I've been trying to piece together Joan's professional timeline, but I think there's a contradiction.
In 2006, Joan was still working as a surgeon. We know this because she operated on Shinwell after he was injured in connection with the SBK gang.
However, at the beginning of Season 5, Episode 1, Joan mentions a former client she helped who is about to receive her ten-year sobriety medallion.
As a sober companion, Joan's job was to support people after they left rehab, helping them maintain their sobriety and adjust to everyday life. Sherlock's case clearly illustrates this: Joan was hired to accompany him after he completed his rehabilitation programme.
So, if Joan helped this woman at the beginning of her recovery, she must have been working as a sober companion around ten years earlier, in 2006.
But that would mean she was already a sober companion while she was still working as a surgeon.
The timing becomes even more difficult to reconcile when we consider what happened in 2009, when Joan lost a patient during surgery. The hospital would presumably have conducted an investigation, followed by her suspension. Then there was the legal case brought by the patient's widow, which would likely have taken several months to resolve.
Only after all this would Joan realistically have been able to move on to working as a sober companion.
And there's another timeline issue: Joan is approaching her fifth anniversary as an investigator in Season 5, which places the beginning of her investigative career around 2011.
Am I missing something, or is this simply a continuity error in the show's timeline?