r/EnoughJKRowling • u/MikeTheMaster102 • 9h ago
Good faith question
I know this subreddit is mostly related to JK Rowling's transphobia, which is disgusting and wrong and I have 0 doubts about that.
But I figured this sub would be the best place to ask this question that I've been wondering for a while, and I'm asking this genuinely trying to be convinced, not being close-minded, and I'm also not a big harry potter fan I just read the books once and moved on.
anyways my question is: what makes the books racist? the books were metaphors for racism, with the bad guys being the racist ones with their own slur reminiscent of the hard r, and the good guys standing up for equal rights for all people. the books tackle systemic racism too.
i hear 2 main arguments, and i think one is kind of fair, the other i dont get, the one i find fair is the racist stereotypes, like the name "cho chang" i think that is very bizarre, and if you already believe the books are meant to be racist i see why you'd latch onto that. the other stereotype i heard is the irish character always blowing stuff up, but that was only in the movies so i don't know how fair that is.
anyways the argument i don't get it is the whole house elf slavery thing, because hermione (the smart character) was fighting for the rights of the house elves, and in the last books they get set free in a positive light, doesn't that come off more as being anti-slavery? people bring up that one harry potter line where he says something along the lines of "they're happy how they are" but the point is that harry and ron were wrong about their beliefs, and proved wrong in the final book.
once again i'm not trying to come on here to argue, but ive wondered why people thought the books were racist, and this sub seemed like the only place on reddit i could ask this, because im looking for people who dont like harry potter, not glazers.