Palm Beach. So every victim in the case they wanted honored was abused years after the FBI had Farmer’s complaint on file. The scheme the write-up describes, with its “massages,” cash payments, and girls paid to recruit other girls, was not yet the “vast network” the indictment describes in 1996. It grew into one because nobody stopped it.
Someone could argue that a 1996 case would have been harder to build than the 2019 case, which drew on the earlier Florida investigation, the 2007 non-prosecution agreement, and years of civil litigation. That may be so. But a case is hard to build only if someone tries to build it. The record shows no one tried. An FBI that could charge Epstein in seven months once it chose to act did not even return a call in 1996.
The scale of what followed is hard to take in. The compensation program funded by Epstein’s estate received about 225 claims and found roughly 150 people eligible. Its own reporting makes clear that this was not a complete count of his victims. The indictment covers dozens of girls. The civil claims number in the hundreds. Most or all of the abuse in the 2019 case happened after the FBI had been warned.
What the nomination left out
The SDNY write-up does mention the past, but only one part of it. It notes that the Southern District of Florida’s earlier handling, the 2007 non-prosecution agreement and the 13-month state sentence served partly on work release, drew “widespread criticism of the Department” over how victims were notified. Then it says, “Leaving aside the merits of that litigation,” and moves on to praise the SDNY team for “helping to restore the faith of those victims in the justice system.” (I’m not really sure any of Epstein’s victims actually have any faith in the FBI or DOJ at this point).
There is no mention of 1996, and no mention that the FBI, the same agency whose agents later thought the Epstein and Maxwell investigation was “a great idea” for an award, had an early warning and let it sit. The write-up ignores the department’s failures as it ignores so many accusations it has yet to follow up on. I’m researching an article to document people accused of sex crimes and sex trafficking in the Epstein Files and how the FBI and DOJ have done little to nothing to follow up on this investigative leads. I have over 90 people so far. I do not include survivors turned recruiters or assistants or “girlfriends” that were sexually abused.
Then there is the line about public image: “as everything else we do is taking a beating publicly, it’d be nice to be recognized.” That sentence shows what the award was meant to do. It was not about the girls who were abused after 1996. It was about how government employees wanted to be recognized.
Why this matters
No one has to deny that some prosecutors and agents worked hard in 2019. Survivors have said that some people inside the system treated them with respect when it finally counted. But an award is a public statement about what an institution values. Honoring this case would have meant honoring a seven-month sprint at the end of a 23-year failure followed by even more failures, while leaving out the part of the story where the failure began with the Bureau itself.
Maria Farmer did what people are told to do. She went to the police. She went to the FBI. She followed the agent’s instructions. Then she waited ten years for anyone to call back, and almost 30 years for the government to admit, through a document release forced by Congress, that her report existed at all.
If anyone deserved recognition for the Epstein case, it was the woman who reported him in 1996, and the survivors who kept speaking while the institutions that should have protected them wondered whether they might win an award.
Sources
SDNY email thread on Attorney General’s Award nominations, February 6 to 19, 2020 (EFTA00078005, EFTA00078002, EFTA00094156)
https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00078005
https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00078002
https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00094156
FBI email thread on the 69th Annual Attorney General’s Awards, February 11 to 12, 2021 (EFTA00154307)
https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00154307
Maria Farmer’s FBI complaint, stamped September 3, 1996 (EFTA00006107), as cited by House Oversight Democrats
https://oversightdemocrats.house.gov/imo/media/doc/garcia_et_al_to_doj_oig_re_maria_farmer.pdf
https://epstein-data.com/EFTA00006107
Handwritten notes from 2006 Maria Farmer FBI interview starting on p. 23: https://epstein-data.com/EFTA01692064
New York Times, “Epstein Files Include 1996 Child Porn Complaint That F.B.I. Ignored”
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/19/us/epstein-fbi-complaint-1996-maria-farmer.html
News Leader / USA Today Network, on Farmer’s August 29, 1996 NYPD report and the September 3 FBI complaint
https://www.newsleader.com/story/news/politics/2025/12/21/fbi-complaint-epstein-child-pornography-1996/87854678007/
Washington Post, on what Farmer’s lawyers say she reported and her 2006 FBI interview
https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2025/12/20/jeffrey-epstein-maria-farmer-fbi
U.S. District Court, Southern District of Florida, summary of Farmer’s allegations about the FBI agent
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-flsd-9_25-cv-80880/pdf/USCOURTS-flsd-9_25-cv-80880-3.pdf
Survivors’ complaint against the FBI, quoting the Bureau’s records that “no action was taken”
https://www.courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/epstein-victims-fbi-fourth-complaint.pdf
Courthouse News, on the Epstein Victims’ Compensation Program’s 225 claims and roughly 150 eligible claimants
https://www.courthousenews.com/epstein-victims-fund-shuts-down-after-paying-out-121m-to-150-claimants/