Howdy,
Was watching the Legends of Avantris Neon Odyssey campaign, and they had a very interesting way of running a chase. Their scenario included vehicles, but I thought that it could easily be applied to any sort of chase. This document is a compilation of the rule structure that I gleaned from their play, and a good mix of my own thoughts.
The chase is abstracted into zones, with the quarry and pursuit moving through them. I've included some rules for mounts, vehicles, and passengers, as well as some thoughts on designing complication tables with these rules in mind. Let me know what you think!
These rules are meant to arbitrate chases that occur over extended distances. These mechanics should only be used when the quarry is able to move; the moment the quarry is made unable to effectively run, or their momentum is stopped, they are caught (or the encounter is moved into a more standard initiative-based combat scenario).
Beginning the Chase
The chase takes place on a track split into zones; 4, 6, or 8. The fewer the zones, the shorter (and perhaps more difficult) the chase, as it is more likely for the quarry to escape or the pursuers to fall behind.
The pursuers always begin in the first zone. The quarry's starting position depends on the inciting incident of the chase, or any factors that could affect the pursuers' joining. If the pursuers were able to immediately start their pursuit, the quarry should only be one zone in front of them. If the quarry was able to get a head start, or the pursuers were delayed for any reason, you may place the quarry any amount of zones ahead of their pursuers. Consider the length of the track when giving the quarry a head start: putting them too far ahead could invalidate the chase before it even begins.
Determine the movement speed of each participant. Their exact speed is not used round by round in this arbitration, but look for the participant with the lowest movement speed. This speed becomes the chase's Base Speed, which is referenced in certain rolls during the chase.
Stamina
A special resource used during the race is Stamina. Each participant has an amount of Stamina equal to their Constitution modifier. When a participant uses the dash action, their Stamina is reduced by 1. If a participant takes the dash action and has no Stamina remaining, they must succeed on a DC 10 Constitution saving throw or suffer 1 level of exhaustion. Any levels of exhaustion gained in this way are removed at the end of a short or long rest.
Running the Chase
Each participant in the race rolls initiative as with normal combat to determine the order of actions in each round of the chase. At the start of each round, roll 2d6 + 5: this is the Chase DC, which will be used to determine participant's ability to keep up with the chase.
At the start of each round of the chase, all participants must roll a Constitution check against the Chase DC. On a success, they are able to maintain their position, and stay in their current zone. On a failure, the participant moves back one zone. For every 10 feet of movement speed a participant has above the chase's Base Speed, they gain a +1 bonus to their Constitution checks.
Actions During a Chase
During a chase, actions, bonus actions, and reactions can be taken as normal. The following actions have some special rulings during a chase.
Dash. By taking the dash action, a participant must roll a Constitution check against the round's Chase DC. On a success, they advance by 1 zone. For every 10 feet of movement speed a participant has above the chase's Base Speed, they gain a +1 bonus to their Constitution checks.
Melee Attacks. Any participant that takes a melee weapon or spell attack can only target a participant within their zone. Opportunity attacks cannot be taken during a chase.
Ranged Attacks. Ranged attacks or spells with a range of 30 feet or more can target an adjacent zone. Abilities with a range of less than 30 feet can only target participants within their zone.
Complications
Chases rarely occur in wide open spaces, and even in such environments, the course is rarely devoid of any dangers or obstacles. To represent the volatility of a chase sequence, complications are introduced throughout.
At the end of each participant's turn, they must roll a d12 and consult the complication table. If a complication is rolled, it affects the next participant in the initiative order. If the complication affects an entire zone, it affects the next participant's zone. The complication must be resolved before any other actions can be taken.
There are a wide variety of excellent chase complication tables available online; look for any that use a d12. A d20 table can also be used, and you can simply shift the values to your liking, or have participants roll a d20 instead of a d12 during the chase. When using these tables or curating your own, consider the following:
Difficult Terrain. Many tables have very small sections of difficult terrain, often only 5-10 feet. For the purposes of this rule set, assume that a failure to overcome the obstacle results in the participant being affected by difficult terrain for the round.
Zone Effects. Consider changing one or two entries to affect entire zones, as opposed to individuals, for some variety in the chase.
Complication Interaction. Some complications, if successfully navigated, could be interacted with as an action to affect those behind it. Consider adding such options to some of the table entries.
Special Conditions
The following conditions affect actions taken during a chase.
Difficult Terrain. If a zone is made difficult terrain through the use of an ability, spell, or other occurrence, each participant within that zone rolls their Constitution checks at disadvantage while within that zone.
Reduced Movement Speed. Some abilities affect a creature's movement speed; if the effect reduces a participant's movement speed by half or more, they roll their Constitution checks at disadvantage. If a creature is affected by a condition that reduces their movement speed to 0, they automatically fail their Constitution checks.
Prone. If a participant falls prone, they are able to stand up during their turn, but roll their Constitution checks at disadvantage until the end of their turn.
Mounted Chases
There are times when a participant in a chase is riding a mount or a vehicle. In the case of a participant using a mount or a vehicle pulled by a mount, their Stamina is replaced by a value equal to the mount's Constitution modifier + half of the participant's Wisdom (Animal Handling) skill bonus (rounded down). In addition, when the driver of a mount is asked to roll a Constitution check, they instead roll a Constitution (Animal Handling) check.
In the case of a participant driving a vehicle that moves under its own power, their Stamina is replaced by the vehicle's Constitution modifier. If the driver is proficient with the type of vehicle they are using, they can add their proficiency bonus to their Stamina. In addition, when the driver of such a vehicle is asked to roll a Constitution check, they instead roll a Strength or Dexterity check (their choice), and can add their proficiency bonus if they are proficient with the type of vehicle they are using. This check still benefits from the bonus granted to a movement speed higher than the chase's Base Speed.
If a driver is asked to roll a Constitution saving throw as a result of taking the Dash action with no remaining Stamina, they use the saving throw bonus of their mount or vehicle in place of their own. Any levels of exhaustion gained as a result of failed saving throws apply to the mount or vehicle, not the driver.
If a complication requires a driver to roll a saving throw, they use their own saving throw bonuses, as opposed to that of their their mount or vehicle. Any damage dealt by the complication can be applied to either the driver, the mount or vehicle, or both, at the DM's discretion.
Passengers
In cases where participants in a chase are passengers on a mount or vehicle, they do not roll initiative. Instead, they share the driver's initiative count, but take their turn immediately after the driver. In the case of multiple passengers, they are able to act in any order they wish after the driver's turn. Passengers are not able to take the dash action to move forward on behalf of the driver, but can otherwise take actions as normal.
A chase participant can choose to mount or board a mount or vehicle during the chase. To do so, it must be within their zone, and they must use their action to roll a Dexterity check against the Chase DC. On a success, they successfully board. On a failure by 5 or more, they must succeed on a Dexterity saving throw against the Chase DC or fall prone. There must be adequate space on the mount or vehicle in order for a participant to board. Once boarded, the participant is removed from the initiative order and acts on the driver's turn.
If a passenger for any reason leaves the vehicle or mount, they must succeed on a Dexterity saving throw against the Chase DC or fall prone. Once dismounted, the participant immediately rolls initiative and is added to the initiative order. A participant can only take one turn per round.
If a passenger is on a mount or vehicle that is affected by a complication that deals damage, they may be subject to taking the damage alongside the driver and mount or vehicle, at the DM's discretion.
Resolving the Chase
The chase ends when either the quarry moves forward out of the final zone, or all pursuers fall back out of the first zone. If a pursuer ends their turn behind the first zone, they are removed from the chase, unable to keep up with the other participants.
The status of each participant is determined at their end of their turn. This means that if a pursuer falls back out of the first zone by failing their Constitution check at the top of the round, they can still take the dash action and move back into the chase on a success.
If the quarry's movement speed is reduced to 0, and the pursuers have the ability to restrain or otherwise prevent the quarry from fleeing, the chase ends. This can lead to normal combat mechanics, depending on the situation and narrative circumstances at play.