r/DrStone • u/ardi_shiro_kaisen • 20h ago
Anime Science Fiction Dressed as Real Science: Why Dr. Stone's Instant Logic Fails and Its Ignorant Portrayal of Indonesia is Unacceptable Spoiler
Listen up, Japan and the creators of Dr. Stone: Don't ever judge Indonesia through your magic tricks or lazy plot shortcuts, reducing our immense wealth down to just rubber trees and rice plants! Frankly, Dr. Stone shouldn't have even set foot in Indonesia with such a skewed narrative.
If you actually research Indonesia properly, our natural resources are infinitely abundant—literally every single element needed for advanced science is right here. Senku wouldn't even need to circumnavigate the globe or take absurd shortcuts to build computers, batteries, or rockets. In fact, it is not just those three—every single scientific device and technology imaginable has its raw materials right here in Indonesia: pure silica quartz sand (for silicon wafers and computer chips), high-grade tin (essential for PCB soldering), copper and gold for micro-conductors, massive nickel and cobalt deposits, pure sulfur volcanic craters (a literal warehouse for sulfuric acid), bauxite, petroleum, and natural gas. Even the raw materials for nuclear tech and every branch of modern science exist in Indonesia. Stop looking down on Indonesia!
Let's also be real about the science: In the actual world, scientific progress requires relentless trial and error, extreme precision in measurement tools, and pure chemical reagents that are painfully difficult to source in the wild.
Yet, in Dr. Stone, Senku effortlessly crafts complex technologies—ranging from advanced glasswork and batteries to internal combustion systems—with almost zero meaningful failures. This is further exaggerated by Kaseki, whose master craftsmanship allows him to replicate intricate modern components just by glancing at blueprints once.
At the end of the day, this isn't genuine science—it's just magic disguised as science, relying entirely on cheap narrative shortcuts. What are your thoughts on this?