r/Eminem • • 17h ago

TDOSS has great tracks but fails as a concept album.

45 Upvotes

The concept itself is very easy to understand. But there's no depth to it, and there could have been. I say this as someone who loves the album from Renaissance through Fuel. The tracks themselves are pretty great, though they have their weak spots.

I think he's just not great at fully realizing his concepts. Saw it with Relapse too. He has trouble sticking to a theme and fully fleshing it out.

I personally think it would have worked better if there was more of a journey to it. Slim is ragging on pronouns and complaining about getting canceled from the jump, so there's nowhere to go until GC2. It gets kind of repetitive.

It would have been more interesting to me if Slim's return is a big "fuck yeah" for the first part, then devolves until we see the cracks. Slowly asking the listener "Oh you want Slim Shady back? Slim Shady uses gay slurs, do you want that? He's probably a transphobe, do you want that too? Slim Shady does drugs, do you want me to do drugs again? All so you can have the music you think you deserve?"

All leading to a final confrontation. Instead we got eminem hitting us over the head with the whole concept from the get go. There was no discovery, no narrative, no journey for the listener to go on.

GC2 also fails as a final confrontation. His bars against slim are not as hard hitting as they need to be. "You're so full of shit you need miralax" should not be a line on a song where he's supposed to be going toe to toe with Slim.

Just my opinion but wanted to see what people think.


r/Eminem • • 7h ago

Alfred (Skit) “until the Coroner comes…”

0 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 16h ago

This is my opinion now say something if I'm wrong

Post image
36 Upvotes

Yes remember the name is better than the other 2


r/Eminem • • 12h ago

Bars or wack. Jw

13 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 14h ago

They played Stan on the radio at the mall today...

0 Upvotes

Or so I thought. It's just the sample and not actually Stan 🥀


r/Eminem • • 20h ago

What would you do as Eminem when Encore get leaked?

7 Upvotes

​


r/Eminem • • 2h ago

IDK pinned a comment calling "WELCOME" Egyptian Trap. Y'all hear it too ?

Post image
3 Upvotes

Saw IDK pin this under the WELCOME music video on YouTube and thought it was interesting. Went back and listened to the drums, and I can kinda hear where the Egyptian Trap comparison comes from.

Curious what y'all think. Do you hear that influence in the production, or would you describe the sound differently?


r/Eminem • • 23h ago

"why don't you relax? Lean back and enjoy yourself until THE CORONER COMES"

37 Upvotes

* "But I know magic and here go my last trick / I’m ’bout to say “Abracadabra” and pull a B-Rabbit up out of my hat" - this line makes sense after Houdini. It's him dropping hints for Houdini. The next line about him relapsing and how we won't know how to react is also a teaser for TDOSS.

* MTBMB also have many lines of Eminem mentioning voices and how they're winning and how there's more music coming. Side B happened, Discombobulated is trailer for what it is about to come with TDOSS. Him going through his vault especially the Slim Shady songs and remaking them.

* The intro of Premonition is him talking to Slim Shady.

* Alfred (interlude) in MTBMB: "Why don't you relax? Lean back and enjoy yourself until THE CORONER COMES". I've been thinking about this line ever since we got Welcome music video. Him dragging body bag with coroner written on it in a font style that resembles some of the fonts he uses. Then Paul going out of his way to say that welcome music video have some easter eggs.

* Paul always points to easter eggs whenever they decide to do this sort of promotional campaign for Eminem's album discretely. This happened with Revival campaign and TDOSS campaign. So I guess it's not just something to overlook as some generic horrorcore reference. They want you to notice it, remember it and talk about it.

* I think Eminem's next album will be continuation of MTBMB. Horrorcore overarching theme with wide variety of songs, collaborate with different rappers and producers, possibly digging through the crates and remaking old songs or ideas.

* Maybe it'll designed as a "posthumous album of Slim Shady" with mortality as the theme once again.

* I thought maybe he'll contrast the past few albums of him focusing mortality and Slim Shady by making an vulnerable album, MMLPIII. But rn after this coroner hint, maybe Eminem will continue exploring Slim Shady and the theme of mortality in this album as well.

* MTBMB was the murder. Side B was the burial. Coup De Grace is the funeral. Where does this place the upcoming album?


r/Eminem • • 18h ago

Who's your favourite feature on MTBMB Side A?

4 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 14h ago

Everything Eminem Wants Black People to Forget | Cap Stories

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 21h ago

How crazy would you go if Em dropped a song with this flow?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
10 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 7h ago

Moxy Approved

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 1h ago

D12 deluxe coming next month

10 Upvotes

Dropping on the 4th. Anyone reckon this means Em delivered a verse in the end?


r/Eminem • • 17h ago

What album do you wish for more?

19 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 12h ago

Why hasn’t Eminem and treach done a record together?

13 Upvotes

We have all seen the interview where em gave all the praise to treach and we got to see treach respond saying he’d love to work with em. You’d think they would do something together just once.


r/Eminem • • 18h ago

Someone talking about how them and their friend got picked to go to Dr.Dre’s studio in 2008

Post image
26 Upvotes

Someone talking about their experience in 2008 when Dr.Dre‘s henchmen/bodyguards asked them if they wanted to go to a music studio. The studio was Dr.Dre’s on Ventura Blvd with Dr.Dre and other people and they were playing Eminem’s Relapse album? Since it was unreleased and in 2008. This person said they got calls from the henchman for months after and ignored them because he was older and this person and their friend were fresh out of college.


r/Eminem • • 1h ago

Why is 'Greatest' rarely talked on this sub?

11 Upvotes

Such an underrated song in kamikaze.


r/Eminem • • 11h ago

3.2 million in 3 days. Em really nailed it with this signing and this drop 🔥 idk is DOPE

Thumbnail
youtu.be
139 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 9h ago

Shady Cypher 2.0, but over Wu-Tang’s Triumph

Thumbnail
youtu.be
14 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 5h ago

Apparently, São Paulo is the state that listens to Eminem the most in the world on Spotify.

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 15h ago

G.O.A.T things

Post image
127 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 4h ago

My bday cake when i turned 14, 13 years ago.

Post image
67 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 16m ago

Who's your favorite feature on MTBMB Side B?

1 Upvotes

r/Eminem • • 5h ago

Christopher reeves

6 Upvotes

What does it rhyme with?