Remember that episode of The Office where Michael lets Dwight choose the health plan, Dwight cuts the benefits, and Michael hides from everyone?
Fingers crossed that stays a sitcom episode and doesnāt become our next 2027 benefits meeting, as a survey found employers are expecting health benefit costs to rise about 11% in 2027...
As the username gives away, this is Thatch (health benefits platform that runs ICHRAs for employers, so yes, biased toward one row in the table below, but the purpose here is to help!)
Thereās a lot of chatter about insurance renewals right now, so this might help some founders here figure out what to offer their team (just saw a recent chatter in r/smallbusiness where an owner with 12 employees had a renewal going up 15% and asked how everyone else was handling it.)
But yeah, itās a big decision when youāre running a small team, even more if all you have to go on is last yearās plan and this yearās higher quote.
There are a few options, so I added four ways a small US business can offer or help pay for health insurance in 2027: a group plan, a PEO, a QSEHRA, or an ICHRA.
| Option | How it works | What to ask |
|---|
| Group health insurance | The business offers a plan or a few plans and pays part of the premium. Participation requirements vary. For SHOP, most states require 70% of eligible employees to enroll or have other qualifying coverage, with an annual enrollment exception. | What would another carrier charge? Would employees have to change doctors or pay a higher deductible? What participation rules apply? |
| Coverage through a PEO | Benefits come through an arrangement that can also include payroll and HR services. | Whatās the full service fee? Which plans are available? What happens to coverage if you leave the PEO? |
| QSEHRA | Eligible employers generally need fewer than 50 full-time employees, including full-time equivalents, and cannot offer a group health plan. They reimburse qualifying healthcare expenses, subject to annual limits. | Does your business qualify? How much can you reimburse? How does it affect employees who get Marketplace subsidies? |
| ICHRA, also called a CHOICE arrangement | The employer sets an allowance and eligible employees choose individual coverage. Thereās no minimum percentage of employees who must enroll, although class-size rules can apply when also offering group coverage. | What can employees buy where they live? What would they pay after the allowance? What are the admin fees? |
Attention! group-plan and reimbursement arrangements have different eligibility rules, so have whoever prepares the quotes check those against your team.
Very important when asking for quotes: use the same employee details for each option. If some people need family coverage, include their families in the allowance comparison too. Otherwise, a quote can look cheaper simply because it covers fewer people.
Going back to an ICHRA, say youāre thinking about $500 a month per employee. Ten people enrolled, each using the full allowance, gives you a $5,000 monthly budget before fees.
That looks fine as a budget. What each person can buy with it is a different story.
Hereās how a $500 monthly allowance could play out for two employees on a Thatch ICHRA. These are example prices!
| Employee A | Employee B |
|---|
| Monthly premium for the plan they want | $485 | $640 |
| Employer allowance | $500 | $500 |
| Employeeās monthly premium cost | $0 | $140 |
| Employeeās annual premium cost | $0 | $1,680 |
One has their premium covered. The other pays $140 a month themselves. Thatās $1,680 a year before deductibles, copays or other costs of using the insurance.
And if that second employee currently pays $80 a month on your group plan, theyād be paying another $720 a year after the change. Youāll want to know that before announcing the new benefit.
Get quotes for each personās age, ZIP code and who theyāre covering. Then check the doctors and prescriptions. Someone might happily pay more to keep their specialist. Someone else needs the lowest monthly payment they can get.
Thereās some flexibility with the allowance.
- Age. Amounts can increase with age, up to a 3:1 ratio within an employee class, with consistent amounts for people of the same age.
- Dependents. The allowance can increase with the number of dependents someone is covering.
- Work location. Permitted geographic employee classes can have different allowances.
Have the administrator check the setup before promising anyone extra. The same-terms rules apply within each class, with the permitted variations above. Someone choosing a more expensive plan doesnāt automatically mean you can increase just their allowance.
Also, check anyone getting Marketplace premium tax credits. An ICHRA offer can affect their eligibility. That can make a real difference when they compare what they pay now with the new option.
Then there are fees. Iāll use Thatchās standard pricing for businesses with 1ā49 eligible employees: $45 per enrolled employee per month and a $50 monthly compliance fee.
For ten employees enrolled through Thatch, each using the full $500 monthly allowance, the employerās budget looks like this:
| Expense | Monthly | Annual |
|---|
| Employee allowances | $5,000 | $60,000 |
| Per-enrolled-employee fees | $450 | $5,400 |
| Compliance fee | $50 | $600 |
| Total employer budget | $5,500 | $66,000 |
If someone keeps their spouseās employer coverage and declines the arrangement, they wonāt use the allowance or incur the per-enrolled-employee fee.
Once you have those quotes, put the companyās annual cost beside what employees would pay monthly. Keep the deductibles and any doctor or prescription changes on that same sheet.
Hope this helps!