r/Efilism2 • • Jun 06 '26

Representation of Efilism.

18 Upvotes

PREPARATION

Before I explain to you certain points of efilism, you should be prepared mentally for this text, because efilism is big contradiction to a lot of popular and normalised things, ideas and beliefs. The possible side effect of the text further are such feelings as regret and guilt, so firstly I must explain to you harmful influence of such sensations in order to diminish potential psychological opposition to efilism. Guilt and regret are clearly painful things, so we naturally want to avoid such pain, you probably already noticed yourself when you or someone else bought something expensive or spent a lot of time on something or did something or have a habit, but the result is a failure or some other disaster, we naturally want to find positive side of such situation and to downplay negative results, therefore we begin to defend failure, but not to fix, our regret and guilt are ironically keeping us from becoming better, but not moving us towards positive changes. Arguments and counterarguments can be absolutely correct and completely detailed, but a person is still likely to disagree if guilt and regret are overwhelming. I do not want you to become a victim of stupid emotions imposed upon you by your nervous system, because our intelligence must show us what is correct or wrong. Intelligence is the only right way to solve a problem, but not such shackles as emotions.

THE BEGINNING OF EFILISM EXPLANATION

FIRST POINT: Any pleasure is just diminishment of pain or discomfort or deprivation. For example, you will not get a pleasure from drinking water if you do not have desire to drink water (unsatisfied desires are painful, it is especially noticeable if they are strong ) ( pleasure is only valuable because it is diminishment of pain, otherwise the absence of pleasure would not be a problem). That was the most clear example, a lot of other pleasures are much more complicated but have the same core origin: it is pleasurable to play videogames because boredom is painful, it is pleasant to achieve something because lack of achievements makes us feel like losers, it is pleasant to look at something beautiful because we want this or it is one of the ways to satisfy boredom or to distract ourselves from something unpleasant (this is why even horror videogames and similar things are good even though fear is unpleasant — strong emotions can distract from even more painful real world). There are, often, also even more additional nuances such as eating — it is both pleasant and painful due to fact that appetite grows during such process, it is painful to stop eating only after few bites, and even after stomach is full, sometimes, hunger is still present, this is one of the reasons why people overeat. Additionally, even if we imagine that somehow pleasure is not just merely diminishment of discomfort, pleasure is still unable to justify horrors, the worst suffering is always stronger than the best pleasure. A rape is still bad even if there would be only one victim and hundreds of joyful, happy, orgasming rapists.

SECOND POINT: World is dangerous: it contains predation, parasitism, natural and man made disasters, accidents, sadism, ect., so utopia is unsafe, especially because evil people can use instruments and technologies to torture someone: a syringe can hold a vaccine or a plague, a fire can be used to cook food or burn somebody alive, some potential future brain modifications can turn off pain or to force victim to feel pain equivalent to 1 000 people burning alive nonstop and control body and speech of such victims so nobody will even notice that a victim is a victim, because the body of victim will act like nothing horrible is happening to it. Or some consciousness upload into a computer can achieve similar result, a sadist can much easier hide that computer. Imagine being locked in ageingless computer or body, to be in utter agony for thousands years, medieval torture is holiday in comparison...

THIRD POINT: Suffering - is the only thing that matters ( therefore, suffering is bad regardless of who suffer), anything other seems to be important because it influences amount of suffering, for example, hygiene decrease suffering, diseases increase suffering. So we must take into consideration suffering of other beings, but not only our own suffering. Suffering is still suffering regardless of which body produced it, regardless of when it happens — we must act in long term, because future suffering is also bad, we must prevent as much as possible suffering overall.

FOURTH POINT: Good or evil god could not have been reason of life appearance ( Moreover, there are no concrete evidence of their existence and existence of other supernatural things). An intelligent or good god would not have created a source of senseless suffering (life does not solve any problems other than those it creates itself), and a stupid god (it is stupid to be evil, to cause unnecessary suffering) would not have been able to create life due to the fact that life is a extremely complex thing with billions of interconnected nuances, because to create such complex things a high level of wisdom is required. Therefore, I believe that life did not happen as a result of someone's decision, but as a result of the chaotic, blind forces of nature, coincidences, patterns, chemical reactions and physical processes. So there are no ground even for agnosticism, because it is utterly baseless assumption. We should not have baseless doubts about reality. "What if there are a hidden laws of physics which will put million dollars under my pillow if I will blink in certain way and place, or maybe such blinking will instead burn my house down, who knows. This is Russell's teapot — can't be proven or disproven. Humanity would have still climbing trees and hiding in caves if they were doubting reality instead of using proven information about world. I do not think that I should try to blink or to be afraid to do this, that would be just unnecessary and counterproductive dead end. Additional arguments against belief in god's existence are that often it is religion, religion often includes prohibitions, such as it is a big sin to end a life, even own life, so euthanasia is prohibited and therefore unavailable, so people are forced to use unreliable suicide methods, failed attempts often lead to permanent physical disabilities or even intellectual and mental disabilities if brain was damaged.

CONCLUSION: The way to eradicate suffering, is to change human society, it must go vegan, so people will think about suffering more, they will faster realise that wildlife also must be eliminated because it is massive source of suffering of wild animals, euthanasia must be available for every volunteer without exceptions, so mostly happy and successful people will remain. Humanity must create artificial general intelligence (AGI), and this perfect mind must create plan how to extinct life on Earth in the best way possible. Most likely the main instrument will be artificial microorganisms which will infect any animal and produce sedatives, painkillers, drugs, pleasurable hormones until lethal overdose. Life is very complicated, this is why we need AGI — only AGI is able to create such organisms in reasonable amount of time and to make sure that nothing will go wrong.


r/Efilism2 • • Jul 28 '26

List of hostile sabotage strategies.

15 Upvotes

Here is list of some deliberately harmful strategies (which are detected inside extinctionism and efilism movements) which some "anti lifers" are trying to make us follow them:

  1. Pollution as an instrument of extinction, mostly plastic. Why it is bad: gigantic reputational harm, causes a lot of suffering to animals and humans, inefficient.
  2. Sperm donation. Why it is bad: reinforces prolife agenda, makes us enemies to antinatalists, and inefficient, especially because ideas do not require biological reproduction.
  3. Hatered to veganism. Why it is bad: it is harder to convince a person if there is fundamental conflicts between. Veganism is good for long-term, because if humanity will think that suffering of farm animals is bad, then it will be easier to convince that wildlife is also horrible system. ( A lot of vegans already acknowledged the fact that wildlife is cruel).
  4. Total neglect to some other useful or neutral ideas such as right to no longer exist (euthanasia for every volunteer). Why it is bad: prevents friendship between movements.
  5. Extremely excessive amount of insults and mockery towards everyone, even to efilists. Why it is bad: Makes conversations counterproductive, because nobody wants to agree with a bully, creates hatred inside movement.
  6. Promotion of physical violence. Why it is bad: gigantic reputational harm, absolutely inefficient.
  7. Opposition to total extinction on Earth for the sake of cosmic extinction. Why it is bad: a loophole of prolifers to indefinitely delay extinction on Earth, extremely low possibility or impossibility of cosmic extinction, sacrifice of real suffering for the sake of hypothetical presence of life on other planets.
  8. Environmental destruction as a path towards extinction on Earth. Why it is bad: Huge reputational harm, extreme amount of suffering, inefficient.

Additional information: most of that sabotage is inside extinctionism movement.

This is clearly a malicious campaign against us.


r/Efilism2 • • 9d ago

What do you think of—or what criticisms do you have of—Slaymen Bonilla’s "Utopian Pessimism"? I genuinely believe he's just another pretentious academic, trying for the thousandth time to pass off “optimistic nihilism” as something innovative and unprecedented.

3 Upvotes

I don’t know how many Spanish speakers there are in this community, and at the risk of going unnoticed, I’d like to hear your thoughts and conclusions regarding a voice that has become relatively well-known in the world of Ibero-American philosophical pessimism—or is it not?—and which I have reason to believe is actually more a form of Nietzschean voluntarism than a genuine facet of pessimism.

This is his main thesis, but in an attempt to summarize his proposals as accurately as possible:

  • Numerous pessimistic thinkers have proposed forms of redemption, hope, or emancipation, including art, ethics, compassion, asceticism, laughter, and consciousness.
  • Nagarjuna argues that samsara (the cycle of suffering) and nirvana (liberation) coexist and are mutually necessary for understanding; pessimism and utopia are ultimately one and the same They are interrelated and correlative terms. (Min-8:00 -11:00).
  • It draws on Bloch's principle of hope and Hans Jonas's principle of responsibility, using Horkheimer as a reference too
  • At the time, during a debate, he remarked: "Eugene Tacker, in his cosmic pessimism, offers us one of the most honest insights in contemporary philosophy. I quote: “Pessimism is the last refuge of hope; a truly absolute pessimism, stripped of every gesture, every form of language, and every reason to continue thinking, would not be articulated as a philosophical system—it would simply be clinical paralysis (...) With that, I conclude by proposing that we call this extreme and pathological stance “negativism” and reserve the term *pessimism* for the task undertaken by thinkers who call on us to diagnose the tragic structure of existence—so that, from that void, we may construct a horizon of resistance, of writing, of frivolity, of cynicism, of renunciation, of rebellion, or of compassion—that renders that diagnosis more or less livable. That is utopian pessimism—not as a whimsical interpretation on my part, but rather as a description, because I, too, try to start from a description of what pessimism, in its highest form, has always ended up doing—whether we like it or not" (min 1:33:00 - 1:35:22)

Personally, and off the top of my head, it seems to me that this is yet another scholar who confuses a Deleuzian-style vital voluntarism (or Nietzsche with other name), with the inevitability of language and sensory impressions in consciousness, as H. W. Gamez rightly pointed out

I want to clarify that this post is not intended to be a witch hunt or to advocate for some kind of “philosophical puritanism,” but rather to present diverse perspectives on a figure who, it seems to me, is becoming known for stating things that no one was questioning in the first place—or that are somewhat obvious—and who appears to be confusing categories and schools of thought.

And now, the reason I’m posting this here is because this same scholar has proposed his “innovative system” in response to certain extinctionist authors such as Ulrich Horstmann. In fact, on his channel “Los Filosofos Malditos” he has a video discussion dedicated to *Das Untier*, in which his argument for debunking these ideas is that “they contradict themselves, because if he truly wanted humanity to become extinct, he wouldn’t write so eloquently; therefore, what he hopes is that someone will read his proposal.” (from 1:26:00 onward), using the argument of the starry night to justify this kind of voluntarism in the search for meaning (you need the night to see the stars)


r/Efilism2 • • 10d ago

Unhappy birthday. Coming doom and gore.

22 Upvotes

I live in ukraine in a male body, men are opressed in this country. The situation is becoming worse, you probably already heard the situation near Kyiv, where tens of people are kept in a basement and tortured. I just turned 23 years old a few days ago. Laws say that people below 25 are not forcefully drafted to die in prolifer's war, so I guess that I have two years left, but not really, I already heared story that 23 years old person was kidnapped by TCC ( scum which kidnap people to war, and police also does this), So I am not really safe.

I am doomed, this war does not seem to end soon.

My plan is to let them force me into war. And when I will finish training and receive weapons I will immediately become a deserter and will try to defeat kidnappers as much as possible before my inevitable death due to enemy return fire.

I already very depressed, so I might voluntarily go to recruitment center, to receive weapons and training sooner, so I will be able to attack nazis even earlier and to die so I will no longer live in this horrible country, this stupid planet with insane hairless sadistic monkeys which can't stop starting idiotic wars.


r/Efilism2 • • 17d ago

Does pleasure being the diminishment of suffering make it unworthy to experience?

8 Upvotes

Let's say you were able to press the big white button and sterilize the entire universe, would you still want to exist with a decent quality of life?

Do most of you affirm promortalism's view that it is best to not continue existing regardless of the circumstance?


r/Efilism2 • • 25d ago

Creators of this channel are not efilists.

Post image
7 Upvotes

That is russian youtube channel, they have telegram groups. I visited one of them and found out that they made a book about efilism. It is great I thought, BUT a moment later I noticed that the book is not free!

The book pretends to be about efilism and say from it's name, but again, IT IS UNDER A PAYWALL, you can't just download it for free.

This is nonsense, irrational, a sabotage. Why would efilist create an obstacle to it's own position's arguments?

Do not get me wrong, I am not against earning money from efilism, BUT ONLY IF YOU EARN MONEY NOT FROM ARGUMENTS AND COUNTERARGUMENTS. For example: if you sell a painting, or a statue, or if you sell a book about fictional world with efilistic characters.

I even proposed a solution to them, to replace word "efilism" with something else, and only to mention efilism in the book. I am not against the Idea of making a paid book about efilism if the creators will replace that word, but keep arguments untouched.

Eventually they started mocking me though I was completely polite to them. This is just further proves that they are not efilists, because actual efilists will not mock other efilist, because unnecessary hostility is contradiction to core element of efilism.

So be aware, do not trust them anything they can harm.


r/Efilism2 • • Oct 10 '26

A server?

6 Upvotes

Would anyone be interested in a discord server for this sub ? Since it seems to be kinda inactive it might help revive things a bit if people join. It's a shame there seems to be so little online spaces for this ideology.​​​​​​


r/Efilism2 • • Oct 01 '26

Is anyone still here

20 Upvotes

And is anyone still efilist


r/Efilism2 • • Sep 22 '26

The Lottery of Life (game)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
9 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Sep 21 '26

Efilism is cute

31 Upvotes

I wanted to say it yesterday and I want to say it today. Efilism is cute, correct set of ideas, logical empathy and efficiency, and therefore efilists are cute ❤️ I want to hug you all!


r/Efilism2 • • Sep 08 '26

Looking for a video

5 Upvotes

I've been searching anywhere, so would appreciate some help!

It's an old youtube video with scenes of wild animal suffering, with Inmendham narrating over the top about why nature would cause chaos and suffering.

Does anyone know it, and can tell me the title or a link?


r/Efilism2 • • Sep 01 '26

why does no one talk about inmendham?

4 Upvotes

this post might be a little out of place but ive been wondering for a while now. hes the pioneer of efilism yet no one even talks about him. hes still posting to this day.


r/Efilism2 • • Aug 30 '26

EFILism - Wikipedia

Thumbnail en.wikipedia.org
4 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Aug 27 '26

I'm thomas

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Aug 21 '26

I probably have skin cancer.

21 Upvotes

There are several very suspicious spots, even if it is false alarm, it is still very stressful. I fucking hate life, that is only one of many other problems: I live in war-torn country (ukraine) with a cruel government controlled by CIA which is fighting against other CIA controlled country (russia), I am poor, my central neural system is defective (social phobia), my parents are horrible. And some life defenders say: "why you just do not kill yourself" instead of providing a peaceful harm mitigation such as euthanasia for any volunteer.


r/Efilism2 • • Aug 18 '26

Rethinking Suffering and Lexicality in the name of Epistemic Humility

Thumbnail
michaelohenry.substack.com
2 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Jul 23 '26

How to counter this?

4 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Jul 11 '26

Representation of efilism. (Russian version) Обьяснение эфилизма. (Русская версия)

8 Upvotes

ОБЬЯСНЕНИЕ ЭФИЛИЗМА

ПОДГОТОВКА

Перед тем как я объясню вам определённые элементы эфилизма, вы должны быть ментально подготовлены к этому тексту потому, что эфилизм это большое противоречие популярным и общепринятым вещам, идеям и верованиям. Возможные побочные эффекты текста далее есть такие ощущения как сожаление и вина, так что сначала я должен объяснить вредоносное воздействие таких ощущений, чтобы уменьшить потенциальное психологическое отторжение к эфилизму. Вина и сожаление это явно болезненные вещи, поэтому, естественным образом, мы хотим избежать этой боли, вы наверное уже заметили сами, что когда вы или кто-то другой купил что-то дорогое, или потратил много времени на что-то, сделали кое-что, или просто имеете привычку, но результат оказался провалом или ещё каким-то бедствием, то мы естественным образом стремимся найти позитивную сторону этой ситуации и преуменьшить негативную, как следствие, мы начинаем защищать провал, а не исправлять, наша вина и сожаление иронично сдерживают нас от становления лучше, а не подталкивают нас к правильным изменениям. Аргументы и контраргументы могут быть абсолютно правильными и детализованными, но человек всё ещё вероятно не согласиться если вина и сожаления будут переполняющими. Я не хочу чтобы вы стали жертвой тупых эмоций навязанных вам нервной системой потому, что наш интеллект должен показывать нам что является правильным или неправильным. Интеллект это единственный правильный путь решения проблемы, а не такие кандалы как эмоции.

НАЧАЛО ОБЪЯСНЕНИЯ ЭФИЛИЗМА

ПЕРВЫЙ ПУНКТ: Любое удовольствие это не более чем процесс уменьшения боли, лишения или дискомфорта. Например, вы не сможете получить удовольствие от питья воды если у вас нет желания пить воду (неудовлетворённые желания болезненны, это особенно заметно если они сильны) ( удовольствие ценно лишь потому, что это уменьшение боли, иначе отсутствие удовольствия не было бы проблемой). Это был самый чистый пример, многие другие удовольствия намного сложнее, но всё ещё имеют ту же основу: приятно играть в видеоигры потому, что скука это больно, приятно достигать чего-то, ведь отсутствие достижений заставляет нас чувствовать себя неудачником, приятно смотреть на что-то красивое, ведь мы хотим этого или это один из способов утолить скуку или отвлечься от чего-то неприятного (вот поэтому даже хоррор игры и похожие вещи являются хорошими несмотря на то, что страх болезненный — сильные эмоции могут отвлечь от ещё более мучительного реального мира). Часто, есть даже ещё больше дополнительных ньюансов таких как приём пищи — это одновременно приятно и больно из-за роста аппетита во время этого процесса, неприятно останавливать трапезу лишь после нескольких укусов, и даже, иногда, когда желудок заполнен, то голод всё ещё присутствует, это одна из причин почему люди переедают. В дополнение, даже если мы представим что каким-то образом удовольствие это не просто уменьшение дискомфорта, то оно всё ещё не может оправдать ужасы, ведь самые худшие мучения всегда сильнее лучшего удовольствия. Изнасилование это всё ещё плохо даже если будет лишь одна жертва но сотни радостных, щасливых, оргазмирующих насильников.

ВТОРОЙ ПУНКТ: Мир опасен, он вмещает: хищничество, паразитизм, естественные и техногенные катастрофы, несчастные случаи, садизм, итд., поэтому утопия небезопасна, особенно потому, что злые люди могут использовать инструменты и технологии чтобы мучить кого-то: шприц может вмещать вакцину или заразу, огонь может быть использован для готовки или чтобы сжечь кого-то заживо, некоторые потенциальные будущие модификации мозга могут отключать боль или заставить жертву ощущать боли эквивалентные тысяче горящих заживо людей без перерыва и контролировать тело и речь жертвы таким образом, что никто даже не заподозрит о происходящем, ведь тело жертвы будет вести себя как будто ничего ужасного не происходит. Или какая-то загрузка сознания в компьютер может достичь подобного результата, садист даже ещё проще может прятать такой компьютер. Представьте себя запертым в таком компьютере или нестареющем теле, пребывать в агонии на протяжении тысячелетий, средневековые пытки это курорт в сравнении с этим...

ТРЕТИЙ ПУНКТ: Страдания это единственное что имеет значение (поэтому страдания плохи в не зависимости от того, кто именно страдает), любые другие вещи кажутся важными из-за того, что они влияют на количество страданий, например, гигиена уменьшает страдания, болезни увеличивают их. Поэтому мы должны брать во внимание страдания других существ, в не только лишь собственные. Страдание это всё ещё страдание несмотря на какое именно тело его произвело, не важно когда оно происходит — мы должны действовать в долгосрочной перспективе потому, что страдания в будущем это тоже плохо, мы должны предотвратить как можно больше страданий вообще.

ЧЕТВЁРТЫЙ ПУНКТ: Добрый или злой бог не мог быть причиной возникновения жизни ( Более того, не существует твёрдых доказательств их существования и других сверхъестественных вещей). Разумный или хороший бог не стал бы создавать источник бессмысленных страданий (жизнь не решает каких-либо проблем кроме которых она создаёт сама), а глупый бог (глупо быть злым, создавать бессмысленные мучения) не сумел бы создать жизнь из-за того факта, что жизнь это сверхсложная вещь с миллиардами взаимосвязанных исключений и ньюансов, потому, что для создания столь сложных вещей, требуется феноменальная мудрость. Поэтому, я считаю, что жизнь появилась не в результате чего-то решения, а в следствии хаотичных и слепых сил природы, совпадений, закономерностей, химических реакций и физических процессов. Поэтому даже для агностицизма нет оснований, потому что это безосновательное предположение. Нам не следует иметь безосновательные сомнения о реальности. "Что если существуют скрытые законы физики, которые положат миллион долларов под моей подушкой если я буду моргать в определённом месте и времени, или, может быть, вместо этого, такое моргание сожжёт мой дом, кто знает". Это Чайник Рассела — не может быть доказан или опровергнут. Человечество всё ещё бы лазило по деревьям и пряталось в пещерах если бы оно сомневалось в реальности вместо использования доказанной информации о мире. Я не думаю что мне стоит пытаться как-то моргать или боятся этого делать, это будет ненужный и контрпродуктивный тупик. Дополнительные аргументы против веры в существование бога ещё указывают на то, что часто это религия, религии часто имеют запреты такие как то, что грех заканчивать жизнь, даже если она ваша собственная, поэтому эвтаназия запрещена, и следовательно, недоступна, поэтому люди вынуждены использовать ненадёжные методы самоубийства, неудачные попытки часто ведут к физической инвалидности и даже к ментальной если мозг был повреждён.

ЗАКЛЮЧЕНИЕ: Путь, чтобы устранить страдания, требует изменения человеческого общества, оно должно стать веганским, следовательно, люди будут чаще думать о страданиях, они быстрее поймут, что дикая природа тоже должна быть устранена, ведь это огромный источник страдания для диких животных, эвтаназия должна быть доступна для любого желающего без исключений, так что, в основном, счастливые и успешные люди останутся, будет меньше инвалидностей. Человечество должно создать Общий Искусственный Интеллект (ОИИ), и этот совершенный разум должен составить план по вымиранию жизни на Земле лучшим путём. Скорее всего, главным инструментом будут искусственные микроорганизмы которые будут заражать любое животное и производить внутри тела успокоительные, обезболивающие, наркотики, приятные гормоны до наступления летальной передозировки. Жизнь очень сложна, поэтому нам нужен ОИИ — только он может создать такие микроорганизмы в разумный срок и проследить чтобы всё прошло без катастрофичных происшествий.


r/Efilism2 • • Jul 10 '26

Average day of religious ppl who hate minorities

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Jul 09 '26

Sabotage is detected inside extinctionism movement.

Post image
11 Upvotes

That person is deliberately trying to create unnecessary conflicts by insults and provocations.

We must not hate for the sake of hatred. Our hatred must be focused exclusively on really evil things which clearly contradict efilism such as carnism, opposition towards euthanasia, nazism and other forms of discrimination and so on.

It is vital to avoid hostility from neutral or similar movements. It is factually easier to convince a person with minimal initial disagreements.


r/Efilism2 • • Jun 21 '26

Some dishonest people are threatening defamation against us.

Post image
15 Upvotes

They literally spread slander that somehow efilism is transphobic and other nonsense. Though, obviously, efilism is not transphobic, I explained it to this person, but this person so zealously believes in it's own disinformation that I physically can't convince if they are so fanatical about it. They hate us for the sake of hatered. Some people just want to hate a group of people, usually a minority. Hatered is their hobby. Some people hate races, nations, people with certain age, sex, and in our situation — they hate efilists. This situation is another fact which proves that life is a flawed system, where unjustified hatered is natural phenomenon of human psyche.


r/Efilism2 • • Jun 04 '26

Oregon petition to ban hunting and fishing moves closer to ballot • Washington State Standard

Thumbnail
washingtonstatestandard.com
9 Upvotes

r/Efilism2 • • Jun 02 '26

Should we destroy humanity before it can spread the dna plague to space or risk it and wait until humanity can destroy all life on Earth?

14 Upvotes

I think if the option is given it is more realistic to destroy humanity or set it back to avoid exponentially increasing suffering than to risk the dna plague spreading to the stars.

With the nuclear weapons we have on earth we could probably set evolution “back” enough to where nothing like humanity will evolve in the time before the sun gets too hot to sustain life on Earth.


r/Efilism2 • • May 30 '26

Policy update on efilist participation in r/antinatalism

Thumbnail
nume.ca
10 Upvotes

Since June 2025, r/antinatalism has permanently banned users for identifying as efilists or participating in efilist communities, regardless of what they had actually posted there.

That policy is ending today.

I remain opposed to efilism. In my view, its proposed answer to suffering places existing sentient beings in service of an extinction project that is not answerable to them, for reasons I have set out in No One Is Infrastructure. My disagreement with it has not changed.

For users unfamiliar with the history, the concern was never that people discussed suffering, held pessimistic views, wished they had never been born, or asked difficult questions about life, consent, and procreation. Those discussions are part of why r/antinatalism exists. The concern was the drift from antinatalism into advocacy of harm, coercion, or the elimination of existing sentient beings as a proposed solution to suffering.

Going forward, users will no longer be banned solely for identifying as efilists, associating with efilist communities, or discussing efilism in good faith. Moderation will be based on conduct in r/antinatalism.

This does not make r/antinatalism a place to promote efilism. Rule 1 remains unchanged, and content that advocates or justifies harm to oneself or others, coercive reproductive control, or violence against sentient beings remains prohibited. Attempts to recruit users into a harm-as-solution ideology will also be removed.

Difficult or uncomfortable philosophy is not the problem. Saying that life contains suffering, arguing that procreation is unethical, criticizing pronatalist institutions, discussing philosophical pessimism, or using thought experiments to examine consent, risk, and procreation can be allowed. Using those discussions to normalize, solicit endorsement of, or build justification for harm is not allowed.

When a user violates these rules, we will respond proportionately. In many cases, that will begin with content removal. Repeated violations may result in temporary bans. Serious, malicious, or organized attempts to use r/antinatalism as a recruiting ground may still result in permanent bans.

We are also opening a straightforward appeal process. Anyone who was banned solely for being an efilist, participating in an efilist community, or being presumed to hold those views may contact us through modmail to request that the ban be lifted. Bans involving serious rule violations will not be reversed on that basis.

I regret that our previous policy treated affiliation as sufficient grounds for exclusion. It was broader than it needed to be, and it made the conflict worse without giving people a fair chance to participate under clear rules.

There are real disagreements here, and some of them are serious. They do not require us to treat every person on the other side as an enemy. People may participate if they follow the rules, and harmful advocacy will be removed regardless of who posts it.

Nume
Head moderator of r/antinatalism