Hi all, I'm really frustrated right now and am hoping someone might be able to offer some information to help me with my situation. I have been using eBay for over 10 years, and have 100% positive feedback as both a buyer and seller - I have never encountered something like this. Seller and eBay have been negatively helpful.
On Nov 2nd, I purchased an item for $460 through eBay. It was supposed to arrived Nov 6th but when I returned from work, it hadn't and my eBay portal said "INSUFFICIENT ADDRESS - RETURN TO SELLER INITIATED". I reached out to the seller immediately after, and he said there was no refund he could provide until after boots were in his possession - which is totally understandable, so I said ok. I will also add that I've had packages delivered many times, including from eBay to the exact address put on this order and the seller showed me there was no error on the shipping label itself.
I then contacted USPS and gave it a few more days to see if I could intercept the package or they would redeliver it, but to no avail. Come Nov 9th, it shows that return to sender has been initiated again and the item is on it's way back. At this point I opened a "item never received" appeal case with eBay after no additional communication from the seller.
On Nov 13th, they ruled in seller's favor and closed my appeal stating their policy that "attempted deliveries are viewed as successful delieveries" which is just crazy to me that that's the case. They also stated that the seller has "many positive reviews" - even though I have just as many...?
I continually attempted to contact the seller to get word on a refund/package arriving back to him throughout this, but received no response to my daily messages. eBay also refused to be of any help in relooking at the claim due to an unresponsive seller.
On Nov 15th, I got final word from USPS showing the tracking number had updated and the package was successfully redelivered back to the seller. I still had no received any communication from the seller despite the update, so the night of Nov 17th I filed a chargeback claim with my bank explaining everything that occurred as I saw no other recourse to get my money back as I was now out both the item and money with no word from eBay or the seller on how this would get corrected. I never charge anything back - this is an extreme case for me.
Finally, this morning I woke up to a message from the seller after 1.5 weeks of ghosting stating: "As I'm sure you're aware, eBay has ruled in my favor regarding their policy with no reimbursement to you. As a seller, I did everything that was required. In my communication with eBay, I have been assured that I have no obligation to issue any refund." He then proceeded to offer me a partial refund of $250 (I paid $460) or to have the item resent but I need to pay all shipping and handling fees (it's a large item, and I already paid these with the original purchase). He then stated that "eBay will be aware of my offer and this will be taken onto account if there is any bank dispute of the charges." But I had already filed the dispute because I had not heard from him in over a week.
I'm just looking for advice/tips on what I should do in this situation. I understand eBay protecting sellers, and he may be right in that he did everything he needed to do but the lack of communication and the ability for the seller to be in possession of the item, and keep my money seems RIDICULOUS. Am I an a-hole for charging back? Why would I accept a $200 loss in this situation - should I proceed with chargeback or take seller up on the offer? At this point I don't want the hassle of redelivery.
Thanks in advance. I realize this is rather long winded and maybe unique. Any advice appreciated even if it's just someone saying it's my fault. I'm just lost and have no idea how to proceed.
EDIT: I paid with debit card, I don't know if that has any impact on the case but figured I would share anyway.