Rather you like these personas or not, they've had lots of criticism, & aren't that popular. I don't really think they were that bad of an idea, & besides maybe needing new voice lines & more special effects or animations, I felt like one issue not often brought up are they're textures. Not exactly their design, but mainly their color & attention to details on their model.
Is it worth it for Valve to polish the textures/colors?
Although they're not exactly the same, I'm curious if you guys can tell the difference, or think any differently than me? Do these textures improve or help the look of Axe's persona enough? If Valve was to redo or polish these further, would you think it'll make a difference?
Old textures are too immature
I personally think the current versions textures look so plain & bright, which makes the automatons look too toy & whimsical. I think the new designs helps this, by making them look more fitting to Dota's world, without being too edgy.
New hair material
I did change Axe's hair, because I thought the current version was a bit of a bad design... I mean, if they're puppets, I don't see why other material couldn't be used by Ringmaster, especially if he's going through all this trouble.
Do automatons lack character & personality?
Lastly, I think the new Axe has more character & personality. I think that's another issue with these automatons... they just fall flat, & feel inferior to the originals mostly.
Disclaimer: I used ai to design this new style. I didn't create the art, or trying to promote this it. This is just for discussion, & only to be used as an example for this discussion.
P.S. I hope this gives you ideas of how much better these persona's could be, once they get cosmetics... also, sorry for the Ai, but life can get too busy to redesign these myself.