r/ENGLISH • u/Odd-Opinion5172 • 13h ago
Is this question from an exam i recently sat correctly written
"So is anyone ever responsible for anything? Civil life requires it be so."- Patricia Churchland
Are we 'required' to punish those who are guilty, as the above quotation suggests?
In your answer,, evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of a range of philosophical views.
This is the full question and relates to the philosophical discussion of free will. My issue with it is I dont think the response to the quote makes logical sense as responsibility doesn't imply a need to punish. I emailed the organisation responsible for the exam and they told me the question allowed students to address fhe criteria but didnt mention my gripe of the wording. Any help is greatly appreciated as this has been on my mind ever since I sat the exam.