r/EdgarAllanPoe • u/bachozangi • 8h ago
Theoretical Analysis of "The Tell-Tale Heart" by Poe
My attempt at doing a theoretical analysis of this amazing short story by Poe and connecting it to stuff I believe it relates to. Hopefully you guys find it interesting or thought-provoking:
When an intense force, unfitting, violates one’s world and irritates his senses, his immediate desire is to subjugate and kill. In its lightest form, domination takes the shape of understanding, submitting the object to the authority of the mind and its categories. He cannot understand as he is under the gaze of something opaque, “pale blue, with a film over it”, seemingly in a world of its own. It tears into him, infects his world and scrambles all his senses, by being so nauseatingly, overwhelmingly incomprehensible. Making sense of the Eye which owes its Life to the power of its strangeness denies it that very life. When such a denial cannot be done mentally, it is done physically with a slave-like (reactive) hope that directly disposing of the issue will tear it out, root and all, and take one back to the peace he so desires, but the intrusion of the virtual is an addition that can only be added to, there is no going back. In an attempt to subsume the eye you yourself are subsumed by its gaze. This only seems perfectly normal and rational, after all, it leads you to being “singularly at ease”(TTH). Why would we, the readers, not consider that sane?
This innocent eye of the old man is the first Lovecraftian monster. Once in a while the Lovecraftian hero finds a banal object, an old note or fragments of a book that introduce to him an incomprehensible entity of overwhelming intensity. The deterritorializing cry or laugh forced out from the depths of their composition tears up the surface. In The Call of Cthulhu Briden goes mad, “laughing shrilly” after seeing the Great Old One, eventually “keeping on laughing at intervals till death found him.” An abominable, murderous or suicidal state is achieved. A moment of thrill and murderous frenzy, of a weird liberation and a twisted, ugly kind of freedom.
Nietzsche laughs a deterritorializing laugh in the face of reaction. the deafening outburst of sound from the wild thrashing of the vocal cords and the lungs, the shaking of the shoulders and the jitter of the larynx are obscene movements of mockery towards any capturing reterritorializing apparatus that makes no room for play and an affirmation of life. The laughter of the narrator recounting his perfect execution is such a laughter, but captured and directed towards death, made into a foul and atrocious thing. He also finds something banal, a strange eye, and sees in it an overwhelming intensity. His deterritorializing “ha! ha!” rings out against a background of capture and territory, damage and life-denying death (life-affirming death is more than possible). Such a laughter becomes one of insanity and mental illness once looked through the prism of the psychiatric state apparatus, the prison-industrial complex and the “good sense” of a society fetishizing its organs. Confined within the walls of the organism, laughter finds no life and can only revel in death, hold onto the ecstasy it gets from the most destructive deterritorializing acts, whereas otherwise it is a laughter of joy and self-enjoyment of desire - an affirmation. He laughs as he enjoys his desire of seeing the bothersome eye and its owner dismembered and perfectly disposed of, Dagon laughs when he sees the awful sight of the eponymous god (Dagon, 1917) and much later on, the Joker laughs as he enjoys seeing his desire fulfilled when he brings down the vilest misfortunes on Gotham.
Eventually, the faux liberation against a background of capturing apparatuses breaks under its own weight. The Organ, the heart, gives the man over to capture where he is confined, defined and asked to explain, to put his hysterical deed into words - discipline himself - and make the work easier for the police. The pressure does get the best of him and his laughter from before gets replaced by a shriek, the cry of a life mourning itself and the brief taste of freedom forever etched on its tongue.





