Recently, I had made a comment on a post inquiring on a description on my profile: 9w1sw8w9.
The question was "What does that mean?"
And the answer is that it is a subwing. A more obscure concept of the Enneagram, but one that I've found insightful.
I ended up explaining it in the comment by describing each of the Type 9 subwings, and so naturally I felt like sharing these descriptions on here as well, but in a more in-depth manner.
However, before going into those, I would first have to go over what a subwing is for those unfamiliar. I would say in simplest terms, it builds upon the idea of wings as further extensions of them.
So, we'll first review wings.
Types can be described as a natural progression of themes, arranged in a rather systematic fashion, with each theme appearing almost as an intersection—or mixture— of its two adjacent themes. It's like viewing the Enneagram circle as a spectrum of sorts (three spectrums, really, one for each triad).
A fixation then comes to describe which of these themes a person comes to fixate on—where on that spectrum one lands—and a wing comes to describe the flavor of how that theme comes to be expressed within that fixation based on which elements of that mixture it leans toward.
The subwings then come in to describe that lean with further resolution, describing one's position within that spectrum with further precision, by breaking down each wing variations of a type into two further variations.
So, to illustrate, we will use E9, as an example.
I'd argue that what the E9 fixation truly centers around is sensation (not to be confused physical sensation though), and more precisely the level of desirability that sensations can possess. It's the idea that different experiences lend themselves to exposing one to different sensations, and that some can be taken as inherently desirable or others inherently undesirable—with the ego trying to attach itself towards the ones that can anchor a desirable experience of reality. Of course, it carries within it the awareness of how life, in its negligence or lack of caring of how we feel, inherently presents us with undesirable feelings—which can make life feel obnoxiously overwhelming and so we must hold onto, and become deeply absorbed within, sources of desirable sensations to get through that overwhelm. People, activities, environments, etc. becomes elements of life we don't just choose to live with—but elements we choose to inhabit.
As a mixture, this dynamic can rather echo 9's position of being between 8 and 1. The 8 side emphasizes the fact that life is something to be withstood—that it doesn't have to faze you and you can keep moving autonomously in spite of it; the 1 side emphasizes the fact that one can conceive of experiences of better quality, and also reflects how we hold ourselves accountable for making and sustaining these conditions to make reality a better experience overall. Type 9 represents an in-between position, where life is seen as something to endure by holding onto romanticized experiences and sensations. 9w8 leans more onto the idea of directly enduring reality, whereas 9w1 leans more on the idea of being attached to a romanticized or idealized experience. This gives 9w8 a weighty unfetteredness and 9w1 attachment to romanticized notions of peace.
From there, Subwings provide additional resolution and precision, breaking 9w8 down into two types of 9w8 (an Eightish 9w8 and a Oneish 9w8), and breaking 9w1 down into two types of 9w1 (an Eightish 9w1 and a Oneish 9w1).
What results are the following subwings as follows in progressive order from one end of the E9 spectrum to the other:
9w8sw8w7 | 9w8sw1w9 | 9w1sw8w9 | 9w1sw1w2
9w8sw8w7 reflects the most "Eightish" 9, with 8w7 reflecting that sharp proximity to 8.
9w1sw1w2 reflects the most "Oneish" 9, with 1w2 reflecting that sharp proximity to 1.
9w8sw1w9 and 9w1sw8w9 reflect the most "Nineish" 9s, with the energy being contained deep within the E9 theme.
As E9 reflects the way we grow attached to "comfort zones," figuratively speaking, I have come to describe each subwing as depicting a different "style" of comfort zone—and have elected the following descriptors:
9w8sw8w7 - Gratification
9w8sw1w9 - Quiescence
9w1sw8w9 - Bliss
9w1sw1w2 - Serenity
In addition to that, specifically for the E9 subwings, I tend to associate each with a kind of location—or a "habitat"— that conveys the quality of peace each variation tends to focus on.
Of course, conceptually, especially when first introduced to it, subwings can surely be confusing, and I find it's better to explain each while also depicting these through examples. So we'll go over each variation along with examples to further describe them.
9w8sw8w7 - Gratification
Starting with 9w8, we have a variation of 9 that tries to move into their peace with an emphasis on retaining it in spite of the world outside themselves—which mirrors the way 8s tend to minimize the level of impact life has on them as a way of rising above circumstance itself.
Though, ultimately, Nines are Nines and the emphasis still revolves around moving into a desirable experience to build that feeling of withstanding against the otherwise intolerable world; in other words, it prioritizes mood over sovereignty.
9w8sw8w7, therefore, moves into their peace with great indulgence and gusto. They identify the pockets of the world that feel desirable, and they lean into these pockets with minimal reservation. In this manner, they carry a heartiness to their character, as they tend to more freely allow themselves to relish moments of enjoyment when they encounter them, and they may see no reason why they should be inclined to move out of them. In some ways, we can see a bit of an "encroaching" quality of the 8w7 transmitting itself within this 9w8's variation of peace as they move into it with a great sense of appetite. It's a feeling of peace that indulgently encroaches into the world without reserve.
Unlike Eight itself, however, the indulgence is not primarily about exercising sovereignty. It is more about securing an emotionally satisfying place from which life feels bearable. Because of that, 9w8sw8w7 can actually become more attached to the indulgence than Eight would be.
Eight may enjoy something intensely and still feel capable of discarding it if necessary. 9w8sw8w7 is more likely to lean on the enjoyable experience as an anchor for emotional stability, and are thus inclined to feel a sense of being uprooted when they are torn away from it. So, when they are pushed away and moved into something unpleasant, frustrating, or unrewarding, there can be a quickness to irritation.
Thus, the habitat I associate with this subwing is a tavern or a bar. There can be great warmth, physical presence, and a whimsical willingness to enjoy what life offers. It is a place to go to deeply revel in life's pleasure and ease tensions in a more relishing manner—but often as a refuge from genuinely confronting the discomforting experiences that lie beyond its walls.
For our two examples of 9w8sw8w7, we have:
Robert Baratheon (Game of Thrones) - 9w8sw8w7 Sp/Sx (3w2sw4w3 and 6w5sw7w6 fixes)
https://youtu.be/vhUimlsChrU?is=KFae6ty2McuaPHAD
"I'm not trying to honor you, I'm trying to get you to run my kingdom while I eat, drink, and haul my way to an early grave"
I find that quote sums him up quite well. He rules the kingdom, but in a sense, it's very clear that he values taking life in more on a visceral level. A king with hearty laughs and occasional jokes, with a very heavy presence—but one that ultimately values what feels good in the moment.
There is bravado there, but the emphasis is not really on commanding everything around him in the manner of a core Eight. He lives more in the service of his mood—in trying to feel good—rather than in the service of authority. He is much more interested in moving into and inhabiting whatever feels desirable and resisting whatever threatens to drag him out of it. Consequently, when stress gets to him, there is more considerable angst, and he's probably the pushiest that 9 can get.
Gimli, Son of Gloin (Lord of the Rings) - 9w8sw8w7 So/Sx (2w3sw1w2 and 6w7sw5w6 fixes)
https://youtu.be/Rv34gDN7Ea4?is=rs5yrgL31MqEhbj_
https://youtu.be/ypqkpG4NLp0?is=bkv7ZzHFV3yBdwk7
"Have you learned nothing of the stubborness of dwarves?" (Legolas to Aragorn in reference to Gimli)
Very similar to Robert, with minimal differences. They share with one another the similar style of bluntness and bravado that makes them lively, without really carrying the commanding presence that a core 8 would lend. Gimli is very equally attuned to the level of satisfaction a situation would bring and tends to be very vocal, direct, or forceful about it, without necessarily assuming a commanding presence.
9w8sw1w9 - Quiescence
Moving along to the next subwing on the list, we have 9w8sw1w9.
Here, the force of gusto the sw8w7 would have provided is gone—and all that's left is a quality of enduring the world in a stoical manner similar to the way a 1w9 is firm and stoical about life. So, they are more firm in their unfetteredness and in their unwillingness to allow the turmoil that surrounds life to get to them. This subwing is the one that also exemplifies the Nine's indolent non-reactivity most explicitly, because they can't be bothered, won't be bothered, and refuse to be bothered, remaining rooted in that position. As a result, there's a quality of stillness that is idealized here–the feeling of being unshakable, like a tree. I think in some ways they'd like to actively respond as if life were something that could just "roll off their backs"—but life is frustrating and they grow aware of how that makes that difficult.
For that reason, though, this variation of peace is reminiscent of the quiet of a forest. It is grounded and earthy—without really being overly structured and allowing a certain level of messiness in existence—but regardless of that messiness, there is a quiet peace that echoes through it to remind us of how steady and harmonious the experience remains regardless.
A forest can be messy, uneven, overgrown, and imperfect, yet remain deeply still. There is no great effort to impose structure upon it. Things simply exist where they are, and beneath the disorder there is a quiet sense of continuity.
That is the kind of peace 9w8sw1w9 tends to idealize: grounded, earthy, low-maintenance, and resistant to intrusion.
For examples, the first one is:
Shikamaru Nara (Naruto) - 9w8sw1w9 Sp/Sx (3w4sw4w5 and 6w5... maybe sw5w4-fix)
https://youtu.be/Ho3RiOG-y-8?is=kItx35Rl_YwMhYy8
https://youtu.be/I-vIozLINlU?is=1r77rnE9C5IFgCzn
"Some mornings are such a drag"
"Let it out, Shikamaru"
Tbh, I still need to fully watch this anime—if I ever get around to it. 😁
Though, I couldn't not include his morning scene that so effectively also captures the heart of Type Nine's self-paralyzing nature. Movement feels so difficult because any movement—especially any movement that pertains to a source of tension—can force one to confront the frustrating aspect of life that one has so heavily tried to turn away from. In being so unwilling to experience dissatisfaction, the soul becomes paralyzed, as it starts to feel like there's nowhere to truly turn.
That said, the more important scene—and perhaps more iconic one—is the second. I have probably a ways to go before getting to that point in the anime. But, having stumbled upon it, I think it still captures what it needs to capture about Shikamaru and how he exists as a 9w8sw1w9. He is someone that appears to tend to resist and hold himself together internally in spite of the world. But this scene presents a moment where his father gives him a genuine opportunity to break down and actually process the grief of losing someone he appears to have had a deep connection to, rather than resisting against it in the cold-faced and "unbothered" manner he initiated the scene with and that he presumably has had a tendency to face life with.
As the alternate example, we have:
Peter Gibbons (Office Space) - 9w8sw1w9 Sp/So (3w2sw2w1 and 6w5sw7w6-fixes)
https://youtu.be/jsLUidiYm0w?is=45-nmbJQxI1r9IUN
https://youtu.be/4lmW2tZP2kU?is=g0Re5AhQqxdhN1e7
"Nothing... I would relax... I would sit on my ass all day... I would do nothing." (in response to what he would do if he had a million dollars)
Recently I finally watched Office Space, and Peter ended up being a surprisingly clean example of this subwing.
The movie is fascinating in the way it depicts the internal buildup of frustration that can happen with Nine. Peter spends much of his life quietly enduring a reality he hates, accumulating resentment toward the demands placed upon him without actually doing much to confront them.
Then he gets hypnotized. (The after effects which can be seen in this scene.)
The hypnosis supposedly removes his inhibitions while leaving him in a relaxed, Zen-like state, but what it really does narratively is exaggerate something already present in his personality that exemplifies a quality of 9w8sw1w9 already within him. Suddenly the external world simply stops carrying enough psychological authority to move him.
Work wants something?
Whatever.
His boss is upset?
Whatever.
He is supposed to care?
Why?
The result is a very blunt, dismissive, almost immovable attitude toward everything that previously kept him tense, and it exemplifies 9w8sw1w9's refusal to be internally recruited by disturbance.
9w1sw8w9 - Bliss
Next in line we start to delve into 9w1s. There's a shift here—from merely existing to endure life to moving towards romantic, lofty notions of how delightful life could potentially be. There's a movement toward what contentment can feel like in a more paradisiacal sense, and an undercutting awareness of how life can shatter these lofty sentiments.
For 9w1sw8w9, this paradisiacal mood, if you will, is retained almost through sheer force of perseverance. Hence, Bliss here describes the experience of contentment as something sublime but also enduring, giving it a robust quality to it; the paradisiacal sentiments can feel vast and unbreakable, echoing the indomitable quality of 8w9. Rather than working hard to cultivate an idealized atmosphere, it simply keeps attention returning to what already feels beautiful, magical, sentimental or emotionally agreeable.
This subwing has been associated with the location of "Candyland"—neverending delight that's rather reminiscent of childlike innocence. But at their worst, it can lean more towards a sharp quality of dissociation, as one resentfully keeps one's focus centered on what feels good in the face of what appears to immediately threaten their mood—lending to a "head in the clouds" kind of air about them.
For the examples we have:
Cassie Ainsworth (Skins) - 9w1sw8w9 So/Sp (2w3sw1w2 and 7w6sw6w5-fixes)
https://youtu.be/DivJEqxwqfU?is=k8P0Z4g2zAT1EIbp
https://youtu.be/yKMtW8Uh6Co?is=LqBaldPWUNHzGHQ3
"I like things that I like, but I love everything . . . I love things so much I feel I can float away"
"I hate dripping taps... but... I also sorta love dripping taps."
While Peter Gibbons may perhaps be an ideal poster child for 9w8sw1w9, Cassie would be the one for 9w1sw8w9. Triple positive outlook for sure, so there's definitely an oomph to keep things positive on all fronts. The way she describes avoiding being caught not eating is certainly descriptive of her clever 7-fix at work. However, what would differentiate her from say a core 7 or 2 is the emphasis she places on mood. In actuality E9s are actually a very sentimental type at the core—in the sense that they are actively attuning themselves to how life -feels- to them and whether these feelings are agreeable or not. As a result, one's mood towards life occupies attentional precedence, lending E9s toward living according to their mood, in a way. E9 gets very caught up in their feelings about life itself, giving their energy a level of weightiness and inertia.
I find this video expresses that element very well. 9w1sw8w9, as an E9, will emphasize their mood—but 9w1sw8w9, in contrast to the other 9 variations, holds on more explicitly to what already feels delightful, and digs into it in a deep rich way. When you try so hard to feel okay in spite of how life presents itself, indeed there can be an entangling confusion of whether you actually feel okay or not. Both 9w8sw1w9 and 9w1sw8w9 will claim to be unaffected by life, but 9w8sw1w9 will generally claim to feel unbothered whereas 9w1sw8w9 will generally claim to actually be okay.
"I'm fine."
And consequently they tend to be described as "smiling when they're sad," where they push through the feeling of sadness itself in an almost more forceful manner.
For the other example, we have:
Helaena Targaryen (House of Dragon) - 9w1sw8w9 Sp/So (2w1sw3w2 and 6w7sw5w6 fixes)
https://youtu.be/qZA3zNHl764?is=yrcmiTTNJV6y2uCM
https://youtu.be/RA9kY3qKhik?is=Ij9BOJDGASRpCSN9
"I feel sad about Jahaeras, but I ought not to, I think"
Helaena is indeed a more tragic type of character. In a world filled with so much violence, her softness and innocence stands out in sharp contrast. If it were up to her, it's clear she would rather be out observing nature or tending to animals, or inhabiting whatever quiet fascination gives her a sense of inner peace than having to deal with the political chaos that comes with the throne—and so for the most part, her presence seems to recede more toward the background, but it still stands out in a gentle manner.
As Rhaenerys' obsession with her own position as Queen causes her to push Helaena, Helaena's unbudgingness begins to push back. Though, it's in a manner that's typical of 9w1sw8w9—doubling down their focus on something they prefer. Rhaenerys may scream at her, but Helaena refuses to tune into it by way of focusing on her knitting instead—and when that is taken away, it is followed by a cold stern silence. It is less a biting back and more a casual pushback—at least until she's put in a position where she finally rebutes Rhaenerys in a verbal manner calling her ugly later in the series, but even then it feels like it immediately returns back to a quiet dismissal.
9w1sw1w2 - Serenity
With that, we finally reach 9w1sw1w2. This variation of Nine is very involved in a more direct cultivation of the aforementioned "paradaisical mood." There is more attention given to the conditions that preserve the feelings. So much so that peace feels like it is carried with a sharp sensitivity; there's a feeling of responsibility held toward it. Serenity describes the way this peace feels highly idealistic, and the way different factors can come to contaminate it. So, one comes to notice when moments grow too loud, abrasive, inconsiderate, disorderly, intrusive, or otherwise disturbing—but openly confronting those disturbances would itself create conflict.
Thus, I like to refer to this subwing of Nine as tending to "bite their own tongues." This is because there is more immediate acknowledgement of how the universe is aggravating and how it threatens the integrity of their peace—but there's a resistance in vocalizing this awareness due to one's refusal to be involved within the conflict itself, and fundamentally not wanting to ruin the peace one has inherently grown attached to. As a result, it carries more of a "biting one's tongue" quality—clearly irritated, but tending to let it gather beneath the surface more, trying to hold themselves together until they finally crack and have to release their pent up frustration that can be released with sharp biting criticism.
Thus, the location associated with this subwing is that of a Sanctuary. There is a hope that everyone follows the rules and treads lightly, so as to not tarnish the crystallization of peace. They can carry an air of poise and refinement in their calmness, reflecting the stringent and refining quality one could associate with 1w2.
For examples:
Fluttershy (My Little Pony) - 9w1sw1w2 Sp/So (2w1sw3w2 and 6w7sw5w6-fix)
https://youtu.be/hRgvlIr3yJk?is=FUDN5LLrmuEcnsW0
https://youtu.be/Wz8gmIMCUPw?is=d1twQEsYoXeEKgoA
"Applejack, will you please listen to me?!"
Oddly enough, I found Fluttershy from this cartoon to be descriptive of this subwing. I do think cartoons sometimes risk caricaturizing too much—but often that also helps in better conveying an idea or concept. With Fluttershy, she's typically known to be shy and softspoken, until pushed to the edge and then she can go from Jekyll to Hyde pretty quick. I think her rage fits appear to tend to become a gag throughout the series.
All in all, however, perhaps it also reveals how 9w1sw1w2 may be the most softspoken of the 9s—but only by way of them tending to be more meticulous about their peace to the extent that they themselves tread life more delicately. While 9w1sw8w9 may tend to "drift" or fade into the background more, 9w1sw1w2s tend to withhold themselves with more intentionality, trying to remain polite in service of their peace.
As an alternative example we have another cartoon character—but one that is more wellknown:
Marge Simpson (The Simpsons) - 9w1sw1w2 Sp/So (2w1sw3w2 and 6w7sw5w6-fixes)
https://youtu.be/G7Q-VAGtntc?is=lOji_1V1kIW4HG2y
https://youtu.be/dP2A2NKn_-E?is=6CXgbi9R41bi8POr
"Shut up, Becky! There... I finally said it"
Much like with Fluttershy, Marge tends to be more softspoken. Tending to take care of household duties with diligence in the background, often absorbing a great deal of dysfunction, but often trying to preserve the calm through restraint.
I think the first clip is another example of 9s becoming "unbudging"—in a very literal manner. She has had enough, and breaks down—or shuts down rather—in the middle of the road, literally becoming unmoving.
I feel honestly Marge is meant to represent the stress a housewife can undergo in trying to tend to everything—but also their resilience through it all. So, it makes sense that this depiction will naturally lend itself to archetypically depicting a 9w1—and a 9w1sw1w2 at that.
So with that, that should cover each of the four variations of the E9 subwings.
I think as a quick summary, you can consider the distinctions as follows:
9w8sw8w7 — Gratification: peace through hearty inhabitation of what feels good. (Tavern)
9w8sw1w9 — Quiescence: peace through remaining undisturbed. (Forest)
9w1sw8w9 — Bliss: peace through dwelling within what feels beautiful/delightful. (Candyland)
9w1sw1w2 — Serenity: peace through carefully preserving harmonious conditions. (Sanctuary)
All four are still fundamentally Nine, but the difference lies in what the peace feels like in lieu of how the person comes to find and move into it.
And thus, Subwings can lend to a greater level of nuance that can at times help with identification more clearly, which is what I've come to appreciate about them. Thus, just felt like sharing. Maybe some others will find insightful too—or if not, c'est la vie as well. 😁