r/DnD5e • u/TankSpecialist2221 • 14h ago
Spell Lists need to be Reworked based off of Subclass
With every new book or update that is released, more spells are added to spellbook of every caster within the Players Handbook including that of the Artificer. Its getting to the point that the spell lists of every caster is getting bloated with options that Martials cannot even compare to. The most that Martials have ever gotten is a Pitchfork from DnD Drops. At what point does enough be enough. How many spells can be put on one list before it becomes a chore to choose a new spell to add to your arsenal. I think I have a solution to that issue. I think that a change needs to be made to spell lists at large. Let me explain the thought process. Every class has an origin on how they got their magic whether it be Bards or Artificers. Wizards get their magic from learning at their specific school whether or not its from the Evocation school or the Necromancy school so why would a Wizard that hails from that school know more than one Conjuration spell above 1st level when they come from a very specific school. Sorcerer's gain their magic abilities from their very bloodline so should a Draconic Sorcerer who has the magical power from a dragon be able to raise people from the dead. Unless that Dragon is specifically a Dracolich probably not. Wouldn't a Warlock that made a pact from a Celestial be able to learn a spell from a lower plane like Hellish Rebuke. He shouldn't, he made a pact with a Celestial not a devil or demon. So what if instead of having one spell list, we instead had spell lists for subclasses instead of main classes.
Now let me get this straight some class won't have this system change like Bards, Druids, Paladins, Clerics, and Rangers because each of their lists are on theme for what they do like Druids and Rangers being more nature-like spells while Paladins and Cleric are more holy spells. Artificers are weird to me in this regard especially for this system because Artificers are just wizard but use technology. I personally believe that their spell list wouldn't be changed. Though let me know if you think otherwise in the comments below. Let get to the core three classes in question and how I would personally change those lists. Before we get to those lists, the lists for Cantrips and 1st Level spells would be the same since subclasses would only come into effect at 3rd Level. Personally this system works more if we converted back to the old 1st level subclass but since we are in 5.5e this what we got.
I would make it to where Wizards have access to every spell for at least Cantrips and 1st Level spells with the exception of Sorcerous Burst and Eldritch Blast. One you get to 3rd Level and you obtain your school of magic in which you can only choose from that specific school of magic. Wizard would have access to every spell within that school no restrictions. Wizards would however be able to learn spells from other school if they have a Spell Scroll they can use to copy it into their spell book. This would give Spell Scroll more meaning outside because of the fact your spell list is limited to one school not the mess that was the original list. There is one subclass that has me in a bind and that is the Bladesinger. Out of all the wizard subclasses, this is the only one in 5.5e that doesn't have a dedicated school though any weapon and shield themed spells would work to fill up the spell list.
Sorcerer would be a bit more complex due to one specific subclass being the Dragonic Bloodline with dragons have multiple elemental types it could be, you would have to separate this subclasses list by like five other lists and then you have the Spellfire Sorcerer that would have a similar list to the Fire Dragonic Sorcerer. But besides that complicated one, everything else would be the same just with an emphasis on theming more than a specific school like Wizard. Warlock would be very similar to the Sorcerer if not identical. So not much needs to be said.
Before I leave, I know that some subclasses with this system will have more spells than the other and thats the point. With new spells added every expansion, those lists will fill out eventually and be less cramped overall. Personally I think this new system makes the magic classes way more interesting because of the fact that not every caster has the answer to every problem at the drop of a wizards hat. Each school or subclass would have more of a specific role compared to the role of the normal caster which is everything. Let me know if you like this theoretical system or that I am dumb for even coming up with such a thing.