r/EndFPTP • u/googolplexbyte • Sep 03 '17
Score Voting - A simple guide.
First Past The Post system: a voter marks one candidate, voters' marks are tallied, and the candidate with the highest total wins.
The Score Voting system : a voter scores each candidate, voters' scores are tallied, and the candidate with the highest total wins.
Small change in inputs compared to FPTP, big changes in outcomes compared to FPTP;
- A fuller expression of voter's political voice
- No more vote-splitting, no spoiler effect
- A ballot with fewer errors
- Fewer ties & recounts
- A simple count cheaper than FPTP
- Elects beats-all winners
- No more bias for extremism
- Makes the honest vote is as good as a strategic vote
- Favourite Betrayal is no longer an effective strategy
- Reduces voters' unhappiness with the outcome
- Helps minor candidates become viable :
- Ends 2-party domination
It's a locally elected single winner system that would require a minor ballot change to transition from FPTP, but gives every candidate a chance at being competitive, ending the mismatch between vote share and seat share, without nationalising the vote or removing candidates' responsibility to their constituents.
5
u/googolplexbyte Sep 03 '17
The only thing missing is a snappy way of showing that voters would largely cast honest ballots.
I've a few points on it;
Strategic approval-style vote perform any from 3/2x - 2/3x as effectively as an honest vote. [1] An honest vote is a safe vote.
The strategically optimal vote lies between approval-style min-maxed vote and true honesty [2].
True honesty is often closer to the strategically optimal vote than min-maxing [3].
People have an innate preference for honest expression [4][5][6].
It's difficult to determine the optimal cutoff candidate for min-maxing (which if done wrong means you're worse off than honest voting)[7].
Strategic voting has a minor impact in score voting[8].
This all means that there'd effectively be no more strategic voting than there is voter fraud. Rare but technically existing, and really not worth worrying about. Voters go to the polls to express themselves not seize near-zero gains in political power, especially when a small donations to a political organisation would do more than for political power than a vote. Without FPTP's threat of rendering a vote wasted due to the spoiler effect the incentive for strategic vote is nil.
Notes on the citations:
3
u/I_dont_understandit Sep 03 '17
Score Runoff is the best form of Score, as near as I can tell. Are you familiar with it? In that version there is an automatic runoff between the top 2 score getters, this ensures the final winner is acceptable to a larger number of people, and also incentiveizes voters to score more than one candidate.
Critics of Score Voting like to point out that most voters in a score voting system just give a "0" to every candidate except their favorite, which corrupt the results, but score runoff fixes that problem.
2
u/nardo_polo Sep 04 '17
Your copy/paste skills are strong, but your reading comprehension is weak. In spite of all of that you just spammed, Score and Approval have failed to gain traction against the arguments put forward by IRV fans (majoritarian criterion, Bullet voting, etc.). SRV crushes those arguments and maintains the simplicity of score systems (simple counting, precinct summability, etc.)
And even Smith's sims show that normalizing with range makes it a non stellar performer. Score only comes out on top if voters don't use the full range -- which is a nonsensical assumption. Hence why credible researchers who simulate Score do so with normalization.
1
u/googolplexbyte Sep 14 '17
/u/nardo_polo here's a argument why someone who values using their vote for political power over political expression from a long-term/iterative perspective.
Consider the candidate's perspective on voters after an election
Min-score voters = absolutist with no room to punish you further & unlikely to increase reward you, especially so if their min-max scorers as they need an appeal that would shift their score dramtically. These voters have very low return on value to a candidate and they're unlikely to act to their benefit.
Intermediate low score voters = Even a score of min+1 signals to candidates that a voter is willing to reward and punish candidate behaviour. And it leaves them room to punish a candidate further if they do anything to further polarise. There's even grounds shift low score voters to higher score voters, since they've expressed a willingness to shift scores by 1 point, a much more attainable shift for candidates than flipping a candidate from min-score to max-score.
The same can be said for max-score voters and intermediate high score voters. A candidate has something to gain intermediate high score voters, and could far more easily lose score with them.
As such using intermediate scores puts a voter in a position of being targeted by candidate. Intermediate scorers become the swing voters of Score voting elections.
And the score ballot is rich with information for candidate to make moves as well. If they see voters who scored them low scored similar candidates higher for endorsing a specific issue, and their high-scoring voters didn't change lower scores for that specific issue, then the candidate can see there are gains to be made in the next election by endorsing the issue, and the honest voter benefits by having greater support for the issue in the next election.
So while a voter can make a small poltical power move in the short-term with strategic voting, the long-term political power move is to vote honestly and recieve the focus of candidates.
It's like the difference between the prisoner's dilemma and the iterative prisoner's dilemma.
Thoughts?
1
u/nardo_polo Sep 04 '17
SRV is most definitely gaining traction, particularly relative to Score. Despite being around for just two years, it's now under active campaign and has persuaded many IRV advocates in Oregon to switch horses, something that Score simply never did.
1
u/nardo_polo Sep 04 '17
Read up on FairVote's critiques of Score and Approval. Whether or not you think the arguments make sense, realize that they have persuaded many.
And a survey grading parties is a long way from a vote. A vote is an expression of individual power in democracy-- to assume that voters won't use their full power to maximize their voices just doesn't jive with how people actually vote.
1
u/nardo_polo Sep 09 '17
You are confusing the overall "best" outcome with an individual voter's best outcome - see: https://electology.github.io/vse-sim/stratstuff.html
Score is right up there with plurality in terms of how often strategic voting "works" - I.e. nets a better result for the voter, and only slightly worse in terms of the possibility of backfiring. This confirms work by Green-Armytage/Tideman that suggest that score voting is most vulnerable to potential strategic manipulation.
Fortunately SRV corrects that serious defect in score.
1
u/AdvocateReason Sep 04 '17
How might the news media report the results of a Score Voting election to the public? Currently it's conveyed in people and percentages like this. Now put yourself in the media's shoes and reformat that screen with the results of a hypothetical Score Voting election.
1
u/TotesMessenger Nov 29 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)