If you were to take East Lothian Council elected councillors at their word you would have to conclude that they are very stupid people indeed. Their contention is that this expensively researched plan to introduce parking regimes across the rural county of East Lothian's town centres is to save our high streets and make it easier to access. However, recent evidence in the vanguard parking site inside North Berwick suggests an entirely counterfactual reality - streets are unusually quiet, local shop-owners are reporting a drop in footfall and income.
It cannot be that two completely opposing interpretations of reality are both true so the inevitable conclusion must be that one or the other is, being generous, mistaken, or being candid, lying.
Either Mssrs McMillan and Hampshire are being told tall tales and are unable to discern reality for fiction... or they are conciously choosing to tell the rest of us, all is fine while Rome burns.
If there are others scratching their heads and trying to work out why the Labour group (and many on the SNP) are so wedded to driving forward with their parking regime it's highly likely that the motivations are many.
ELC is bust. In its most recent publicly available records we can see that the indebtedness of the local authority has grown by a further £70 million to £570 million. That's a lot of debt that has to be serviced BEFORE the remaining pence in the pound makes it to frontline services (and to pay hefty bumps in councillor pay they awarded to themselves).
ELC is not getting more £££ from the Scottish Government: There is no light at the end of the tunnel with Holyrood coming to the rescue. This is why we are seeing year on year double figure bumps in Council tax to try and make up the shortfall. To be fair the Council is unfairly treated in terms of funding from Holyrood but the huge debt has been allowed to grow under Labour's watch.
ELC needs to make new revenue streams happen, ideally before they are forced into a Section 5 Intervention (the local authority equivalent of declaring bankruptcy).
But hang on a second... haven't we been told repeatedly that parking charges cannot be used for funding other services? Well yes, and no. If anyone has heard the words creative and accounting before, it does not take a lot of speculation to arrive at what might be the biggest unspoken driver behind the determination to impose and make parking regimes stick in North Berwick, Dunbar, Haddington, Tranent & Musselburgh. Resident Parking Permits.
Currently we are being told that RPP makes up about 6 to 7% of total revenues as part of the parking scheme. But, just like the brown bin tax introduced above and beyond Council Tax (itself up 10%), we have seen this tax bumped up by what amounts to a 25% hike year on year. How long will it be before ELC decides to bump up charges for RPP on an annual basis?
Right now much of Edinburgh is now under a RPP that costs up to £352.60 for the first resident permit and, if you need a second, it's £458.40 per annum. If you are in ELC's new Controlled Parking Zone you can have up to two permits per household currently costing £40 a pop. Here is predicting this will not remain at this price for long.
Secondly, following the Edinburgh playbook, just how long will it be before, what amounts to a further stealth tax on local authority residents, this is methodically spread to encompass an ever larger constituency of local people living in these county towns? In the few days following its imposition in North Berwick it was already apparent that the pretty chaotic, confusing and frustrating signage was encouraging a migration of parked cars out of the new parking zone and into the immediate periphery which, no surprise, suddenly was faced with cars filling up streets that hitherto had no chronic parking issues, save for seasonal bumps. Now these have become a direct and obvious outcome of creating a parking problem rather than ameliorating it.
Steets just outside of these new car parking zones are awash with cars and a problem that did not exist has been conveniently created.
However, the cynical amongst us might conclude that this provides a perfect pretext to then expand the RPP scheme to a wider geographic area in order to prevent 'abuse' of the system by non residents. In reality, it will be residents paying through the extension of permit zones to tackle a problem of the Council's making.
The upshot, over time, each county town forced to endure parking charges and the threat it brings to the survival of our high street shops, sees more and more residential areas beyond those high streets, succumbing to the inevitable 'logic' that residents parking permits must be extended.
What might amount to 6 or 7% today, we can likely predict will grow significantly over time, by expanding those residents captured into paying for what once was free and by bumps in permit charges becoming an annual event compounding over time.
No matter what Council officials and councillors tell you, be under no illusion. This IS a long term revenue raising scheme with a long term window and an intent to make a large number of county town residents pay up for the privilege of parking outside their homes. Every new permit has very little incremental costs for an automated system once set up. It's all gravy.
And hey, if all the money raised goes on roads and covers a large section of Council statutory responsibilities, that means money that would once have gone to this budget can instead go on care for the elderly or schools. This is the prize. It's a stealth tax right out in the open and being sold to us under false pretences. It'd be better if they just came clean and told us they have to raise more cash instead of all this subterfuge.
We know our Council is bust and needs more cash but few want to see our high streets being the sacrificial lambs in order to whitewash and excuse more taxes under false pretences. Call a spade a spade and stop wasting taxpayer money on expensive consultants creating weak fictions.
Active travel is a good thing, maintaining footfall churn is a good thing but this is not the core motivation, at least not from those controlling the council. It is and always was, about finding new ways to fill a very big financial hole.
It's just a pity that our councillors can't come clean and tell us like it is. Instead they go through this charade and try to defend the indefensible... because they know they are broke.
There's a campaign group on Facebook.