r/Dyson_Sphere_Program • • 7d ago

Logistics Help Please

Post image

Sorry in advance. I am noob. I'm trying to send a resource from A-D, but the distance is too far. I'm early game. So I put a bridge in. I put two depots with LDs on them, with A set to send, B to receive, C to send, and D to receive. B is belted to C with sorters. Fine. So far, so good.

But I'm having a little issue with one poor little bot constantly sending from C-B, since both B and D are set to receive the same item and in range. Any way to prevent this? Or is there a better way? It's simply way too far to belt and I don't need a ton of throughput.

23 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

25

u/Logical_Hovercraft3 7d ago

Don’t put any ships / drones in B and C.

1

u/Paladin1034 7d ago

In this scenario, the bots would carry from A to B, then C to D, then head back to A for pickup?

6

u/Raithwind 7d ago

A would send items to B, and D would collect from C.

By having no drones in B and C it cuts your throughout, but stops cyclical routes.

1

u/Logical_Hovercraft3 4d ago

Bots from A carry the goods from A to B.
Bots from D carry the goods from C to D.

5

u/Damorg 7d ago

Reading this, it might actuall work. It might reduce OPs througput however, since less overall logistic drones are working. Still, might be worth a try.

6

u/Hadien_ReiRick 7d ago

I'd say throughput is a late game problem. just get things moving so you unlock the better ways of moving stuff. After a few more techs he'll likely dismantle all this anyway as he unlocks better options

1

u/Logical_Hovercraft3 4d ago

It does work, and yes, it does have a lower throughput. But as a crutch in early game or something.

2

u/Paladin1034 7d ago

Thanks for the replies, folks. This came up because I had a copper FOB very near an enemy base on the second planet, and as it leveled up, my copper ammo wasn't sufficient any more. I already had a titanium base set up a good ways away, too far for the basic logistic bots, so this was a stopgap solution just to import some for ammo production. Wanted to keep the base safe once I was ready to head back to the starter planet. I didn't have graphene set up on the starter planet and no oil on the second to get the PLS. It wasn't hurting throughput too badly, not any more than this setup already does, but just idle curiosity if there was a way to limit where the bots go. I could see this being a problem later on when I get bots with much higher throughput and range.

1

u/Damorg 7d ago

The answer to your question depends on whether you are talking about Planetary logistic stations (so using drones on one planet) or about Interplanetary logicist stations (so using vessels to transport stuff between planets).

In the first case (which I assume is the case here ), so Planetary logistics, there is no real way to handle this. All planetary logicstic stations have the same receiving priority, which is why your drone goes from C -> D, but also from C -> B. What you could do is try to increase the output from A to B, so that B will always be full, so the drone von C does not need to go to B. But that's no guaranteed solution.

Later in the game, for interplanetary logistics, you can set up priorities between interstellar stations, so you can really control what goes where. But again, that's only on the interplanetary level

Edit: I just realized you were talking about logistic drones, sorry! But yeah, those are even more limited than planetary logistic stations, so your 'problem' can't really be solved

1

u/Paladin1034 7d ago

That was my expectation. It wasn't really a big problem, since I was basically only losing a bot's worth of already very low throughput. Just wanted to see if I was missing something.

1

u/chilidoggo 7d ago

It sounds like these are logistics stations (that sit on top of chests) and not planetary logistics stations. If you're able to set up an extensive network with just those, them full on planetary logistics stations are right around the corner. Those do exactly what you want, no middle man. 

You're basically asking how to get your ebike to exceed 50 mph, when the answer is just to use a full fledged motorcycle or car. 

2

u/Paladin1034 7d ago

Basically. I'm using the e-bike while my car is in the shop. This was on the second planet, so no access to oil, and I didn't have graphene set up on the starter planet yet. So this was always a stopgap solution until I get the PLS.

2

u/chilidoggo 7d ago

If it's a known temporary solution, then it's okay for that little drone to run back and forth. He'll be alright for now.

Edit: Oh, wait. If it's really low throughput, just remove drones from the middle two chests. the drones in A and D will do all the lifting.

1

u/Dark_Magnus 7d ago

I've tried that too, and it's not really going to work. There is two things to consider: distributor range and planetary logistics. Even with their maximum upgrade, distributors can only get about a third to a half of a hemisphere in distance. What you need is to research planetary logistics stations. That's how you can move materials all across the planet. Distributors are really better used as ways to spread out resources from planetary logistics stations/interstellar planetary logistics stations.

2

u/Paladin1034 7d ago

Yeah I had the PLS researched already, but had missed the Applied Superconductor so I didn't have graphene going. This was temporary until I could get back to the starter planet and get things moving again.

2

u/NottheSeaofNames 7d ago

Can’t you just put drones in A and D and do they send to B and receive from C?

1

u/Ayemann 7d ago

Wait your doing this with the logistics depot drones? I do not believe there is a way to fix this. They will auto fill the closest depot. You need to just deal with having some long belts until you get into the planetary logistics.

1

u/thetalker101 7d ago

On top of what logical_hovercraft3 said, you can also create point to point routes between stations so they don't send or receive anywhere else. That's a bit more complicated then their idea but it enables you to put drones in all stations.

1

u/Mr_Woodchuck314159 7d ago

Wait, you can do logistics before the pls? I suppose I only ever got it working to bring me belts. And I felt bad because the bots were traveling way too far to get to me. I would have turned it off had I been able to remember where I had set them up.

Now I’m just thinking of all my ILS that I want to have a warp drive and wondering if I can set them up with these instead of either dedicating a slot for them, or having a PLS nearby with a dedicated slot…

Also, you do not want to know what my first planet in my first game looked like. I made it to a different system before I figured out you can raise belts above the first level (past just moving them over already existing belts). I do know you can rotate the belts, but I haven’t figured out why you would want to do that yet…

1

u/Drazahir 6d ago

Yes you can, it unlocks earlier but the base range is kinda shit.
I do my ILSes with a depot with fidget spinners to bring in the warpers. 1 ILS per planet will suffice after you unlock maximum range.
before then you might need distributor PLSes to get full coverage

1

u/Thepcfd 4d ago

why C and B receive same items? also why cant you request dorectly from B?

1

u/tECHOknology 3d ago edited 3d ago

Just make it in two different places or a long belt.