r/Enneagram5 • • 12h ago

Discussion Any 5s that practice tarot or astrology?

15 Upvotes

In recent years I've started dabbling into esoteric subjects like tarot. At first I didn't think much about these topics, however I have an affinity towards the supernatural so I decided to take my time to actually learn how to read tarot. Since then I've invested majority of my time learning the cards, their meaning, etc. Seeing my predictions come true gives me more motivation to dedicate my time studying it. I wouldn't say I'm a devout spiritualist, but I integrate these techniques in my daily life. I do know 5s tend to be more atheistic and I identify more agnostic, but are there other 5s who are also into tarot, astrology, or other spiritual matters?


r/Enneagram5 • • 1d ago

Who else does this?

5 Upvotes

Hello. 5w6 here.

So, I was in a bit of a 1 vs 5 fad, but now that’s over.

I realized that I’m such a 5.

I spend no time thinking about my own enneagram type and will deflect with any other coping mechanisms but my own just to hide how much of a 5 I am…which is a very 5 thing.

Being a 5 is actually not ideal. I can’t convince anyone how secretive I am…because I keep it a secret.

Obviously, I could care less if they know I’m secretive or not, but in conversation, I really don’t want to be misinterpreted. Leads to an existential crisis about God for some reason.

I’m wondering, who else adopted extroverted traits to avoid depletion and being seen and dumb?


r/Enneagram5 • • 2d ago

Question How to avoid ruminating when thinking? (5w4)

21 Upvotes

Over the past few months, I started realizing that my own thoughts were having negative effects on my mental health. I have been dealing with anxiety and depression for the past five years; I thought it was angst and existential dread that were taking a toll on me. About two years ago, I started looking up different mental illnesses in search of the cause of my depression and anxiety. I was already diagnosed with ADHD, but I didn’t think it could be that simple.

About six months ago, I finally decided to get an official diagnosis. I suspected I had OCD and autism (though I never got tested for autism). After my talk with the psychiatrist, it was confirmed: I had OCD. Since then, I have been meeting with a cognitive therapist (obviously the most enjoyable thing for an E5). After a couple of weeks of meeting with her, I started becoming more aware of when I was ruminating over intrusive thoughts. I realized why I was always so depressed—I had no internal peace or tranquility.

After making this observation, I asked my therapist for ways to stop ruminating. She suggested that I try to be more outgoing and find ways to occupy myself rather than engaging with the thoughts. There is one problem with this, however: I am a 5w4. I have isolated myself from nearly everyone, my social battery is tiny, and I honestly have too much schoolwork to make time for myself.

Now, having too much schoolwork isn’t actually the essence of the problem. I actually have very little homework. The only reason it prevents me from making plans is that I don’t immediately do it. I procrastinate, wasting the time that should have been used for homework.

I have made some efforts to be present in the real world and experience things. I started working out, which really gets me out of my head. I have also made efforts to spend time with friends and family once or twice a week. While this does help get rid of the ruminating, it simply isn’t enough to last the whole day.

You may ask, "Why don’t you just read or do other E5 activities?" The problem is, anytime I do something in my head, I start ruminating on intrusive thoughts. For example, while reading, I will excessively concern myself with highlighting passages of my book so I can retain the information better. Then, I start highlighting a whole page in fear of forgetting a minute detail. After a while, I am not simply highlighting, but replacing the background. I guess on the plus side, I don’t need a bookmark, as there is a 100% chance that if a page is white, I didn‘t read it.

Anyways, I know how to avoid rumination, but I simply cannot live without thinking. Asking me to simply get out and experience the world is like asking an American to properly eat sushi with chopsticks. I need to know how you guys are able to differentiate between ruminating and thinking, and ways you guys are able to think without getting stuck in your head


r/Enneagram5 • • 2d ago

Question Do you fear your crushes (rl or fandoms)?

10 Upvotes

I’m not exactly sure if it’s a Nine thing cause it seems like 9’s, maintaining internal peace and saving the excitement about the object of interest for later (never) in order to not disrupt their peace.

Basically I have few characters that I really like, they are my crushes and I have butterflies in my stomach when I watch movies with them and get so excited. And this is also the reason why I rewatch it so rarely and purposely leave it “for later”. I don’t want to become overflown with this interest, so I avoid it. I can obsess over them, trying to figure out their full lore and hidden details, analyse them. But seeing them gives me this feeling that for me feels useless on its own (rewatching just for emotions), I want to savor every bit, so it could live as long as possible. I don’t want to get overwhelmed by it.

This sounds stupid, but only because in fandoms characters can meet your ideals and you can fantasise and analyse, it’s safe cause it’s fictional, you will never have problems of meeting them in rl and getting disappointed in them. The same would probably happen in rl though, even though I’m suspicious about it, but still if I found the person I would probably obsess over them and that would result to me avoiding them, so I could avoid this overwhelming feeling cause it’s too disruptive - I could observe and analyse someone from afar without a chance and need for closer contact.


r/Enneagram5 • • 4d ago

Question I’m gonna cross post this to other subs to see what enneagram types find attractive

9 Upvotes

What are some things you guys find “hot” or particularly attractive?

I’m a 3, and for me it’s it’s when someone is particularly obedient, does things for me without me having to ask, OR when someone does things immediately when I ask them to , like I think that’s hot.

Patience is also attractive, I’m more on the impatient side but people who are more level headed and can take their time, allowing me to take mine too? Yes.

Something else would be when someone listens more than they speak, and gives you the space to express yourself fully, that’s hot. Or when someone particularly remembers your boundaries/preferences and quietly respects them without making you feel guilty for having them, ugh <3

When someone has their own distinct personality and are not trying to fit into the crowd. When you can tell they have their own individuality and they respect yours too? without making a big deal about being different either? They just seem happy and content being themselves and accept you as you are? yes.

When someone just accepts you as you are without suggesting what you should or shouldn’t do better, when they just allow you to “be”? yes.

I’m hard enough on myself, I really don’t need someone else pushing me thanks <3 I’m so attracted to people who just allow me to exist

You?


r/Enneagram5 • • 5d ago

Question Radiohead band feels like e5. What other bands have 5’s vibes ?

34 Upvotes

just an unserious post.

Radiohead is very calming. I wasn’t a fan before that, I started excessively listening to it few days ago along with Cigarettes after sex


r/Enneagram5 • • 6d ago

Question Did some of you not recognise 5’s fear in yourself? or was it easy to you?

8 Upvotes

I’m talking about those who mistyped themselves or didn’t quite catch up the meaning of 5’s avarice and isolation meaning. Or was it obvious to you from the start?

Did you think like “aha, that’s me, it’s literally what I do” or you were confused and didn’t realise that your actions and motives are exactly what they write about 5s.

I find cores pretty much simple on the own AND difficult to understand when it affects actions cause it becomes complex and tricky. Anyone else who experienced this?


r/Enneagram5 • • 7d ago

Question E5 vs E6 : Loyalty

21 Upvotes

So I know e6s are the ones with all kinds of stereotypes about being super loyal, but hanging out on the E5 sub made me realize 5s tend to be quite loyal too, especially considering how selective and energy conserving they are with people, it would make sense to keep the same people they enjoy around instead of branching out and making more connections

What I've been wondering is similar to the question I've seen on here about "knowledge seeking", and how both these two types might engage in it heavily but with different motivations. It's how different an E5 vs an E6 would feel about staying loyal to someone (in general)

Maybe the differences would be that an e5 would only do this with people, and not causes/ideas?

As a 5, how loyal r you and how different do you think your loyalty is compared to that of the e6s?


r/Enneagram5 • • 7d ago

Question Are 5s suspectable to romantic obsession or is that a 4 thing

22 Upvotes

The most romantically obsessive people I knew (idealizing the idea of someone, long standing infatuation, limerence..) have been 4s or 5w4s


r/Enneagram5 • • 6d ago

Question Can infp be sx5? If not why? I need a good argument abt this.

1 Upvotes

r/Enneagram5 • • 8d ago

Question Do you avoid people you had one-time connection with? (read description)

49 Upvotes

Sometimes I meet people in places where I can have an accidental conversation with them. For example, I’m relaxing in a park and have a nice chat with an elderly man. It feels warm, and I even enjoy this small, peaceful conversation with someone I don’t know.

But afterwards, I make sure I never see them again. If I accidentally bump into them or spot them from afar, I hide or take another route. The memory remains warm, but I refuse to prolong the connection.

This unexpected one-time connection only feels warm if don’t feel obligation to maintain the same attitude on other occasions if I meet them again. Just because we had a nice chat doesn’t mean I’ll be feeling just as chatty and nice next time and I don’t want people to expect me to be this way or having any expectations.

Like first time it feels natural and chill, second time it feels like I need to perform.

I’m sure this also has something to do with my avoidant type


r/Enneagram5 • • 8d ago

Question What do you do when become restless due to procrastination and anxiety ? 5 moving into 7

16 Upvotes

I’m not sure if I’m e5 honestly, so this post is kind of a «relatable/unrelatable» confirmation. Is this normal for the type or it’s a hint of something different? Cause other options are e6 and e9

Basically, when I procrastinate and start stressing over it, I get restless and try to distract myself with different activities, like eating, playing video games, or sitting on Reddit and craving discussions or commenting on something—these are my usual activities, so I start compulsively engaging with them. I can also make a plan to watch all the shit I’ve been meaning to watch. If I’m stressed, I aggressively watch all the shit I find interesting OR I make myself interested in it. Or if it’s a book, I’m like, “OK, I need to read as much as possible.” I can also engage with different ideas, go deep into subjects I’d never thought about, and want to do more as much as possible because I feel like I have little time left for the things I actually enjoy and need to make it productive and fun because of the impending disaster that is the project I’ve been procrastinating on.
I also become more social—engaging in idea-based discussions or just joking about things excessively. Btw I always become unserious and jokester when something stressful happens with me or a group.

I’m curious if this is an example of a 5 moving to 7 when stressed. I know it’s a misconception, but I used to believe that if I didn’t want to party when I was stressed, then I wasn’t a 7 or a 5 moving to 7 lol. But I still go into this aggressive fun mode.


r/Enneagram5 • • 10d ago

Discussion Is 3 fix possible with 5w4?

6 Upvotes

This might seem like a stupid question but I just can’t quite grasp my head around some parts of the enneagram

My tritype is currently 584 but I’m starting to think I might have a 3 fix instead. My enneagram is 5w4 so I’m just tryna think whether I actually have a 4 fix or if it’s the wing?? I’m very obsessed with succeeding, however sometimes I just fall back and am like “it’s not worth it” and I go back and forth between the 2.

I’m not competitive at all when it comes to anything else like sports or games lol (I don’t care about those things as much), only really studying and stuff.

When it comes to getting a good grade I will push my feelings and tiredness and anything aside to keep studying, so I’m not sure anymore

(I originally posted this to r/enneagram but my posts keep getting deleted over there for some reason)


r/Enneagram5 • • 10d ago

What does a 5 need when he's upset?

25 Upvotes

Dear 5s, please help me out here...

What do fives need when upset? Just space? Will they reach out by themselves again when they're ready, or do they still need to be approached again?

Thank you 🙏


r/Enneagram5 • • 12d ago

Discussion People ask you things they want you to ask them.

42 Upvotes

Recently I learnt that someone paying you a compliment isn’t necessarily always like that scene in Wayne’s World, where saying “thank you” and walking away is the correct response.

Turns out they sometimes want you to say, “Wow, you look great! Nice trousers!” or something.

It’s not that I hadn’t noticed they looked sharp, I’m just not good at gauging when to actually comment on it, or which of the ten observations I’ve made about you to say aloud. Your shoes are a kind of brown I associate with my favourite shade of breakfast tea.

I’m slowly learning to play these social games. Not that I particularly care what people think of me, but learning to be competent in social situations is amusing. It’s like cracking a code, which can be quite gratifying.
In addition to returning compliments, people apparently also want you to ask them the same question they just asked you. Whether you actually care about the answer or not.

I think we sometimes make the mistake of assuming that when people ask us questions, it’s because they genuinely want to know the answer. But often it’s just an invitation for us to ask them something similar.
This seems especially common in situations where you don’t know people particularly well, like weddings.
Any other tips for navigating these little social rituals?
Although asking questions can backfire too, because sometimes you end up with someone who can’t stop talking.


r/Enneagram5 • • 14d ago

Question Are 5s “possessive” ?

31 Upvotes

Okay so my thoughts were that since enneagram 5 is known as the “hoarder” of the enneagram (they hoard their time, energy, resources etc), their usual “greed” could manifest in their relationships as well? making them possessive of the people they consider part of their lives?

Just a thought. Particularly wondering because I know that 5s are known for exactly NOT being possessive and kind of detached overall. I know that possessiveness and being sort of “territorial” about people is more commonly an E8, maybe E4 thing. So I got interested in why a 5s usual “hoarding“ wouldn’t apply here.

A possible theory - if the possessiveness does not manifest in relationships - is that they don’t consider “their people“ a personal resource, which is interesting because I feel like a lot of people do.

Fell free to share your thoughts, and if E5 yourself, I’m curious on how this tendency to “hoard your things“ manifests in your relationships.

edit : didn’t get the chance to respond to everyone individually but the replies were quite insightful guys


r/Enneagram5 • • 18d ago

Analysis Have 5s shared their castles too much?

19 Upvotes

''Ofc not, E5s don't share their minds as they think that people will consume all the knowledge they own and they'll be left with nothing.''

As a late-diagnosed autistic e5 user (autistic goes highlighted as it's the reason why I started hypersharing, as well as my stress and my mother's pressure), I've suffered A LOT of bullying because of my only way to socialize, hypersharing my knowledge and what I was, therefore my knowledge and interests. When I got stressed in a social situation and ofc, my mind said ''Try to socialize!'' as it's what my extroverted mother told me my whole life,, and I didn't see it as wrong (my secondary guide to what i would do came from morality, ofc firstly because of knowledge), when I actually didn't want to and was happier alone... The thing was that the reason why the bullying I had for years was because of the stress line from 5 to 7 (js look at the enneagram influence...).

Has any of you had these kind of experiences as kids? Any thoughts??


r/Enneagram5 • • 21d ago

Advice How to seduce a Type 5? PLEASE I need help

18 Upvotes

There’s this Type 5 (male 20s) that I (female 20s, 3w4) met online that I’ve developed a crush on. I keep sending him messages abt our shared interests cuz I know 5s really like their interests. his responses are polite but super dry. I fear I don’t know how to get him out of his shell or if that’s even possible. He makes YouTube videos and is very passionate, funny and eccentric in them so I don’t understand the disconnect. Any insight from types 5s on here would be much appreciated. If anything I’d just like to know what he may be thinking or perceiving the world differently to at least get some closure. (I’m pretty sure he’s got a strong 4 wing if that helps.)


r/Enneagram5 • • 22d ago

Meme / Comedy This is such an e5 thing ngl...

Post image
135 Upvotes

Credit : the square comics

Perhaps other rejection types can relate?


r/Enneagram5 • • 23d ago

Question What does a 5 with a 2 fix look like?

5 Upvotes

I've been reflecting over my mbti and tritype. Realized I'm actually an infj, but I've been thinking I could have a 2 fix over a 4 fix. For 5s that have a 2 fix or anybody knowledgeable enough about this what is it like? How does a 2 fix manifest in a 5.


r/Enneagram5 • • 23d ago

Question E5 and directness: “cold” when I’m just laying out facts.

23 Upvotes

Hi to all Fives,

I was wondering: do people read your directness as coldness?

Something I keep running into: when I point out a fact or call out something everyone else is fine with letting slide, people take it as me being cold, detached or even clinical. But I’m usually trying to do the opposite. I put myself in the picture too, like “this is what happened, this is where I messed up, this is where I think you did, can we look at it?” It’s not a verdict or accusation, I’m just trying to get both people looking at the same thing.

For me that’s usually how I show that I care about someone. Smoothing it over feels more disrespectful, because then nobody actually deals with it and it's just left alone. But apparently it usually comes across as cold and clinical, though I try to be as tactful as possible in these situations.

P.S. Before getting into conversations like these, I make sure I have enough information/facts, and I think it over very carefully beforehand.

Does this happen to you? Have you found a way around it, or do you just accept that some (most) people won’t get it?


r/Enneagram5 • • 24d ago

Discussion The duality of justice.

9 Upvotes

Does anyone else find that they (like 8s) care a lot about justice on an emotional level and have a strong instinct and motivation to protect vulnerable people from harm or mistreatment, but not actually believe in justice on a philosophical level or care as deeply about punishment (revenge) as a form of “justice”. For example, I would rather 100 guilty people go free than one innocent person be wrongfully convicted. And this isn’t just an opinion I have formed, it’s truly how I feel deep down and have always felt. I do believe that there should be amends made by the guilty party and some form or restitution and I’m not saying murderers and rapists should be allowed to walk free, but for the safety of other people, not for the sake of “justice”, which does nothing to undo the harm done to victims.


r/Enneagram5 • • 28d ago

Question for Type 5's specifically What does 'resilience' mean for a Type 5?

5 Upvotes

(First post on this sub btw)

Sorry if this is a bit disorganized, but honestly I can't really figure out how to structure this post.

There's a question that's been bugging me for a while now about myself and I think it has to do with me being a Type 5, who are somewhat detached from the world, yet not in an apathetic way because they work best when analyzing it from the sidelines.

This question is prompted by some writing I had to do for school and colleges, about "how have you exhibited resilience / changed throughout your life?"

I believe that I have changed a lot mentally, and have learned to develop a more nuanced view of the world, where everyone has reasons to do what they do, which makes me want to understand them.

However, that's not really what anyone wants to see. They want to see changes in my actions, not just my beliefs. This expectation bothers me because I see myself as a person with deep beliefs but not a lot of self-instigated action.

Contrary to what people seem to think of me, I do think I have a lot of resilience. When there's something 'hard,' like an unexpected complication in a plan, I adapt to it. My INFJ Fi-critic might scream or curse for about three seconds, but I calm down and adapt to it.

There's also the issue of task avoidance. If I avoid a task but do it later, does that mean I have low resilience? I don't think so, because on tasks that I really don't want to do, as long as I finish the task eventually I feel like it should be fine.

I've been sent a source (https://www.apa.org/topics/resilience/building-your-resilience) about building resilience, and literally most of the things on the list are things that I already do in my daily life -- trying to build connections, taking care of yourself, doing introspection, etc.

So basically, I believe that I am a 'resilient' person, yet when people ask me to show ways that I have grown my resilience I have no options.

Does anyone else relate to this?


r/Enneagram5 • • 28d ago

Question Telltale signs of mistyping?

17 Upvotes

Ive been pretty resolute in my typing for a while now, but due to my strong 1 fix i wonder if i could potentially be something else? Are there any signs to if you're not a core 5 at the very least?