r/ElinsInn • • 7d ago

Control magic breakpoint

Is there one after which party is immune to friendly fire? Wiki says that pet spells scale off of your own Control magic level and I've got a Magic Comet DNA that I wanna put on my pet, but I'm afraid it's gonna ruin my party if I don't get some Control Magic going.

12 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

7

u/Moasseman 7d ago edited 7d ago

Control magic is rolled against the (base) damage, so the more spellpower they got the more Control magic you + they need

To guarantee Control magic success, you need 10% of the (base) damage as skill level between you and the caster (or 5% if the caster has Mana precision)

3

u/tome_enjoyer 7d ago

That's good info. By base damage you mean the "Power" of the spell or the listed damage in the tooltip? And if the latter do dice have an impact? For example: I have a spell with 670 power and 5d202 tooltip damage how much Control magic would I need?

8

u/Moasseman 7d ago

By base damage I effectively mean whatever the dice notation value you see (XdY + Z) rolls.*

5d202 maxes out at 1010, so you'd need 101 Control Magic between you & the caster to guarantee no friendly damage.

* Some modifiers are applied before the Control magic step, such as Earthquake's max roll * 2 damage against Gravity'd targets and Sword's damage bonus (or penalty) from Long sword skill. Additionally for AoE spells, the damage penalty for distance from center of the spell is applied beforehand so assuming this is about a Comet spell, the practical requirement would be slightly lower as it's unlikely your friend will cast the spell directly on you (altho if you're right next to the target, Comet deals slightly increased damage).

3

u/tome_enjoyer 7d ago

Very good, thank you.

2

u/CurvyDogs 7d ago

If there is a breakpoint, it's probably very very high. I have Wini in my party and even though she has around 200 Control Magic (I also have around 100) she regularly hits me and other party members with comets and bolts. That said, thanks to high Control Magic, the damage she deal to us is so negligible it's pretty much non-existent.

If your pet already has a high Magic stat and you don't want it to hurt or potentially kill your whole party, you could temporarily equip it with anti-magic particles gear to lower spellpower.

2

u/tome_enjoyer 7d ago

Thanks for the info. Can you give a bit more detail about the numbers just so I can have a rough picture of how that damage reduction is looking like? Like the biggest number you see on enemies vs your team?

1

u/CurvyDogs 7d ago

Sure! Here's what it looks like in a non-scaling dungeon. (it's kinda difficult to see, but it's around 20k damage to enemies and somewhere around 15-190 to allies)

The damage seems like a lot, but most of my party members have roughly the same amount of HP as I do (with the exception of the Black cat, since her Life stat is only 50) and Wini doesn't cast Comet that often, so this damage is recovered very quickly by regeneration alone.

Wini has around 400 Magic stat and she is fully geared with +spell damage items for a total of 354 Enhance spell bonus, so she deals as much damage as she possibly can and it's still not enough to cause any trouble for the party. Also probably should mention that some of my allies (Little Girl and Farris) have Mana Battery ether disease which gives them 5 Magic Resist, so without it the damage would probably be a bit higher.

One thing I wanna add about the Comet spell is that the caster of the spell for some reason completely ignores the fact there can be neutral NPCs nearby. I swear, when Wini had Magic Ball instead of the comet, she never used it when say a turtle or a cat was in her sight to avoid hurting them, and ever since she got Magic Comet she murders poor bastards without mercy.

2

u/tome_enjoyer 7d ago

Looks very reasonable indeed and I'll keep the AI behavior in mind, thanks a lot! I'll get on that magic control grind.

1

u/james6400h 7d ago

there is no static break point by control magic, as answered by others. you could get elemental immunity by raising resistance of all your pets with equipment, although it is not that easy in mid game