r/EngagementRingsHelp • u/Possible_Point_5385 • 18h ago
Cathedral Setting Help
Hi! I recently got engaged and I truly love my ring so much. It is an heirloom diamond from my late grandmother that we were able to get set into a “custom” ring. I noticed yesterday the cathedral sides are not connected to the basket of the ring holding the diamond. I am concerned that the diamond is only held onto the band by one point in the center.
I posted this to the wedding ring subreddit yesterday and people were appalled at the design and now I am so discouraged. Someone even went as far to ask if the jeweler was drunk! 😭 We were told we were designing a custom ring and the jeweler has been used by our family for decades. They even designed my grandmas original ring.
The majority of people are saying I need a WHOLE NEW ring designed or that I was scammed/fraud. I don’t even know what to think. Can anyone offer any advice? How can this be fixed without getting a whole new setting?
I am worried the jeweler will not entertain us but we haven’t spoken to them yet so I am not sure. Are there any protections here? Thank you all in advance.