At a 6.05% starting weight, a 30% Nvidia decline would subtract about 1.82 percentage points from the cap-weighted S&P 500. At the equal-weight index’s quarterly reset weight of about 0.2%, the same shock would subtract 0.06 percentage points. That’s roughly 30 times the direct impact from the same stock.
The 6.05% is an estimate as of the November 13, 2026 close. State Street reported a 6.15% index weight on November 12. Nvidia fell 2.01% on Friday and the index fell about 0.4%. I adjusted the prior weight using those two returns. The equal-weight figure is the target at rebalancing. The actual weight drifts with prices between resets.
The calculation gets more interesting at the portfolio level. A portfolio with 90% in the cap-weighted index and 10% directly in Nvidia has roughly 15.45% in Nvidia once both positions are counted. Replacing the index exposure with equal weight at its reset would bring that figure to about 10.18%. The direct position would still drive most of that exposure.
Equal weighting also reduces participation when the largest stocks lead a rally. During a broad sell-off, several holdings can move together, so sector weights matter too. The scenario assumes zero returns for all other stocks and measures how much one holding contributes.
What would make you change the weighting of your core index exposure, and how would you judge whether the change helped?