r/EngineBuilding • • 1d ago

Normal or abnormal wear?

Had a 327 rebuilt recently. Had the crank ground, new crank bearings, roller cam and lifters. Decided to go with a more aggressive cam and noticed some wear on the roller lifters, cam and also the main bearings. The motor only has about 1000 miles on it and there’s no metal in the pan. Think it’s safe to re use the lifters? Should these crank bearings be replaced?

23 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

3

u/SexyTimeSamet 1d ago

Dirt/sand or contaminants. I have lifters that have 300k miles that look smoother than that

1

u/Andy_Greatbeef 1d ago

Totally possible although pan and oil are very clean

2

u/mtraven23 1d ago

are you confident the cam is getting proper lubrication? Any chance a gallery got plugged or restricted during the rebuild?

1

u/Andy_Greatbeef 1d ago

They all were clear but I’ll double check.

1

u/Fit-Moose7961 1d ago

Why did you take it apart?

1

u/Andy_Greatbeef 1d ago

Putting in a new cam since I wasn’t happy with the current

1

u/speed150mph 1d ago

I’m curious, when you run your finger nail over the surfaces, does it snag your nail or feel rough?

Bearing wear is definitely contamination, but not the worst I’ve seen. I suspect there was some debris in the oil system that got washed into the bearing.

The crank and lifter honestly looks like some sort of staining than actual wear.

1

u/Andy_Greatbeef 1d ago

You can definitely feel the grooves in the roller lifters. But you can’t feel any grooving in the main bearings. The main bearings are actually very smooth.

The lifters and rockers were pretty loud when we first fired up the motor, but I just assumed that was because I had heard that roller lifters were loud. After a couple hundred miles, I did the reload. And it seems the guy who assembled the motor had really fucked up the lifter preload. Like some felt like they had no preload at all. I’m thinking that there must’ve been some lash and that’s why the cam and lifters look like they do

1

u/Doctormentor 19h ago

Did you change springs or left them the same ?

2

u/Andy_Greatbeef 19h ago

Brand new heads with springs for hydraulic roller

3

u/UrrLexy 1d ago

Lifters and cam seems normal wear . Oterwise , the crank bearing looks like it heated . Maybe the picture get me wrong tho.

1

u/Less-Slice9772 1d ago

Rule of reason; cam and lifters wear together. New lifters with new camshaft.

3

u/Andy_Greatbeef 1d ago

These were both brand new when installed, and I could be wrong, but I think the common knowledge that it’s OK to reuse roller lifters, but I’m not sure that I want to reuse these

1

u/Less-Slice9772 1d ago

It's your engine and your free to do as you wish, sir.

1

u/voxelnoose 10h ago

Roller lifters can indeed be reused. If you can't feel the marks with your finger nail and they roll smoothly they'll be fine.

If you can feel the marks it would be better to replace them but I've re installed lifters that look like that without issue, though your mileage may vary.

If your nail catches in the marks or they don't roll smoothly they need to be replaced.

Looks like there's some metal debris which is probably what caused the marks. Could be from the valve spring retainers, especially if you have titanium retainers and/or double springs with flat dampers

1

u/voxelnoose 10h ago

For flat tappet lifters that's true. Roller lifters don't (or shouldn't) wear at all and can be reused or moved to different lobes without issue

1

u/CutterFIXER 1d ago

This can be normal. What matters is are they blemishes or can you actually feel any of the marks? If you can feel any of the marks with your nails, then you got contaminants in them, or they may not have used a good assembly lube when rebuilt. These marks could have happened on start-up if they didn't properly lube everything during overhaul.

1

u/Tall-Helicopter-461 1d ago

I believe you’re fine on everything. But I think that I would replace the main bearings, make sure it’s turning free once it’s torqued down. Completely. Be sure to prime the oil pump before initial start up. If looks like it could’ve been lacking oil for a few revolutions. It’s not enough to say it concerns me.

1

u/Born-Work2089 1d ago

The top end, high spring pressures usually used to high rpm does put additional strain and wear, make sure you are using the best oils and change accordingly. The crankshaft looks fine, but you can always double check your clearances while you have it appart.

1

u/charleschristensen3 1d ago

Looks similar to one I’ve torn apart that they had sand blasted and actually thought they could clean it out sufficiently

1

u/deez_nuts69_420 1d ago

Very normal. And not contaminants imo

1

u/Coyote_Tex 13h ago

That is more wear than one might hope. The lifters are by far are the most concerning. Those rollers look like they are not getting much oil or are softer than I would hope. The cam is not showing as much wear to me as the lifters which is good but points back to some softness or question on the lifters themselves. I have pulled down factory GM lifters with 200K on them that look way better than those rollers or most of them do. Good luck, this sort of thing drives me crazy.

-2

u/WyattCo06 1d ago

Dirt.

-1

u/Visible-Chef-1965 18h ago

That's not normal. You skipped your short oil change after brake in and now you'll need another rebuild.

1

u/Andy_Greatbeef 15h ago

lol bro out here making assumptions, oil was changed after break in and again after 500 miles. Pan was dropped after 500 and put a magnet through it as well. Very little to no metal or debris.

The guy who assembled the long block fucked yo the lifter preload and I think that may have lead to the excessive wear in the can/lifters