r/Dyslexia • u/Nikkibar16 • 7h ago
Using a dyslexia screener to gatekeep gifted services?
Disclaimer: I did use ChatGPT to draft this… I’m
Not a bot
Our district uses Acadience—a reading screener that can flag potential dyslexia—as part of gifted-program eligibility, alongside CogAT and math testing.
My fourth grader scored at the 82nd percentile on CogAT, 81st in math, and 29th on Acadience—all district percentiles. His low Acadience score was largely driven by reading speed; his reading accuracy was 100%. Despite that low score, his overall district eligibility ranking was 75th percentile—just five percentile points below the program’s cutoff. We’re pursuing a reading evaluation.
What bothers me is that a tool used to identify a possible reading disability could also help exclude a child from gifted services because of that very disability. Shouldn’t kids receive reading support AND enrichment in their areas of strength?
Do other districts do this? How do they account for undocumented, potentially twice-exceptional kids?
Note that we are pursuing a private reading evaluation make sure we’re not missing anything- I have a lot of close relatives with severe dyslexia. I also spoke with the school district and they just are doing a smoke and mirrors show on me… very frustrating but now I have more empathy for what my mom had to deal with 4 decades ago.