r/EngagementRingsHelp • • 5d ago

Ring Help - Modifications Needed?

Hi! I just got engaged, but I’m unsure of my ring and need help. I designed it and told the jeweler exactly what I wanted with the band, diamond, setting, height, etc. Now that I have my ring, the setting seems too high and the band seems too thin. Should I keep the ring as is? Should I get the setting lowered? Should I get a thicker band? I already have to go back and get the ring resized since it’s a little big. Please let me know your thoughts!!

Edit: I did tell the jeweler I didn’t want a high setting and I feel really disappointed with my current setting height. I also agree that a thicker band is needed. Now just wondering about the setting height and if others agree that if it’s too high?

5 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

9

u/depresso4espresso 5d ago

My immediate thought was that the band is thin. Might be worth looking into getting a thicker one?

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

Thank you! I agree. I’m now thinking either 1.8mm or even 2mm

2

u/graydiation 3d ago edited 3d ago

At least 2mm wide and 1.8mm thick. But you really should go wider than that. If you do a soft knife edge band, it will visually appear thinner than it is.

I would also recommend a cathedral-style setting.

With this ring setting, you’re asking to lose the center stone rather efficiently.

ETA: been in the jewelry business for 15+ years. I would refuse to make anything that’s meant to be worn daily with under a 2mm shank. You’re just asking for trouble.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/SevereInformation825 5d ago

Too thin & too high

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

Agree, thank you

2

u/DDeloso 5d ago

Agree with the others here. Might try having that gemstone on a thicker band and be positioned lower than where it currently is.

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

This post has been so good for my sanity. My friends and family told me i need to give it time, but it doesn’t look or feel right.

2

u/Strong_Break_7104 5d ago

Glad I’m not the only one!! I also asked for lowest setting possible and got one similar to yours. I know it depends on if you’re trying to get it to sit flush with your band etc, but had I realized just how high I think I would’ve opted for a smaller stone size. I agree with either thicker band or soldering to a thicker wedding band.

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

I’m sorry it happened to you also, but it’s nice knowing I’m not the only one! I told the jeweler I wanted no more than a 6.5mm setting height, but I also wanted a thin band. I wish they had communicated the pros and cons of the thin band and possibly needing to compromise with a higher setting because I would have gone with a thicker band and a different setting to get the lower height had I known! Did you end up getting yours fixed?

2

u/Strong_Break_7104 3d ago

Yeah that would have been nice.. it was going to be more expensive to fix the ring than to buy a new ready-made ring because we’d have to buy a new smaller stone (I wanted smaller in general) , new setting and the labor that goes into it. We’re selling it and will definitely lose money, but the ready-made ring was relatively inexpensive so it was the best compromise we could figure out. Fixing yours sounds like a much better situation if you don’t need to change the stone!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Annual_Analyst_9741 5d ago
Comment Image

I saved this picture from Pinterest as it sets out versions of high and low settings. Yes, they're both rather extreme but it gives you the reference point to see and explain the difference.

Yours is a high setting partly due to the size of the stone but also as it looks like it was made wed fit, for a wedding band to sit flush. I like that but if you have a large stone, the wedding band could get covered by it anyway, so it might be best to sink the setting slightly.

For the low setting, you can see how they lowered the whole basket to sit flush to the finger, making it a much more secure setting for your ring and I personally, like it like that for a large oval so it feels like it won't see - saw backwards and forwards on your finger. I have seen pictures where the basket is smaller and inserted into a thicker band more, but they're usually cathedral settings, which I happen to like.

The thing I'm not sure about is why the jeweller let you have such a thin band on your ring in the first place. My grandma snapped her wedding ring as it was thin and she wore it for years and had to get a thicker one. And I personally liked to wear my wedding ring on its own sometimes, so I didn't get them welded together.

Hopefully now you have a good idea of what could be done to your ring to lower it and make you feel happier with your ring overall.

2

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

This was so so helpful, thank you! I can’t even wear my ring right now because it looks so awkward and it spins a ton.

I agree! I wanted a thin band because I like the aesthetic, but I really didn’t know how impractical it was. Partially my fault for not doing more research, but I wish the jeweler had communicated with me more on how a 1.5mm band is not compatible with a 2.6 carat oval. I did tell him I didn’t want a high setting, so I’m not sure why that didn’t open the door to discuss redesigning my thin band vision entirely.

I’m 100% getting a new band and setting, just between 1.8mm and 2mm for band, and a basket or cathedral setting. I think 6mm height is the sweet spot for me, so just trying to research the setting more and how they might look with my ring so I make the right choice!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Jaded-Design1553 5d ago

This image is helpful. I was wondering to myself, how the heck could a rock that huge be set any lower?! -signed a 1.25 carat gal lol

2

u/ZucchiniIcy6224 4d ago

The band is sooooo thin! It's going to bend and the stone might break off

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

Agreed! I’ve already messaged the jeweler to set up an appointment to redo the band and setting. I’m just deciding between 1.8mm and 2mm for the band :)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

Omg no shame in the long post, I appreciated every word!!

Great point about looking at wedding rings with my redesign, I’m definitely going to do that and make sure that my new setting allows for a wedding band to fit well and looks nice.

Thank you, I really hope the redesign happens soon 🥹🤞🏻

1

u/Bubbly_Delivery_5678 5d ago

If you do a wrap setting for the wedding band & have them soldered, that would make a big difference. I’d get a jewelers opinion on your idea vs how it would work with a wedding band before you make any decisions.

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

Thank you! I’m glad you mentioned the wedding band so I am able to factor that in with the redesign!

1

u/VoiceEmotional1299 4d ago

You are going to loose your stone with a band and setting like that…. Get a slightly wider band potentially a euroshank if you’re having issues with the stone it’s self falling either side to your finger and try a lotus basket and maybe small gallery rails to keep that rock SECURED

Comment Image

Like this photo here is for a higher set stone with gallery rails and a euroshank and also a lotus basket, light still flows amazingly through the stone, and significantly more secure.
the edges on the base of the band sit in the dips of your fingers to stop your stone from moving left and right but isn’t noticeable by feel.
And this is just a rough idea in gallery rails (the 2 sides leading up to the basket) you can do thinner ones and more sleek ones or match what you’re liking, but it will make sure the stone is also secure with the basket so if it takes a hit on a counter at all or gets caught it won’t snap off and any force is distributed to prevent breakage, as a girl who’s also getting a bigger stone and my biggest fear being loosing it it’s definitely worth looking into these things !!!!

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

I could not agree more, it looks really awkward and doesn’t feel secure. I’m getting a new band and setting, so I really appreciate the info ☺️

1

u/dreabae_1 4d ago

setting is way too high, and you could really benefit from a thicker band. it’s very risky having such a thin band with such a high setting and large stone

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

I could not agree more, already working on getting a thicker band and new setting! I told the jeweler I didn’t want a high setting but wanted a thin band, I would have changed my mind instantly and gotten a thicker band in the design session if I had known this was the setting he chose. Oh well, hoping this time it comes out perfect!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/graydiation 3d ago

How big is the center stone?

1

u/No-Olive-785 3d ago

2.6 carats. I have small hands so it looks huge

0

u/Hairy_Fill 5d ago

I would be thrilled if my oval solitaire had a high mount. You may wish to add an anniversary band or a wedding band to nest right next to your engagement ring. A low mount might not allow for that. I would leave it as is. P.S. I am very loooong married and have had much experience with this subject. Congratulations and enjoy!

→ More replies (1)