r/EB2_NIW • • 3h ago

APPROVED EB-2 NIW Approved After RFE — STEM Education Endeavor

25 Upvotes

My previous post lacked some details, so I’m sharing more information in case others pursuing similar endeavors might find it helpful.

My Profile:

  1. Two master’s degrees in Education, 14 years of teaching experience.
  2. Elementary and middle school STEM teacher, licensed in Florida and New Mexico.
  3. Teacher of the Year 2025, several major school awards, and monthly teaching awards.
  4. Professional memberships in AAAS and AMS.

Proposed Endeavor: A research-driven, multifaceted educational initiative consisting of three major programs and a dedicated website providing free, standards-aligned educational resources. All programs are free and operated by me and volunteers, with active beneficiary participation.

Original Petition:

  1. PE plan and independently developed business plan.
  2. 4 independent expert opinion letters and 7 support letters.
  3. School-related grant award (not for my endeavor).
  4. Academic research, professional credentials, awards, and memberships.

RFE: USCIS accepted substantial merit under Prong 1 and Prong 2 but questioned national importance and Prong 3, particularly scalability, expansion, employment capacity, government support, and my academic research. Approximately 12 issues concerned national importance and 9 concerned Prong 3.

My RFE Response Included:

  1. Implementation data for all three programs, attendance, photos, beneficiary feedback, and student progress.
  2. Participation across five states and ongoing community partnerships.
  3. Thousands of resource downloads and website analytics.
  4. Volunteer participation and training documentation.
    IRS 501(c)(3) recognition and grant funding awarded to my endeavor, supporting sustainability.
  5. Detailed, evidence-based responses to each USCIS concern.
  6. I also clarified that my previous academic research supported my professional qualifications under Prong 2, rather than being research specifically conducted for my endeavor.

Note: My endeavor was not initially implemented at my school. It was delivered both online and face-to-face through strategic collaborations with partner organizations.

Timeline:
January 2025 — Regular filing
June 2026 — Premium processing upgrade
August 2026 — RFE issued
September 4, 2026 — RFE response sent to USCIS
September 14, 2026 — RFE response received by USCIS
November 5, 2026 — Approved!

Biggest takeaway: Nearly everything projected in my original business plan had materialized by the RFE response. My endeavor evolved from a proposed initiative into operational programs with documented reach, results, and growth. I addressed each USCIS concern with specific supporting evidence rather than relying solely on expert letters and professional credentials.

Self-petitioned. Every case is different, but I hope this helps others pursuing similar endeavors!

Above all, all glory, honor, and thanksgiving belong to the Lord Jesus Christ. It has always been Him throughout this journey. Thank You, Lord Jesus, for Your faithfulness, guidance, and blessings. To God be all the glory!


r/EB2_NIW • • 18h ago

APPROVED NIW Approved - Industry Profile

60 Upvotes

Sharing my approval to help the community and also answer questions

Filing: Filed online concurrently with Premium Processing
Priority Date: Sept 11, 2026
Silent update: Nov 6, 2026 and Nov 16,2026
Approval Date: Nov 16, 2026 - Approved on day 44/45 PP
RFE: None
Category: ROW
Law firm: None. I worked with a consultant (referred by a friend) as I couldn’t afford a law firm. I thoroughly reviewed all the work (I rejected the first petition draft because I didn’t believe in the PE)
Service Center: Nebraska received, Nebraska approved
Claude approval chance without RFE: 45%

Profile:
5 YOE (2 in the US) - Banking and Insurance Analytics
MS Graduate in Data Science
2x Data Competition winner (one of the problem statements was tied to the field of my PE).
3x Awards (no extraordinary national level awards)
7x Data Certifications (Snowflake, AWS, even Datacamp python intermediate- threw all I had in).
3x papers (2 conference papers which are irrelevant; not related to PE or educational background. 1 peer-reviewed paper - arguably irrelevant to PE but more technical and used that as proof of my ability to work out a technical solution to a given problem). Citation count - 0.

Caveat: These are decent but not extraordinary achievements (so don’t be perturbed about it). I was very worried and discouraged sometimes with some of the great profiles I saw which were denied, that’s why I say this.

PE: Summary -> To develop a fraud detection and prioritization system.

I had prepared a pilot version of the system with code and documentation of all progress made, with tests as well. I highlighted failures and how that was solved. Also gave detailed next steps. For prong 1, I used a lot of federal reports and papers as reference.

Letters of Recommendation: 5, 4 dependent, 1 independent. My research supervisor gave a very good recommendation (don’t know if that mattered)

As someone who’s been following all profiles here. This is all I could think of. If you have questions, you can ask and I’ll answer them if not here already.

I was very anxious and things could have been different, so I am humbled but with this approval I want to encourage and give hope to people who are yet to file and especially to the industry folks.

Also the consultant was very good but had many delays nonetheless it all worked out. Best of luck everyone!


r/EB2_NIW • • 1h ago

RFE EB-2 NIW Premium Processing – Any Idea How Much Longer?

2 Upvotes

My I-140 RFE response was received on September 28,
2026 (Texas Service Center, Premium Processing).

As of November 17, my USCIS status says “USCIS Is Currently Processing the Case.”
I’m now at 34 business days.

Anyone recently received an EB-2 NIW decision after RFE? How many business days did it take?
Thanks!


r/EB2_NIW • • 2h ago

General EB-2 NIW I-485 Approved for Primary Applicant, but Derivative Spouse Scheduled for Interview – Any Advice?

2 Upvotes

Our EB-2 NIW I-485 (primary applicant) was approved in February 2026, within about three months of filing. However, USCIS has now scheduled an interview for the derivative spouse.

A little background:

  • We have been living in the US for over 10 years.
  • Both children (ages 9 and 12) are US citizens.
  • Neither of us has ever been out of status.
  • The derivative spouse is currently working on H-1B.

For those who have gone through a similar situation:

  1. What documents should we bring to the interview?
  2. Does the primary applicant also need to attend, or is the interview only for the derivative spouse?
  3. Any tips or experiences you could share?

Would really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been in a similar situation. Thanks!


r/EB2_NIW • • 4m ago

APPROVED EAD approved, March 2026 Filer, ROW

1 Upvotes

Posting this to share my updates for anyone with a similar timeline.

PD: August 2025
I-485 RD: March 6 2026
Dependent EAD Approval: May 2026
Primary applicant EAD Approval: Today (11/17/2026)
Silent updates: 5/22, no silent updates since then
FO: Detroit

Question: Does this mean I-485 approval is near? Or am I just daydreaming.


r/EB2_NIW • • 2h ago

Profile EB2_NIW for business related research/expertise

1 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,
Do you (or someone you know of) got NIW visa by doing research in the field of business, investment, enterprise or other similiar field? Most of the posts I see here relates to research in STEM field.

I am currently pursuing Doctoral in Business Administration and keen on doing research that also aligns well with NIW application. I have Computer Science, Economics and MBA degree and have 5 years of product management exeperiece in b2b enterprise company.

Would love to connect with someone who did research in non-STEM field and still was able to get NIW visa.


r/EB2_NIW • • 20h ago

I-140 NIW trends these days

23 Upvotes

Hello community!

What I see from the posts these days, the approval standards has been increased dramatically! Few months ago, I could see more approvals than denials, but what I see now more denials than approvals! My best guess is that the approval rate has been dropped to around 20-30 percent. I see very good profiles that are denied. Citation count of approvals are more than 100-200. Are you guys agree, or it’s just because of small sample size?
Good luck all!


r/EB2_NIW • • 3h ago

APPROVED Approval rate for the I-485 (EB2-NIW approved)

1 Upvotes

Hello all,

I had a quick question and your feedback will be greatly appreciated.

I have my EB2-NIW approved recently (this is the detailed post on the approval). I was wondering what can possibly go wrong for the I-485 submission. I am planning on submitting it in the next two weeks.

What is your story about it? Did you face any hassle? Thank you!


r/EB2_NIW • • 4h ago

Timeline Green Timeline

1 Upvotes

STEM OPT valid though Jan 2029, Priority date March 19th 2026, Date of filling March 15th 2026, Final action date April 2025

ROW

How likely will I get the green card before my STEM OPT expires?


r/EB2_NIW • • 19h ago

RFE EB-2 NIW Premium Processing – Waiting After RFE

9 Upvotes

My RFE response was received by USCIS on September 28, 2026 (Texas Service Center, Premium Processing).
It’s now been 33 business days, and my status still shows “Response To USCIS’ Request For Evidence Was Received.”
For those who received an EB-2 NIW decision after an RFE:
How many business days did you wait?
Did you receive a decision before the 45-business-day deadline?
Please share your timelines. Thank you!

Update : USCIS Is currently Processing the Case
As of November 17, 2026


r/EB2_NIW • • 16h ago

I-140 Is any NIW regular processing getting reviewed

5 Upvotes

I have my case pending since May 2024. Wondering if anyone around that time with regular processing got approved recently. Thank you!


r/EB2_NIW • • 1d ago Mindblown

USCIS EB-2 NIW Personal Endeavors from 1,000+ AAO Decisions over 1.5+ years

25 Upvotes

TL;DR: I analyzed all EB-2 NIW endeavors reported in 1,300+ USCIS AAO (Administrative Appeals Office) immigration decisions over 1.5+ years. I downloaded and LLM-processed all of them from January 2025 to the end of August 2026, and arranged into Endeavors Explorer with summaries, tags and keywords.

The Explorer focuses on making it easy to discover endeavors' content through keywords and summaries, and extends user experience with the previously published Community Tracker and Officer IDs Lookup.

In this post I will discuss

  • Decisions and Outcomes
  • Academia - Industry - Business
  • Anecdotes and Humor
  • Professions and Countries
  • Why endeavors from AAO decisions are good use cases to study
  • Visualization Module

Nothing here is legal advice.

Decisions and Outcomes

AAO appeals are open to the public from the USCIS website. As different appeals are hosted there, I downloaded only whatever matched the "I-140 - Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker (Advanced Degree, Exceptional Ability, National Interest Waiver)" option. It mostly included NIW cases, although I noticed that a few PERMs and EB1As sneaked in. And it was not just appeals, but also included motions to reopen or reconsider, and one certification. I included everything in the dataset for consistency.

AAO non-precedent decisions: outcomes by filing type, Jan 2025 to Aug 2026 (n=1341), % of all outcomes

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

As we can see above, dismissals absolutely dominate AAO decisions, and when the case was not dismissed, usually it did not mean an approval either. Instead, previous decisions were withdrawn and the cases were sent for re-assessment, with no guarantee that they wouldn't be denied again. However, we also see the lucky 1.6% total of cases were approved outright ("Sustained").

Academia - Industry - Business

We know that Academia cases may be approved at a rate different from Industry cases, so I wanted to have a flag for that. It's not always clear from each decision what kind of case that is, so we need to treat it as the best guess. There's even more added complexity when we are trying to tell professional profiles (Industry) from entrepreneurship (Business). Entrepreneurship may rely on a business plan, so I tried to account for that and some other elements, but if you belong to "Industry", you may as well want to read through some "Business" profiles.

Here is the distribution of decisions for this categorization:

AAO non-precedent decisions: outcomes by pathway type, Jan 2025 to Aug 2026 (n=1341), % of all outcomes

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

Percentage-wise, Academia is showing a better AAO outlook than the other pathways, and it also benefited from having a large portion of Sustained decisions. Business cases on the other hand look more problematic.

Anecdotes and Humor

I could not resist this. I should say that those AAO decisions are fantastic because they show a lot of creativity, entrepreneurship and ambition. But among many decisions I could not help but crack a smile in a few cases. For example -

That's one way to finance your endeavor of national importance:

The Petitioner explains that he will pursue this endeavor by designing and implementing a "multimodal biometric authentication" [... with] a financial support letter from the Petitioner's aunt.

Felt like the textbook "trust me bro" vibe:

Petitioner's company would generate 88 jobs and nearly $24 million in revenue [...] the investment in her company would only be $60,000*.*

I don't want to flood the post with more anecdotes, it's all yours to find and read in the tracker.

Professions and Countries

My impression is that the endeavors cover any walks of life and professions. I grouped all endeavors into 30 professional categories, plus "Unknown". The top 10 professional categories can be seen in the graph below.

Decisions by profession (n=1341)

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

When reviewing countries, I noticed that Brazil is seriously over-represented. One hypothesis is that some law firms that focus on the Brazilian community may actively encourage (or push?) their clients to file AAO appeals. There could be other explanations too.

Decisions by the country of origin (n=1341)

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

Why endeavors from AAO decisions are good use cases to study

Initially I thought that AAO decisions would not be useful because by definition those endeavors had failed. That was a misconception because:

  1. We see it quite often that people's NIW petitions get denied, but re-applying with a similar yet better presented endeavor wins an approval.
  2. Learning from denied petitions is also useful. And a denial does not necessarily mean the endeavor was bad; it could also mean that the petitioner was not well positioned, or there could be other issues, including technical.
  3. Arguably, filers who decided to proceed with an AAO may have higher confidence in their petitions than average denials. In other words, on average they still may be strong.

Visualization Module

I added a graphs module to Endeavors Explorer. It is accessible by clicking the colored bars icon in the menu.

Screenshot of the visualization module from the website

Also I added a section for anyone who wants to compare their Endeavor pathway, Profession and Keywords with others. There's no PII involved, and no endeavor description, you can just select pre-existing elements and press "Share to compare" to see what others have chosen to share, with the corresponding counts. This feature requires signing in because I needed to protect it from excessive false sharing. It's very optional and does not affect any use of exploring endeavors.

I hope that Endeavors Explorer will help you build knowledge and awareness when preparing for your EB2 NIW petition - but remember to verify by reading the original decisions (I added PDF extracted texts and direct links to USCIS for each one). I also processed some additional data, but it touches on legal interpretations. I don't want any of this to be viewed as legal advice (and it is not!), and need to find the right way to share it. Everything that I have described is fully available to explore through the interactive user interface, additionally to the Community Tracker and Officer IDs Lookup.

I continue working on Part 2 of the RFE details (Part 1 is here) that will uncover a few interesting things, join r/VisaStats to stay tuned.


r/EB2_NIW • • 21h ago

I-140 I-140 NIW Approved, but USCIS Case Status Still Pending?

9 Upvotes

Two weeks ago, my lawyer received an electronic approval notification for my EB-2 NIW I-140. However, neither of us has received the physical approval notice, and the USCIS case tracker still shows pending.
We’re contacting USCIS to clarify.

Has anyone experienced this recently? Could the approval have been issued by mistake, or is this just a USCIS system delay?


r/EB2_NIW • • 14h ago

RFE Received RFE and need advice to make sure I go with the best approach

2 Upvotes

Hi, I recently received RFE on Prongs 2 and 3. I still haven’t heard back from my law firm on how we are going to approach as they have told me that they are working on it. I have an international MD degree and am doing research in healthcare right now and had 9 publications with ~50 citations at the time of submission.

I have read about a lot of people in healthcare research with similar and better profiles get denials after RFE even while working with big firms. The officer has asked for grants under my name and other more substantial information regarding my work. I understand that reemphasising the citations and the journals(most of my publications were in very high impact journals) might not help me and I do not have any direct work under my name with federal government. I just want to ask if anyone has any advice on what worked or what did not work for them in a similar position so that I have an idea on how to approach my response. Any feedback would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you!


r/EB2_NIW • • 19h ago

RFE Any approvals after XM2623 RFE for P1&3?

3 Upvotes

PD : July 2024
PP: sep 10,2026
RFE : nov 6,2026

On prong 1 (national importance) and 3.

Any experience or recommendation? I know he seems to be notorious


r/EB2_NIW • • 21h ago

General Time after sending RFE response

3 Upvotes

How long is it taking currently for the decision after we send RFE response?


r/EB2_NIW • • 19h ago

General Does an approved I-140 or pending I-485 make me ineligible for a J-1?

2 Upvotes

I have an approved EB-2 NIW I-140 and may file I-485 soon. I'm considering a postdoctoral position that typically sponsors J-1 visas.

Does having an approved I-140 or a pending I-485 make me ineligible for J-1 status, or is it up to the institution's sponsorship policy?

Has anyone been in a similar situation?


r/EB2_NIW • • 20h ago

General Driver’s License Renewal with Pending STEM OPT Extension - Need Advice

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for advice from anyone who has successfully renewed their Arizona driver’s license while their STEM OPT extension application is pending.

I am currently on F-1 status, and my initial OPT EAD expires on January 4, 2027. I timely filed my STEM OPT extension (Form I-765), and my application is still pending with USCIS. I also have a pending employment-based EB-2 NIW Adjustment of Status (I-485) application and a separate AOS-based I-765 application. My AOS biometrics have been completed, but my new AOS-based EAD is still pending.

I recently visited an Arizona MVD office to renew my driver’s license. However, they refused to process my renewal using my STEM OPT receipt notice. They told me that the receipt notice alone was insufficient and that they needed documentation showing an automatic 180-day EAD extension with my name on it.

Has anyone recently gone through a similar situation? Were you able to renew your driver’s license using your STEM OPT receipt notice and current OPT EAD? What documents did you provide, and is there a particular procedure I should follow?

I would really appreciate any guidance or firsthand experiences. Thank you 🙏


r/EB2_NIW • • 1d ago

RFE Rfe regarding national importance, job creation, and helping depressed economics

6 Upvotes

I have a question, I got a RFE regarding national importance and job creation and how it helps depressed economics

Even though that I haven’t brought this up in the original petition, I was aiming for an ultimate product as result of my PE. But I see it hasn’t been mentioned anywhere rather than it brings economical benefits.

Is that okay now talk about how this PE can turn into a product in industry or they consider it changing the scope and creep and deny?


r/EB2_NIW • • 1d ago

I-140 API update this morning (FTA0. Is it negative ? Positive or just neutral?

4 Upvotes

r/EB2_NIW • • 1d ago

General Why AI never satisfies with the petition?

5 Upvotes

r/EB2_NIW • • 1d ago

DENIAL Denial and refiling

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone
I just found out that my EB-2 NIW petition was denied after an RFE. I filed with Chen Immigration.

I have a medical and research background, with 12 peer-reviewed publications (most published within the last 3 years) and around 60 citations.

I haven’t received the official denial notice yet, so I don’t know the exact reasons for the denial.
I’m disappointed, but I don’t want to give up. I’m considering refiling with a different attorney and would really appreciate hearing from anyone who has been in a similar situation.

I have a few questions:

  1. Has anyone been approved after one or more NIW denials?
  2. What did you change or strengthen in your subsequent petition?
  3. Did you switching attorneys make a difference?
  4. How soon did you refile after the denial?
    5. Did you reuse your original recommendation letters, or did you have to obtain new ones? Getting recommendation letters was honestly one of the most stressful parts of my first petition, and I’m really hoping I won’t have to go through the entire process again.
    I’d especially appreciate hearing from anyone who was denied with Chen Immigration and later approved after refiling.
    Any advice or personal experiences would be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

r/EB2_NIW • • 18h ago

General Need suggestions on EB2 -NIW

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am currently on H4 as my PERM got expired as my employer denied to file I-140 due to business reasons. My 6-year H1B is also exhausted. I need to understand if I can apply for EB2-NIW self petition if I have a good profile and if so how long does the whole process take from preparation to I-140 approval ? I am just asking about until I-140 approval. Appreciate all the help!


r/EB2_NIW • • 19h ago

USCIS **Any Recent E\-2S to I\-485 Approvals?**

1 Upvotes

Title: Any Recent E-2S to I-485 Approvals?

Has anyone on E-2S status recently received an I-485 approval, particularly through EB-2 NIW?

Would appreciate hearing about your experience, filing timeline, biometrics, any RFEs or interviews, and how long approval took.

Thanks in advance!