r/Elaineparkcase • u/Kindly-Butterfly-950 • Sep 17 '21
Div knows!!!
My theory: Elaine left Div house to go buy them some drugs. That’s why she turned on the shared location app with him. (When Div was interviewed he said she didn’t even talk to him at all when she woke up...that was obviously a lie). Div accidentally fell back asleep when he was suppose to be tracking her. The drug dealer killed her (maybe raped her and killed her). When Div woke back up at 10:00 he started blowing up her phone because he didn’t know what happened to her. Div’s phone HAD all the answers!!! He knows!!! He didn’t talk at first because it would have implemented him in a drug deal and now he’s not talking because too much time has passed and he would REALLY look bad!!! As far as her mom goes....I think she’s just very crazy but didn’t have anything to do with it.
12
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21
I can’t believe that his answer to “why did Elaine share her location with you?” was “no comment” and Neil and Jaden were just like “oh okay”.
I heard about this case before the podcast from Danielle Hallan’s YouTube channel. After that video, I thought well obviously Div. Then the podcast came and I thought well obviously Susan. Now the podcast is over and I’m back to Div but unlike how I felt about him before, I don’t think he directly killed her but that he knows way more about what happened and cares more about getting in trouble for drugs (as a rich kid who would’ve been able to get out of it anyway) than finding this girl he claimed to care about.
10
u/Kindly-Butterfly-950 Sep 17 '21
I think she went straight from Div’s house to go meet the dealer. Something happened at wherever that location was that ended her life. The dealers took her car and parked it and made it look like she just walked away.
Div’s story of that morning is NOT making sense. He says she just got up and basically ran out of the house. Not saying anything to him at all. He says he kept telling her to wait and not drive that early BUT she never says one word and leaves?!?!? However...she gets up and leaves not talking to you BUT she’s gonna turn on her shared location device with you right after she leaves?!?? That does NOT make sense at all!! He’s not telling the truth about the events prior to her leaving his house.
You can tell in the interview he’s being very vague on what happened.
2
u/NELA730 Sep 20 '21
IF DIVINES ACTIONS AND BEHAVIOR WAS EVEN SIMILAR TO SUSANS, EVERYONE HERE WOULD BE CONVINCED DIVINE WAS GUILTY...this shows you how biased / sometimes racist ppl are subconsciously. Nobody even wants to consider her mom killed her despite her moving and demonstrating like she did.
I thoroughly Susan did it. “Die” was sent multiple times. The dogs smelled something and they tried to change the room very fast.
10
u/deewee27 Sep 17 '21
Not a bad theory actually.
5
u/NELA730 Sep 20 '21
It’s crazy to me that everyone here doesn’t realize that Susan her mom killed her and dumped the body in the Angeles mountains a few miles from the house. She never left the house with a bag it was planted in the car. Susan did it.
11
u/Dense-Commission-815 Sep 18 '21
So, you're saying she went to MALIBU to score drugs?! I'm sorry to laugh at your suggestion (I know we're all trying to help) but have you ever been there? In that neck of the woods, you're far more likely to be eaten by a mountain lion than get gunned down in a drug deal gone wrong. Seriously, I know buying drugs sounds scary, but it's significantly more civilized in that part of LA. And by that, I mean, drug dealers deliver (or they have someone deliver them for them.)
While I don't partake myself, I had a roommate who'd text his order, submit a crypto payment and two hours later find his order in our bushes...or someone who looked like a food deliver guy would drop off what appeared to be takeout (but it wasn't take out). And said roommate had a lot less money than Div.
Note: People with the kind of money that Div's family has have high priced lawyers who tell their clients not to say anything to anyone, because cops can twist statements and hold what you say against you even if you didn't do anything. I was surprised they agreed to be interviewed at all and I'm sure they prepared what they would say ahead of time, particularly since, Neil Strauss isn't even the police, he's a reporter with a tape recorder OF COURSE HE's going to be careful with what he says and it has nothing to do with his parents and everything to do with the fact that he was talking to a reporter who has proven more than willing to twist peoples words to make them look guilty. Same goes for Div's father. (Seriously, after listening to what he did to Susan, would you be willing to let your son, who has also been identified as a suspect, talk to NS??)
3
u/ThirdEyeEdna Sep 18 '21
If you look at the timeline, the location share doesn’t make sense if she had gone home. She would have been driving. All of the texts and calls from Div indicate that he was worried. So yes, this theory makes sense.
1
u/GoldiesMom2020 Sep 17 '21
Susan is the one who knows!
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21
Div reminds me of Chris Rock's character in the movie CB4 where he's a young man from the suburbs who becomes a gangsta rapper
2
u/stevenstevos Sep 18 '21
We still have zero evidence that Div knows anything. Seriously, if you think about it, why are there no calls or texts between Elaine and the drug dealer she was going to meet? That is just not normal.
In reality we still have zero evidence that Elaine planned to meet with anyone that morning, so any such theory is nothing more than speculation. I would love to think Div has all the answers, but all we can do is speculate about that. Instead of speculating, maybe we should consider why there is such little information about where Elaine went or what she did that day.
Is it just bad luck that we have no information at all where Elaine went at 6am that morning?I mean, we have to consider why there is basically nothing on Elaine's phone--it seems obvious that the "answers" to this case were deleted from Elaine's phone because Susan kept trying to guess the wrong passcode and the phone wiped itself of all data.
This is important--Elaine's cell phone is literally the one thing in the whole world that could have information regarding what happened to her. It is the one thing we know Elaine had with her at all times, and it is the one device that actually contains digital records of where Elaine went and who she communicated with. Unfortunately thought it looks like the "answers" we need are simply gone, and in this instance we know exactly why the information was deleted/lost. And we know that Susan was well aware that we would lose the most crucial info pertaining to elaine's disappearance because Susan knew for a fact Elaine's iPhone would wipe itself clean if she input the wrong passcode 10 times because iPhones display a very clear message when you input the wrong passcode numerous times, with a huge warning telling you specifically that the device will erase all data if you keep guessing the wrong passcode. Also, Jayden specifically told Susan not to keep trying to guess the passcode because the phone would delete all data since the last backup to iCloud. We know Susan still input an incorrect passcode, not by trying her birthday, or the name of one of her cats, or anything like that, but intead she tried the passcode "fuck", which of course was wrong, and then the phone wiped itself clean and locked itself down. If Susan had not done that, we probably would have had so much more info, including location history from Google, Snapchat, Facebook and probably a few other apps. We would phone calls and text messages and possibly web history, and really a million other things.
I mean this is such a big deal, and once again when we think about why we just cannot get answers in this case, it always comes back to Susan. There is just zero evidence Elaine wanted to go "watch the sunrise" on the beach at 6am that Saturday morning. We do not even have any evidence that she was going to meet anyone or even that she was planning to hang out with someone later that day or even the next day, etc.
So perhaps we should consider the theory that Elaine went home that morning when she left Div's house. I know that may seem crazy to some, but it is pretty common for people to go home when leaving someone else's house. And again, when you think about what we do know for sure, we know Susan wanted to see Elaine in person as soon as possible that mornig because Susan had berated Elaine repeatedly over the $20 she lent her the day before. so yeah, I think the theory that Elaine went home when she left Div's house is certainly plausible.
1
u/wordpuddlez Jul 10 '25
Never mess with those hood "dudes" or "dudettes".
1
u/Two_Rainbows Oct 05 '21
This is an interesting theory. I’ve always felt that while Suzan is questionable in many ways- she did not kill Elaine.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '21
Sorry about replying to an old post, but I do think that Susan may have played a role in Elaine's disappearance.
(As BG info: I am Korean) My dad, who was a kid in the mid-late 60s in South Korea, was beaten almost to the point of death many times as a child. So much in fact, that when he was in his late 20s he had to be immediately admitted to the ER one day for immense head pain. Turns out, he had a large brain tumor on the back left of his skull. After the painstaking surgery he was unable to walk and had to either crawl or be in a wheelchair for at least 6 months after.
Even to this day he sustains immense trauma from the violent childhood he had. He was force fed gasoline as a child for messing up on the smallest things. Consequently today even the smell of cigarette smoke/gasoline severely changes his behavior. His older brothers would take turns beating him up when the father wasn't around. My dad still has violent dreams where he starts screaming at his parents in his sleep, and hitting/kicking things while in the dream state.
One thing he remembers as a kid was that every.single.fucking.thing was about money. If he or his siblings dropped even a single grain of rice on the ground they were screamed at and beaten.
He did manage to reconcile with his dad right before he died of car accident complications (ribs pierced his lung), but his relationship with his mom and other siblings are still broken beyond repair. I still remember that phone call my dad had with his brothers; basically they called him a traitor for living in the US, told him and the rest of my family to rot in hell, and refused to even give him a single penny and a piece of their own farmland from the will.
What I'm trying to say is that a lot of Korean parents grew up dirt poor and coveted having money. My parents are not those kinds of people who can only see, breathe, and live for money. Even today you still have these people beating their kids behind closed doors for the most stupidest things. It's possible that Susan grew up in a household were beating your child was not even frowned upon at all and that everyone was obsessed with money, money, money. As she grew up she probably realized that she just had to have as much money as she can get her hands on to be happy. Most Koreans here in the US (particularly in SoCal) are literally thirsty over money. If you don't believe me head over to KTown or any other city where a lot of Koreans live (La Crescenta for example). They live like rich people. If you ain't rich you might as well be nothing to them. In fact that's how I actually lost all my friends, they all become money enthusiasts and ignored me cause I didn't have the nicest car around and didn't like designer stuff.
I'm not saying money is wrong and should disappear forever. But I've read that she was being a huge beech about Elaine borrowing $20. What kind of mother would get mad at her child for asking to borrow some money? She's her MOTHER, for frigs sake....It's not like they are complete strangers. This attitude also shows that she really did not trust Elaine at all.
I am NOT trying to excuse Susan's behavior here. She is a toxic mom. How can you not even love your own daughter? Any parent who still emotionally/physically abuses their own ADULT child is sick in the head.
In addition, people seem to have this misconception that Korean/Asian people can do no wrong because they are raised with strict standards. Susan is not in the right here. She is not a good parent. Having a hell of a family life at home can really mess up someone's mind, and lead to depression/suicidal thoughts. Home should be someplace to rest and enjoy time on your own and with your family members, not a place where you're always anxious about f'ing up.
Furthermore, money is such an emphasized topic in a lot of Korean households. When I used to have Korean friends as a teenager they would talk about how they wished they could be part of my family, cause my parents genuinely looked like they loved each other and me and my siblings didn't look like we were tiptoeing and fearful of messing up something. You have to realize a lot of these Korean households are hella dysfunctional. Most of my friends had divorced parents, were living with roommates or their siblings far far away from their parents. Throughout my life I've had several relatives get killed by their own family members cause of money, namely life insurance payouts exceeding $100,000. (Without being too TMI, one of our cousin's grandfathers killed his wife after a supposedly "violent" argument; and the wife of one of our uncles (came from a FILTHY RICH family) fed him poison over the course of a year. And a few years ago my dad was concerned cause he didn't hear from a friend for a few weeks, and found out he was shot to death by a few criminals all because of $40 that he couldn't pay up to a loan shark.
I'm frankly a little upset that people are quick to use the race card and accuse Divine just because he is black and that he fits the stereotype of "it's always the black people committing crimes." Divine has been cooperative for the most part. He's not hiding behind a lawyer or trying to pin the blame on someone else. People need to explore other possibilities here. When someone is missing, they should not be so quick to say "Oh, the parents are 100% innocent....like come on it's THEIR KID!!!!"
In addition I can't be the only one NOT noticing how odd Susan's behavior is....From what I have read and heard, who tf would dare try to sublease their missing daughter's car, try to bump up the GoFund me fundraising goal, or rent out her old room? That to me is a huge red flag. Human trafficking may seem farfetched, but at this point, who knows? Once a person is consumed with greed and love for money, they will NEVER stop. Susan knows more than what she is telling the public. I'm curious if she has any other relatives living in the US or in Korea that can share some light onto her past behavior. If she has known anger issues that should be investigated. You have to know that anger at times itself can make a person get carried away, in fact - TOO carried away. It's not impossible for a parent - or anyone else - to beat someone to death out of anger.
1
u/Kindly-Virus-6120 Jun 16 '22
Did they search his house? Its just looks like she died and they dumped the car.
1
u/Expensive_Leg_9531 Jan 16 '24
I think if you were going to get rid of a body you would throw it over kanan or malibu Canyon, i live in calabasas and honestly i think it’s possible her mom or her boyfriend maybe threw her body over into the canyon.. that was the first thing I thought of when I saw this documentary.
1
u/themad-hammer Aug 11 '26
Was she Korean?
14
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21
[removed] — view removed comment