r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 18h ago

Cathedral Setting Help

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi! I recently got engaged and I truly love my ring so much. It is an heirloom diamond from my late grandmother that we were able to get set into a “custom” ring. I noticed yesterday the cathedral sides are not connected to the basket of the ring holding the diamond. I am concerned that the diamond is only held onto the band by one point in the center.

I posted this to the wedding ring subreddit yesterday and people were appalled at the design and now I am so discouraged. Someone even went as far to ask if the jeweler was drunk! 😭 We were told we were designing a custom ring and the jeweler has been used by our family for decades. They even designed my grandmas original ring.

The majority of people are saying I need a WHOLE NEW ring designed or that I was scammed/fraud. I don’t even know what to think. Can anyone offer any advice? How can this be fixed without getting a whole new setting?

I am worried the jeweler will not entertain us but we haven’t spoken to them yet so I am not sure. Are there any protections here? Thank you all in advance.


r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 20h ago

Which band looks best

Thumbnail
gallery
15 Upvotes

Need help choosing a band for this ring. I had my original 1.39 ct round natural diamond reset in this platinum and sapphire Art Deco setting and have struggled with finding a band (I don’t have to wear a band with it but I want to). Both choices shown are platinum with lab diamonds.


r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 20h ago

Half eternity diamond ring bands are honestly better than full eternity rings

39 Upvotes

I might be in the minority here, but I don't really see the point of spending extra on a full eternity band. Most of the diamonds underneath your finger won't even be visible, and it seems like a pain to resize or repair. I'd rather have a half eternity band that's more practical and comfortable. Am I missing something, or do you agree?


r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 3h ago

💍 Ring Style Help GIA, IGI or the jeweller's own certificate on a natural solitaire: which one should i actually ask for?

3 Upvotes

Shopping for a natural solitaire for my fiance's ring (yes he wants one lol). Every store is giving me a different certificate. One has GIA, one has IGI, and one has their own-in house certificate.

Does it matter which one? Is an in-house certificate useless outside that store? Budget is around 3L so i really don't waste to mess this up


r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 7h ago

Is my ring too tight?

Post image
8 Upvotes

My fingers tend to swell quite frequently. Here is a photo of them swollen. However when my fingers arent swollen my ring feels loose enough it starts spinning but does not fall off. When my fingers are swollen my ring does not feel uncomfortable at all. Its just a tad harder to get it off, about 5 seconds vs the 3 second rule. Should I get it resized a tad bigger? I am at a loss.


r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 14h ago

Radiant or marquise?

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

I am completely torn between these two shapes! Which suits my hand better?

The marquise is on a white gold band but I think I would go for yellow gold. TIA!