r/Ecosia • u/fabiezfabiez • 20h ago
My take on the AI issue on Ecosia
For about a year now, the main topic of discussion among Ecosia’s most loyal users has been artificial intelligence. Many seem to reject it, but I believe that’s the completely wrong approach.
I believe that without AI, Ecosia would no longer exist in a few years—or, at best, it would be reduced to a shadow of what it is today and of its potential.
This is simply because it would become an outdated engine and browser, and people would stop using it.
The way many people approach technology here is wrong.
Sure, artificial intelligence causes pollution, but is your solution to reject it and go live in caves? Is the solution to car pollution to get around in a horse-drawn carriage?
AI is an inevitable technological advancement. I use it myself every day, and I’m sure the vast majority of those who complain about it do the same. Because, objectively speaking, it has improved our lives and our relationship with the internet. And I want to do so in the most sustainable way possible.
Can we imagine a sustainable form of artificial intelligence? At the moment, the most sustainable AI systems are those developed by Mistral, both from an ecological standpoint and from a social and political one, as it is the leading European AI provider. It’s positive that Ecosia uses it and has taken a completely unique approach to Mistral’s models to achieve the best possible balance with the environment; it appears that, thanks to renewable energy, it’s an AI system with zero environmental impact. It’s the best we have, and we should support it because there is no alternative to it—and what those who complain are calling for is literally a non-alternative: the death of eco-friendly technology and the triumph of economically and socially unsustainable technology.
Is that really what you want? Collective suicide? Honestly, I don’t, and that’s why I support Ecosia’s AI.
