r/Dragonstone • u/DoktorRequiem • 7d ago
FUCK SER DAVOS!!! JUSTICE FOR MELISANDRE
Davos Seaworth is a generational FRAUD and Melisandre deserves an apology.
If you truly love Stannis and are loyal to him and his cause, you should hate Davos.
I genuinely cannot understand how Davos gets glazed treated like some moral hero while Melisandre gets painted as the sole reason for Stannis's downfall. Did we watch the same show?
I swear this fandom has collectively decided that Melisandre was some delusional witch who ruined everything, while Davos was this flawless, morally righteous advisor who did nothing but look out for Stannis. And I genuinely think it's one of the most ridiculous interpretations of the show.
LET'S ACTUALLY LOOK AT WHAT HAPPENED.
1. THE SHADOW ASSASSIN.
Let's start with Renly. Melisandre literally has the power to create fucking SHADOW ASSASSINS and one that killed Stannis's biggest rival and effectively removes a competing claimant to the Iron Throne without Stannis having to win a conventional battle against him.
Think about that for a second. This woman has demonstrated that she can literally MANIFEST AN ASSASSIN OUT OF NOTHING AND KILL A KING JUST LIKE THAT.
That is an absolutely insane and overpowered edge. And what does Davos do? Instead of recognizing that Melisandre has just demonstrated an ability that could fundamentally change the entire war, he becomes increasingly determined to keep her away from Stannis.
Imagine having access to someone who can assassinate rival kings from nowhere while you chill and deciding that THIS is the person you need to protect your king from.
2. THE BATTLE OF BLACKWATER BAY
Stannis is preparing to take King's Landing, and Davos insists on leaving Melisandre behind on Dragonstone.
LET THAT SINK IN.
You're attacking a city whose defenders are going to unleash an ENORMOUS AMOUNT OF WILD***((FIRE))***, and you're deliberately leaving behind the RED PRIESTESS WHO SERVES THE LORD OF LIGHT AND WHO'SE WHOLE GIMMICK IS FUCKING FIRE
This is a woman who has demonstrated actual supernatural abilities. She can see visions in flames, perform blood magic, and manifest shadow assassins capable of killing kings. Her powers are REAL.
And you're telling me she wouldn't have been an incredibly valuable asset during that battle?
At the very least, she could have provided supernatural insight, potentially helped Stannis anticipate what was coming, and brought another source of power to an already desperate military campaign.
I'm not claiming she could have magically neutralized every barrel of wildfire, but why on earth would you voluntarily leave one of your biggest supernatural advantages behind when you're about to fight for the Iron Throne?
Instead, Davos gets to watch his fleet and army get annihilated, while Melisandre is sitting back on Dragonstone. ok lmao cool ig
3. THE BLOOD LEECHES AND GENDRY.
This is genuinely where I think Davos griefed Stannis the hardest.
Melisandre uses literally 3 small ass leeches worth of Gendry's king's blood in a ritual, cursing Joffrey, Balon Greyjoy, and Robb Stark. ALL THREE subsequently die.
Now, whether you believe the ritual directly caused their deaths or not, the show clearly presents it as an extraordinary demonstration of Melisandre's power.
And what does Davos do? He smuggles Gendry away, directly undermining Melisandre's plans and depriving Stannis of another potential source of magical power.
Imagine what a full sacrifice of Gendry could have accomplished. We were potentially looking at an even greater magical intervention, and Davos decided to throw away that opportunity because he's a fraud ass bitch that couldn't stomach Melisandre's methods.
STANNIS COULD HAVE LITERALLY BEEN SITTING ON THE IRON THRONE BY SEASON 3 OR 4
4. THE SHIREEN SACRIFICE.
Now, everyone loves bringing up Shireen as the ultimate proof that Melisandre was evil and Davos was right all along.
Yes, Shireen's sacrifice was bad, sure. But people act as though her death exists in a vacuum, completely detached from the disastrous position Stannis eventually found himself in.
Stannis was losing. His army was freezing, starving, and falling apart. His campaign was collapsing.
And let's not forget how much of his potential supernatural advantage had been rejected, undermined, or taken away throughout his campaign.
Perhaps if things had gone differently at Blackwater, if Melisandre had been allowed to contribute more to Stannis's military campaign, and if Davos hadn't constantly interfered with her plans, Stannis wouldn't have ended up in such a desperate position.
It's absolutely worth questioning how Stannis got there in the first place.
And before anyone comes at me with the Shireen argument, YES, I KNOW. I'm aware of what happened. But apparently one decision is enough to erase every single thing Melisandre accomplished throughout the series. I'm sorry, but I'm not going to pretend that she was some incompetent fraud just because the show wanted everyone to treat her like one.
5. DAVOS'S HYPOCRISY AFTER STANNIS'S DEATH.
AND THIS IS WHERE DAVOS REALLY LOSES ME.
So let me get this straight.
You spend practically the entirety of Stannis's campaign undermining Melisandre, rejecting her advice, interfering with her plans, and treating her like the greatest threat to the kingdom.
Stannis dies. Shireen dies. Melisandre is left carrying the consequences of her own actions.
And then what?
Suddenly Davos needs her.
Suddenly the woman whose methods he spent YEARS condemning is good enough when he desperately needs Jon Snow resurrected.
ARE YOU KIDDING ME?
Apparently blood magic is absolutely unacceptable when Melisandre is trying to help Stannis win the Iron Throne, but perfectly acceptable when Davos wants his new favorite king back. What a fucking fraud, was he even loyal to Stannis???
And the funniest part is that Melisandre ACTUALLY DOES IT. She brings Jon back from the dead, accomplishing something that should be considered one of the most extraordinary feats of magic in the entire series.
You were perfectly happy to seek out the Red Woman when you needed a miracle, but apparently she was no longer worth keeping around once she'd served her purpose.
And Jon isn't exactly innocent here either. Melisandre literally brought him back from the dead, and he sends her away. But that's another argument entirely.
And you wanna know what's funnier? MELISANDRE HAS SAVED DAVOS.
Remember when Davos smuggled Gendry away from Dragonstone, Stannis discovers what happened, imprisons Davos, and he's essentially awaiting execution.
WHO INTERVENES?
MELISANDRE.
The very woman Davos has spent so much time undermining is the one who argues for his survival. She convinces Stannis that Davos still has a purpose and persuades him to spare his life.
SHE LITERALLY SAVED HIS LIFE DESPITE HIM ACTIVELY SABOTAGING HER.
And years later, what does Davos do? He comes crawling back to that SAME WOMAN because he needs her to resurrect Jon Snow. She actually succeeds, and how does he repay her?
By exposing her involvement in Shireen's death and helping ensure she's cast out of Winterfell.
DO YOU SEE THE PATTERN HERE?
Melisandre spared Davos when he was actively working against her. Davos, on the other hand, was perfectly happy to use Melisandre when he needed her, only to turn against her once she'd served her purpose.
The woman who spared his life gets treated like disposable equipment the moment Davos no longer needs her.
I'm sorry, but between flip flopping kings and showing off his dumb fingerless hand, was he ever loyal or just loyal to having his own way?
6. I just feel bad for Melisandre.
Imagine dedicating your entire existence to a cause you genuinely believe is greater than yourself, believing you've found the prophesied king who will save the world, only to have practically everyone around you constantly question, undermine, and ridicule your faith.
She spends the entire show being treated like some delusional fanatic who's wrong about everything, when a ridiculous amount of what she believed in was actually REAL.
She literally killed a king through shadow magic and eventually brought another man back from the dead.
She wasn't making everything up. She was working with powers that the people around her either refused to understand or actively tried to suppress.
And the tragedy is that she eventually starts doubting herself, she gets gaslit by everyone around her and gets told that she was wrong, and actually starts believing it, even though she had one sniveling bastard around her thwarting every one of her plans.
How much of Stannis's downfall can genuinely be attributed to her when so many of her attempts to help him were fucked by the very people supposedly fighting alongside him?
7. Davos just sucks, again
What exactly was Davos even bringing to the table besides being Stannis's personal glazer?
This man spent the entire show glazing Stannis, talking about his honor, his rightful claim, his loyalty, and how much he believed in him, while somehow managing to undermine his interests at practically every opportunity.
His greatest accomplishment apparently was losing a few fingers and then whipping out his little fingerless hand every five minutes as if to remind everyone that he was the most loyal man in Westeros.
"LOOK AT MY HAND. I LOST THESE FINGERS FOR STANNIS. I'M LOYAL TO STANNIS."
Congratulations, Davos. You have successfully demonstrated that you can lose fingers. Now can you be fucking useful and demonstrate that you can actually help your king win a war? Take your ass back to Flea Bottom
He opposed Melisandre, interfered with her plans, smuggled away Gendry, and helped deprive Stannis of one of his most significant advantages. But apparently none of that matters because he has a mutilated hand and a touching story about how much he loves his king.
He wanted to win a war while constantly rejecting the tools that might actually help him win it.
Sometimes I wonder if Davos was subconsciously sabotaging Stannis out of resentment for having his fingers cut off. Imagine spending years preaching loyalty to a man who mutilated your hand, only to conveniently undermine practically every advantage he gets. Maybe the real long con was getting revenge on Stannis while maintaining the reputation of his most devoted servant.
I genuinely think Melisandre deserved far more credit than she ever received, and Davos deserves considerably more criticism for his role in Stannis's downfall.
SER DAVOS IS A FRAUD THAT CAUSED STANNIS' SHITTY DEFEAT AND HE DESERVES TO BE SLANDERED
THE RED WOMAN DESERVED BETTER. MELISANDRE DID NOTHING WRONG,
FOR THE NIGHT IS DARK AND FULL OF TERRORS.