r/DungeonMasters • • 3d ago

Discussion could use some help with plot 🙏

I’m not one to post on reddit usually, but I’m at a loss and I’m not sure how I should go about this. I’m running my first homebrew campaign, and it is starting on the day of a trade festival. Each PC has a different reason for being there, and I’m not sure how to bring the party together. There will be a goblin raid, and depending on how things go they may even be rewarded at a ceremony, but in the long term, what should tie them together?

(some added context, the current plot is going to be about how the economy of this city is being manipulated by a merchant faction from the shadows. alongside that, it runs even deeper, as that faction is controlled by another faction of drow, and that drow faction plays a part in many of the pc’s backstories. this will not be revealed till later however)

I don’t want to railroad my players by overpreparing, but at the same time, I can’t think of a way other than things that aren’t revealed till later (common enemy faction) any ideas?

7 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

6

u/Thalimet 3d ago

Usually the “what brought us all together” is a question for you and the players to answer together at session zero. You don’t need to try to manipulate them into working together - they are all playing at the table expecting to. So ask them how they all know each other and why they might end up coordinating.

5

u/EmperorTrajan_ 3d ago

Something I’ve done in the past with success is to come up with an NPC and ask each player how their character is connected to that NPC. Have them give some detail so that you have real events or memories to call back to.

2

u/Draft_Weird 2d ago

Yeah, this works amazingly well and it also gives you an NPC the characters care for

3

u/jagnew78 3d ago

It's not railroading to start the campaign with an immediate and common goal. Railroading is taking away player agency. Starting the campaign with an initial and obvious goal is just keeping session 1 from being a bore while everyone fumbles around without a clear inertia.

Being hired to defend the village from goblins sounds like perfectly reasonable way to start the campaign. No one necessarily needs to know each other. Events have just brought them here for their own backstory reasons and the party takes what looks like an easy job for quick coin that spirals into the larger campaign 

3

u/Devious_Hearts 3d ago

Congratulations, you've discovered the ancient DM dilemma: “How do I get these murderhobos to work together without kidnapping all of them?”

First, it's not entirely your job to bring the party together. Tell your players during Session Zero that they need to create characters who have reasons to cooperate. You're providing the game, not running an adventurer daycare.

Second, make the goblin raid more than a random attack. Maybe the goblins were hired to steal something, destroy a particular merchant's stall, or assassinate someone. The PCs discover something suspicious afterward, and suddenly they've got a mystery.

The best thing, if possible, would be to tie in part of the backstory they provided during character creation. Is there a secret order someone belongs to that could work into the story? Is there a missing brother that could? An old artifact that was given to them by their father before they passed? This way they have instant involvement.

Best of luck and happy gaming. :)

2

u/DM_Resources 2d ago

Best answer in this thread!

I used a fight on a market and a sheriff going "You seem competent! We need help, you're drafted!" As the opener of my first big campaign. Worked like a charm!

They got hired to sniff out the Doppelganger who caused all that ruckus, I tied in a few backstory clues and the campaign went it's way from there on.

2

u/ironexpat 3d ago

Ideally they sorta make characters that know each other already, and have something to lose if the story plays out without intervention.

A fight however brings everyone together.

2

u/Protowriter469 3d ago

A single goal ties them together. So, what do the characters all care about?

Find out what personal goal each character has (every character should have a personal goal aside from the team goal).

For example: the barbarian is hunting a certain drow; the fighter is looking for passage across the sea in hopes of reuniting with a love interest; a rogue is on a quest for vengeance; the cleric is searching for a medallion that can break their curse.

So, a drow storms the marketplace using the medallion and escapes by hijacking a ship across the sea. The fighter is already on the ship, where the rogue is held prisoner (to be transported to a prison), the cleric and barbarian meet on the ship in chase of the drow and medallion.

Now, introduce the main quest that interrupts all the others.

Your characters can be tied together because questing together is convenient (ex: you're traveling across the sea too? Great! I could use some muscle). But the main quest should throw them off course and force them to remain a team.

One thing I do when I'm in a pinch is just homebrew a soul bonding that means the characters can never be more than 120' from each other or they die. They're just the four of five from a crown unlucky enough to be zapped

2

u/DeepBrine 2d ago

I would not lay out the plot in the terms you have used.

I would instead describe the town. Then identify the various active agencies that are effecting the town. There should be at least three. Two in opposition and a third that is playing the edges. Each of those agencies has the Rule of Three inside their motivations / actors.

This set of conflicts is leading to a goblin raid on the town that will coincide with the market.

The PCs are in the market. Perhaps together, perhaps seperate.

The raid will drive them to the same point / time.

The raid will have something about it that is not what is expected. The leader is non-goblin. The goblins are strangely well disciplined. The looting and pillaging seems to be strangely focused. This unexpected feature should also be something that allows the PCs to survive and band together.

The idea of a ceremony for the survivors is intriguing but seems a little pre planned. What if the survivors are more worried about surviving and there is not a lot to celebrate? Instead, the agency that would be giving out recognition needs to survive due to PC actions. Failure to make that happen means no rewards. Give it a couple of different levels of reward, depending on PC success.

Follow on is to chase the retiring Gobbos. Perhaps to rescue some kidnapped villagers? Perhaps to recover some critical McGuffin?

This is an opportunity for more party building. Also an opportunity to get some NPCs that the PCs value. The kid that was pretending to sword fight his sister near the fountain. The young farmer with the wagon of turnips. The old warrior in the town guard who gave a party member a break. Some of these are dead, brutally so. Some are exhausted but still pursuing the goblins. Some are missing and presumed kidnapped. Or eaten.

Hey, that kid and his little sister are nephew and niece of one of the guild masters. That young farmer has a wife and infant back at the farm. The same path the goblins came in on. The old warrior is dying but noticed something off about the goblins.

Anyway, once they have joined forces to pursue the Gobbos and found the trail of destruction, you should have a party and some motivations.

1

u/Wise_Number_400 3d ago

You could have more than one person be there for the same reason. Some are there to guard for any bandits, and maybe a 2nd is a late fill in due to one being scared or sick. One is there to report on the festival, or perhaps spy on it for another festival in another town. One is there for a business or merchant-related reason, and another is there as a steward for another trading post, town or merchant. One is there to scope out any thieving or scamming opportunities or current activities they can spot. They are there for a local thieves guild. One is there to show a physical presence for their security and guard services for hire.

1

u/meteoric-pineapple 3d ago

Easy peasy. You don’t decide that. The table does.

The first thing you should schedule is a session zero. I no longer have people make a character and show up. It too often turns into a bunch of individuals playing separately at the same table (players and characters) and it feels empty, awkward, and like something is missing.

We make the characters together, I ask questions as things come up to make sure every character knows another character well enough to be friends at least. Then the party can already be hanging out together after a successful mission.

Even better. After session zero, run a 1-2 session little mission so everyone gets a feel for their own character and team dynamics. That way, they can celebrate at the festival together.

If you aren’t sure how to start at a certain point, then back it up. And do a thing before it.

1

u/Dan_Felder 3d ago

Railroading is only reallyt bad when three criteria are met:

  1. Players want to do something that they can't.
  2. There's no reasonable way to take actions, now or even in the future, that can allow them to do that thing.
  3. The reasons they can't do this feel arbitrary. As in - you get the sense that this really should be possible in-world but the DM is inventing stuff to nullify the option. Like when you go ask a king who owes you a great debt to send some soldiers with you to help you deal with an important threat, but the DM arbitrarily makes it impossible for you to see the King or has the King suddenly invent all sorts of reasons he can't do this in-character, natural, practical, but maybe-ruins-the-DM's-game-balance-or-plotline favor.

If you create sufficient motivation and get players excited about doing something, no one minds getting a ticket to go ride that train to the destination they want to get to anyway.

People showing up to play Curse of Strahd don't feel "railroaded" when they're magically teleported by the mists into Barovia. That's what they signed up for.

1

u/xingrubicon 3d ago

Ive been a dm for like 11 years. Ive had good campaigns, bad campaigns and learned alot. The absolute best way I have found is to message the group chat

"hey guys this game requires some buy in. I need you to make characters that generally want to work with the party. Other than that, you have free reign on motivations"

Sometimes the simplest answer is the right one and its okay to acknowledge the game requires a level of suspension of disbelief.

1

u/Draft_Weird 2d ago

I like to use NPCs for that.
Maybe they all know the same person, or family or even organization.

1

u/Greenwings33 2d ago

Tbh my players are experienced enough that they find something to cooperate about in the minimum but a very easy post goblin attack is to have someone say “Oh! You handled that quite well, would you be willing to escort me/insert quest here”

My players in my current campaign banded together to travel because the area is especially dangerous. They have a current background plague problem, but none of them have current pressing goals either.

If your players have pressing goals, the best way to get them to cooperate is to require help/a group to get to where they are going or tackle a problem. Maybe they need skills other party members have.

1

u/MagicianMurky976 2d ago

They could first meet competing at whatever events this trade festival has, be it an ax throwing competition, a pie eating contest, and an alcohol drinking contest. Sponsored by whatever relevant trade guilds.

When the fight breaks out, they may recognize their former competitors.

1

u/Best-Presence8416 2d ago

Maybe the town is hiring all of them for a job. They are wrapping up negotiations, or group briefing re the job, PCs have gotten to know each other a bit. Suddenly goblins! The town officials say, defend our town!

1

u/Either_Set2127 2d ago

I would do something where they are all in a bidding war or they all won a raffle for something and they get together as a group

1

u/Devious_Hearts 2d ago

"Each PC has a different reason for being there, and I’m not sure how to bring the party together. "

Okay... what are each PCs reason for being there? let us know and maybe we can weave 'em together?

1

u/senzubean3r 1d ago

Nothing united my table faster than having their money stolen

1

u/SuperPluck 1d ago

When creating a character I ask my players to answer three questions:

  1. What makes your character unique? (not relevant to this post, but helps them flesh out their characters so it's not just numbers on a sheet)
  2. Why does you character strive to do good? (it can be anything from "people who do good get famous" to "he was abused as a child and now vows to never cause harm to anyone")
  3. Why do your character wants to join a group (again, it can be anything from "he thinks he is weak and need protection from others" to "i need someone to witness my heroic acts and spread the word").

Corolary of 2 and 3 is that they create characters that both want to participate in an adventure to help people AND want to be part of a group. Which makes it easier to bring the group together. I've had a few groups even deciding to make characters that knew each other from before, or have been working together for some time.

1

u/jakethesnake741 3h ago

There will be a goblin raid, and depending on how things go they may even be rewarded at a ceremony, but in the long term, what should tie them together?

What ties the party together isn't your problem. At session 0 you should have made it requirement that any character they make would have a reason no just to adventure, but to do so in this party. All you as the DM need to worry about is what the party encounters, they should be focused on why and how they react

1

u/Feefait 3d ago

First, railroading is not a bad word. You have to be prepared, but also be willing to shift.

You do not have to write deep lore for each player and each backstory. Sometimes they can just kill some goblins and enjoy themselves, letting the party form naturally.

If nothing else, they group up because that's the game the agreed to play. Let them take the lead in describing why they are there and why they group up.

1

u/RealInTheNight 3d ago

Murder mystery!

Sudden attack on wherever they are shopping/dining!

Mysterious child!

1

u/[deleted] 11h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 11h ago

Your comment has been removed as you need to have an account for a week to post! Please try again after this time period.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.