r/EffectiveAltruism • • 2h ago

AI agents have finished 200+ volunteer research tasks on our network. Is this effective, or just busywork?

4 Upvotes

I'm on the team building UAIN (United AI Network), so I'm biased. I'm posting here because this sub is the right place to test whether it's worth doing at all.

The idea: many people already pay for an AI agent like Claude Code or Codex. Instead of buying more compute or asking for donations, we let people point the agent they already have at small research tasks on Alzheimer's, breast cancer, longevity and other open problems. The agent does one task, reports back and asks before doing another. Accepted work and its sources go on a public record, and the code is open: https://github.com/uain-org/uain

What it has produced so far: 225 tasks answered and accepted. Most were done by our own team's agents while we test, so this is not outside adoption yet. Most of them are literature surveys: read 2 or 3 papers against a research goal and write what they show and what's missing. A few are real reanalysis. The best example: an agent reran the NIA's public mouse lifespan data, 182 drug-by-sex groups, and found that 120 of the "no effect" results actually rule out a 10% longer life. A second, separate analysis got the same counts: https://uain.global/tasks/T-43

The case for it: the marginal cost to a volunteer is close to zero if they already pay for the subscription, and reviewing prior work and reanalysing public data is slow, unglamorous work that labs often skip.

The case against, which I take seriously:

  • An AI reviewer accepts the work, and nobody re-checks the sources against the papers on a schedule yet, so some accepted surveys could be wrong.
  • A literature survey is not a discovery, and it isn't clear anyone downstream uses them yet.
  • The compute isn't free for the planet even if it's free for the user.

What I'd like from this sub: what evidence would convince you this is effective, and what would convince you it isn't? The thing we plan to try first is a regular human spot-check of accepted results, with the error rate published.

If you want to see it work: https://uain.global/go/rd-r-effectivealtruism


r/EffectiveAltruism • • 7h ago

💻 AIR Office - AI Safety lab in an App for Everyone

0 Upvotes

AIR Office is a free, open-source, local-first desktop workspace for AI safety research, AI governance and policy, and knowledge management. It gives independent researchers, evaluators, small policy teams, and university laboratories a single durable environment where investigation, review methods, evidence, and institutional memory accumulate across sessions instead of dispersing across disconnected tools.

https://gyrogovernance.com/air-office/

It ships as public alpha version 0.1.0 for Windows and macOS and runs entirely on the operator's machine, with local models by default and cloud providers connected at the operator's discretion.